News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by dudul on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @10:35AM (#9929862)
The title is a little misleading. She was never actually hired, just interviewed.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by elsherbini on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @10:52AM (#9929940)
Maybe the title changed since your comment, but 'recruited and rejected' means exactly that, interviewed and not hired.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by mephi5t0 on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:13AM (#9930075)
Down votes are incorrect.

Recruited means enlisted, hired. She was never hired, she was contacted by recruiters and interviewed. "Recruited" doesn't mean "contacted by recruiters" it means hired to do work. Recruiter - who hires/searches for "recruits". Recruit is a person that was recruited not contacted by a recruiter.

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by crazygringo on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:27AM (#9930167)
Not at any tech company I've ever worked at.

Recruiters contacting someone is the recruiting -- the reaching out, telling them what a great company it is, getting them in for an interview, and so on. It's expanding the funnel of interviewees.

Hiring is actually making an offer. That decision is made by different people higher up, and not the recruiter.

Maybe it's different at different companies or industries, but this is my whole experience with it across all sorts of companies in NYC.

(And in response to comment about the Merriam-Webster definition -- meanings change. Lots of tech lingo is different from dictionary definitions. You can say "let's offline this" in a meeting, and you won't find that definition in MW either.)

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @12:12PM (#9930487)
>> Not at any tech company I've ever worked at.

Well, there are grey areas to a lot of these words we're using in this discussion, as the meaning depends heavily on context and the background of the reader (or recipient).

>> Hiring is actually making an offer.

Is it? So when Github says "we're hiring", does that mean they're making an offer to everyone who contacts them? I tend to think most people will interpret that as "we're accepting applications for open positions".

Of course, if Github says "We're hiring Joe Smith", that's a completely different meaning because it's in a different context.

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by noja on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:29AM (#9930180)
The recruiters _are_ recruiting, but they have not recruited someone until that person is earning a salary.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by vonmoltke on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:39AM (#9930240)
No, at it's most strict they haven't recruited someone until the company makes an offer. You can be recruited by multiple groups simultaneously. Happens all the time in college sports.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @12:25PM (#9930588)
> No, at it's most strict they haven't recruited someone until the company makes an offer. You can be recruited by multiple groups simultaneously. Happens all the time in college sports.

Kinda depends on the context, doesn't it? The context can subtly change how the word is interpreted.

This is how I would interpret the various forms based on my own personal experience -- your interpretations may differ:

Recruiter is recruiting Joe -> Trying to hire Joe

Recruiter has recruited Joe -> Successfully hired Joe

Joe was recruited x times by Google --> Google tried to hire Joe x times

Joe was recruited x times by Google to do Y, Z --> Google assigned or hired Joe to do Y, Z x times

Joe is being recruited -> Someone is trying to hire Joe

Joe was being recruited by A, B, C -> A, B, C trying to hire Joe

We are recruiting Joe to be our representative for X -> Joe has been designated to be the representative

Joe was recruited by Company -> Joe was hired

Joe is a new recruit -> Joe is a new employee

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by plonh on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @12:46PM (#9930730)
These examples show that the language is ambiguous. Coders need to cope with that, not pretend English has a good spec.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by vonmoltke on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @01:37PM (#9931068)
This sub-discussion reminds me of the issues with the phrase "job offer". To native English speakers, it is generally taken to mean "company has offered to hire you with a certain compensation package". To non-native English speakers, particularly it seems continental Europeans, it is generally taken to mean "company has offered to consider you for a job" (as opposed to you approaching them).
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by richmarr on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @12:05PM (#9930434)
Down votes aren't incorrect because of the definition of 'recruited'.

Down votes are incorrect because downvoting someone merely because you disagree is the embodiment of confirmation bias.

That makes it the enemy of debate, and of reason itself.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias

(Cue a stream of people claiming the thread is off-topic as an attempt to rationalise their downvotes, or down-voting me with equally fallacious reasoning)

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by richmarr on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @05:54PM (#9932601)
...and downvotes. Pathetic guys, really pathetic.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by ectoplasm on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @05:58PM (#9932631)
pg said downvoting disagreement is fine.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by richmarr on Thursday July 23, 2015 @02:55AM (#9934354)
Well, I respectfully disagree, for the reasons already stated (like most of the on-topic replies to that comment). Even the ones that agreed with pg suggested other mechanics to make up for the down-sides of the current system.

At the start of an innovation or social change the majority opinion is wrong, almost by definition. By having a single reward metric, and then structuring your system so that minority opinions get punished, you're creating a culture that's less free-thinking and more monocultural than it should be.

I can totally understand pg not wanting to change it, after all, he has a day job, but I don't think his 'up is agreement so down should be disagreement because symmetry' argument is worth much as stated.

After all, simple agreement has no worthwhile attribute other than a count of those who agree. Disagreement on the other hand is completely different, there are thousands of reasons why you might disagree with anything but the simplest of comments. Simply recording disagreement as a number is meaningless.

Edit: (I upvoted you for bothering to engage and find a link rather than just downvoting)

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by ectoplasm on Thursday July 23, 2015 @05:28AM (#9934736)
I agree with you, I was just pointing out the rules. I try not to worry about the point system here too much. Usually I just upvote everybody who replies to me.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by informatimago on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:14AM (#9930078)
Nope. Not according to my understanding, and not according to dictionaries such as the Merriam-Webster:

recruit verb re·cruit \ri-ˈkrüt\

: to find suitable people and get them to join a company, an organization, the armed forces, etc.

: to form or build (a group, team, army, etc.) by getting people to join

: to persuade (someone) to join you in some activity or to help you

"Recruited" definitely means she was hired. She wasn't, she was only interviewed four times and not given a job offer each time.

Check her resume: https://www.linkedin.com/in/cherylfillekes

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by tzs on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @02:35PM (#9931440)
That is only a subset of current common widespread usage.

For example, high school athletes who receive offers from more than one school are often said to have been recruited by all the schools.

Some examples from Wikipedia articles:

Magic Johnson: "Although Johnson was recruited by several top-ranked colleges such as Indiana and UCLA, he decided to play close to home".

Fred VanFleet: "At Auburn High School in Rockford, Illinois, he was an All-State player who was mostly recruited by mid-major basketball programs".

Marcus Dupree: "Dupree was heavily recruited by the major college football programs, and during the final month of the recruiting period, his high school coach, Joe Wood, answered more than 100 phone calls a day from colleges".

Marcus Mariota: "He was recruited by Oregon, Hawaii, Memphis, Utah, Oregon State, Washington, Arizona, Notre Dame, UCLA and USC but was only offered a scholarship by Memphis and Oregon".

Chris Taylor: "He was recruited to play college baseball by the University of Virginia and the College of William & Mary".

I'm kind of surprised that dictionary has missed this. I'm even more surprised that other dictionaries I checked also missed this.

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by justizin on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:31AM (#9930196)
Could you possibly be focusing on a less important facet of what this discussion should be about?
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by dudul on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:39AM (#9930243)
It is important.

The title implies that she was actually hired and let go 4 times - which doesn't make sense and would be a very awkward story. Being interviewed 4 times and passed on is a completely different story.

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by clarky07 on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @12:02PM (#9930411)
handy you left one off d. to seek to enroll

The recruiter, recruited her to join google. just as coaches from many different schools might recruit an athlete. One does not in fact have to be successful to have recruited someone.

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by richmarr on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:57AM (#9930362)
or...

noun a person newly enlisted in the armed forces and not yet fully trained. • a new member of an organization or supporter of a cause.

Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by chapium on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:11AM (#9930063)
I would say it is misleading because it misses the entire point of the article. She's part of an age discrimination suit.
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by mkempe on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @11:15AM (#9930086)
added this qualifier to the title
Re:Woman recruited by Google four times and rejected, joins ... by dudul on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @10:39AM (#9929885)
What's this dumb downvote for? The title said she was recruited and let go 4 times which doesn't make any sense. The actual story is that she was interviewed 4 times and then ignored.