News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Amanda Knox Test: How an Hour on the Internet Beats a... by davidw on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:52AM (#993892)
I think they were involved in it, but doesn't a murder conviction usually require proof that person X actually did the killing? Otherwise it's accessory to murder or something.

BTW, what a lot of people are saying in Italy is that she'll probably be let off on appeal.

Re:The Amanda Knox Test: How an Hour on the Internet Beats a... by patio11 on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:11AM (#993954)
I think they were involved in it, but doesn't a murder conviction usually require proof that person X actually did the killing?

That depends on your jurisdiction. I'm not familiar with Italy, but most U.S. states and the federal government do not require actually personally causing death as an element of the crime of murder. If you're a) engaged in the commission of a felony (sometimes, an enumerated list of "really bad felonies") and b) someone dies with cause proximate to the felony you're committing, you just earned yourself a murder charge, regardless of who pulled the trigger. This is called "felony murder". The most common use case is suspects A, B, and C attempt armed robbery on D, D dies in the attempt, and A, B, and C each admit to the robbery but not to the killing. Absent the felony murder theory, you might have to sift through confusing physical evidence and unreliable testimony of self-interested shady characters. With felony murder, your options are simpler: charge 'em all.

Re:The Amanda Knox Test: How an Hour on the Internet Beats a... by DenisM on Monday December 14, 2009 @08:47PM (#995621)
I think there is another reason for this practice:

Imagine that one criminal has good leadership skills and is able to manipulate another, weaker criminal. He could then convince the weaker criminal to pull the trigger and escape consequences himself, and then do it again and again with different weak criminals. By sharing the blame the system compels the leader, whoever he is, to restrain the underlings rather than push them to the extreme.

Re:The Amanda Knox Test: How an Hour on the Internet Beats a... by davidw on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:43AM (#993979)
Ah ok, that's what I was looking for...
Re:The Amanda Knox Test: How an Hour on the Internet Beats a... by NikkiA on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:16AM (#993955)
"doesn't a murder conviction usually require proof that person X actually did the killing?"

No. Murder, and Rape, commonly promote the crime from conspiracy/accomplice to the full crime (murder, rape). Presumably because the stakes are so high for these types of crime, and traditional sentencing for 'accomplice to...' or 'conspiracy to commit' cases is so much lower, that people could game the justice system somewhat.

For example, if you hire a hitman to take out your wife/husband, you WILL be tried as the murderer, as will the hitman. If you conspire with a lover to kill someone, you will be tried as a murderer, no matter who is holding the murder weapon.

Perhaps it's different in America, although I'm sure there have been cases I've heard about in the US that fall under the same rules as those above, and where the conspirators were tried as murderers themselves.

Re:The Amanda Knox Test: How an Hour on the Internet Beats a... by davidw on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:42AM (#993976)
I'm not talking about conspiracy to kill someone, but about a situation like this: say 4 or 5 guys are picking on someone outside a bar, hitting him and so on. One of them pulls out a knife and kills the guy. No one talks. It's obvious that someone in the group killed him (let's say there was a camera or something that recorded things, but not well enough to pick out the killer). Do they all get a murder charge? I honestly don't know. It's evident they're all guilty of something, but only one of them is a murderer.
Re:The Amanda Knox Test: How an Hour on the Internet Beats a... by NikkiA on Monday December 14, 2009 @07:27AM (#994013)
Most places in the world, they would all be tried for murder. And the fact that noone talks about who did it, IS conspiracy.

Edited to clarify that I meant to point out two issues rather than one.