Regarding these points: - Eye witness putting all 3 suspects together outside the cottage that night, and the night previous.
- Knox and Sollecito standing outside the crime scene when the police arrived with mop and bucket.
From what I read these were given by unreliable sources (drunk homeless man)
The police comes out pretty tainted in my opinion and it seems they were eager to find scapegoats early in the investigation.
Also, I don't find a clear motive for Knox/Sollecito. Not participating in a sex orgy?? It seems more probable that Guede raped and then murdered the victim. Also, in the initial testimony guede doesn't mention Knox or Sollecito being involved
I will reply to your points in turn, but to be clear, I'm not specifically arguing for or against the conviction; I'm saying that this article grossly ignores many of the facts of the case.
It appears that large parts of the American media have painted this case as some loon prosecutor bent on convicting an American girl with flimsy flawed evidence and a fanciful idea of some Satanic sexy orgy gone wrong. There's been a lot of column inches devoted to discussing some of the things this article breaks down (the strange behaviour, the telephone calls). I can understand the media focusing on this (it's what the public find interesting, not the detailed crime scene details). But as this article is about digging for information and applying reasonable thought, it's disappointing they chose to ignore the large body of evidence presented at the trial that lead to their conviction.
To your counterpoints:
1. If I recall, there is good (not the drunk homeless man) eyewitness testimony of the 3 meeting prior to the night in question.
- There is fair amount of DNA evidence (see my parent post, and the links). Yes, some may appear potentially flawed (e.g. bra clasp). However the judge considered and admitted the evidence. Consider that a panel of legal experts considered and unanimously convicted based on this evidence.
- From truejustice.org regarding evidence of a cleanup: "The ONLY fingerprints of Amanda Knox in the entire house were found on a glass in the kitchen. Even in her own room there was not one print."
- Yes, the eyewitness isn't great. But again, the evidence was admitted by the judge for reasons given in the judge's summary.
- The police themselves were the eyewitnesses to them being at the crime scene with mop and bucket.
- Whether the police appear tainted is worth considering, but doesn't explain away a body of hard evidence that was admitted in court.
- Your theory that Guede was a lone-wolf rape and murderer was quickly dismissed by the judge, given the huge body of physical evidence suggesting other people involved (again, see my post and the report).
edit:
This is a great link that goes over some of your points (motive, DNA evidence etc:
http://truejustice.org/ee/index.php?/tjmk/comments/how_the_m...
http://www.truejustice.org/ee/index.php?/tjmk/comments/under... http://www.truejustice.org/ee/index.php?/tjmk/comments/under... http://www.truejustice.org/ee/index.php?/tjmk/comments/under... http://www.truejustice.org/ee/index.php?/tjmk/comments/under...
I live near Leeds, where Ms Kercher was from, and the local media has been very detailed about the hard evidence, and painted the case in a way that has been very hard to misunderstand.
Now, admittedly the local media is likely biased as well, just in the opposite way to perhaps the American media has reported this case. But I wasn't aware there was this reporting of Ms Knox as being utterly innocent. If anything, it was clear from the reporting I've seen that she's a sociopath/psychopath trying to manipulate the court with her 'I'm soooo innocent' act.
I don't think the quantitative probability analysis of the Less Wrong thread is that meaningful in the semantics of the analysis itself, but I think it shows that a reasonable person would have a qualitative reasonable doubt about the murder.
I'm not sure the relevance of them being allowed to lie in court; no one is suggested they have committed perjury.
BTW, what a lot of people are saying in Italy is that she'll probably be let off on appeal.
That depends on your jurisdiction. I'm not familiar with Italy, but most U.S. states and the federal government do not require actually personally causing death as an element of the crime of murder. If you're a) engaged in the commission of a felony (sometimes, an enumerated list of "really bad felonies") and b) someone dies with cause proximate to the felony you're committing, you just earned yourself a murder charge, regardless of who pulled the trigger. This is called "felony murder". The most common use case is suspects A, B, and C attempt armed robbery on D, D dies in the attempt, and A, B, and C each admit to the robbery but not to the killing. Absent the felony murder theory, you might have to sift through confusing physical evidence and unreliable testimony of self-interested shady characters. With felony murder, your options are simpler: charge 'em all.
Imagine that one criminal has good leadership skills and is able to manipulate another, weaker criminal. He could then convince the weaker criminal to pull the trigger and escape consequences himself, and then do it again and again with different weak criminals. By sharing the blame the system compels the leader, whoever he is, to restrain the underlings rather than push them to the extreme.
No. Murder, and Rape, commonly promote the crime from conspiracy/accomplice to the full crime (murder, rape). Presumably because the stakes are so high for these types of crime, and traditional sentencing for 'accomplice to...' or 'conspiracy to commit' cases is so much lower, that people could game the justice system somewhat.
For example, if you hire a hitman to take out your wife/husband, you WILL be tried as the murderer, as will the hitman. If you conspire with a lover to kill someone, you will be tried as a murderer, no matter who is holding the murder weapon.
Perhaps it's different in America, although I'm sure there have been cases I've heard about in the US that fall under the same rules as those above, and where the conspirators were tried as murderers themselves.
Edited to clarify that I meant to point out two issues rather than one.
http://lesswrong.com/lw/1j7/the_amanda_knox_test_how_an_hour...
On the other hand, http://knoxarchives.blogspot.com/2009/12/magical-bra-strap-f...
- 4 mixed DNA samples of the Knox and Kercher. Bloody footprints that match. Blood on the tap put Knox at the crime scene that evening or in the early morning.
- A bloody bra in the washing machine
- Attempts to frame an innocent man for the crime.
- Repeated lying to authorities regarding her whereabouts. Still no fixed alibi.
- Knox and Kercher's house was cleaned with bleach.
- Sollecito's trainers were cleaned with bleach. A defect in the sole match a blood print on the scene.
The decision went through going through 19 expert judges and 6 lay judges. Conviction was unanimous.
Certainly, we can ignore some of the strange behaviour of the convicted (the phone calls, the lies, her past). But the case is much stronger than what this article makes out.
This is an English translation of the judge's summary:
http://www.zimbio.com/Amanda+Knox/articles/58/Understanding+...
Other links:
http://truejustice.org/ee/index.php?/tjmk/comments/how_the_m...
http://www.truejustice.org/ee/index.php?/tjmk/comments/why_d...
http://truejustice.org/ee/index.php?/tjmk/comments/highlight...
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article36...
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/feb/08/kercher-trial-kn...
edit: I left out a few other key points to the prosecutions case:
- Eye witness putting all 3 suspects together outside the cottage that night, and the night previous.
- Knox and Sollecito standing outside the crime scene when the police arrived with mop and bucket.
Rational thought takes anyone first to the conclusion that there was more than one killer. Guede left the scene soon after the murder (eye witness reports; evidence of cleaning, Guede's own statement). It is clear the crime scene was later returned to, and altered to cover evidence (faked break-in; footprints; removal of bra from the body). With all the additional evidence against Knox and Sollecito, physical and circumstantial, clear motive, and consitantly irrational behaviour, gives a very strong prosecution case.
This article touches on little of these facts.