If you're going to make accusations like this, at least have the stomach to put your name behind it.
Baseless accusations of shillage are not allowed on Hacker News. Insinuation à la concern troll is a form of this. Please don't do it again.
Everything I said has been perfectly straightforward and honest.
Downvote brigades are usually only a thing on Reddit, but I experience them here occasionally.
The OP claimed you were a shill - I questioned whether you were paid. I said maybe you were just in the circle or bought into the narrative.
The OP had said that tptacek was a shill. I defended tptacek by saying I didn't know that he was paid or whether he was just in the circle of security contractors (he is) or whether he merely bought into and was regurgitating their propaganda.
I did not call tptacek a shill nor make a baseless accusation. It's absolutely true that tptacek is a stalwart defender of public narrative. This is the base of OP (not baseless) of his calling tptacek a shill. I entertained the possibility that he wasn't paid or anything like that.
Anyway, this isn't really interesting content any more. I think the real shame is that the main topic was downvoted to oblivion where people will not see the comparison to the US. The information about Binney (that tptacek clearly showed he was noncharitably and polemically engaging) and Risen and others won't be seen.
That's okay. One battle at a time.
Thanks dang, for your help and attention.
Right, he was involved in insider trading. If you don't do anything illegal it's hard to blackmail you for it. That was the claim. Blackmail. Sure, he did something wrong(-ish).
Nacchio was one of several executives at a variety of companies charged with bilking shareholders out of tens of millions of dollars. The case against him appears to have been quite strong: he stipulated to a number of high-dollar sales of his stocks during times where he knew the price of Qwest's stock was going to crater.