News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by acjohnson55 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @07:42AM (#9921531)
But what is a "real" particle anyway?
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by dvdkhlng on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @08:19AM (#9921666)
"real" particles are those that can leave the holodeck ([1]) "quasi-particles" vanish at the doorstep :)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodeck

PS: replace "holodeck" with "tantalum arsenide crystal" to yield a less off-topic comment.

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by tobias2014 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @11:25AM (#9922865)
What about strongly interacting theories? Are quarks and gluons quasi-particles then too? They can't leave the holodeck aka. Hadron.

I think this could break your classification :)

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by daveloyall on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @11:39AM (#9922971)
Thank you for this explanation.

But hey, speaking of TNG... Can't you just stick on of those fancy crystals in your computer?

Wait, computers made out of crystals? Did that just happen? :)

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:35PM (#9924617)
Computers are already made out of fancy crystals. But these new crystals would be even fancier than the old ones.
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by empath75 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @10:26AM (#9922459)
That's a really good explanation.
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by raverbashing on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @08:51AM (#9921836)
One example happens in semiconductors

You have n-type material, where the charge carriers are electrons. So far so good (a real particle)

In p-type material, the charge carriers are the absence of an electron (called a hole).

It is of course, not a real particle, but it carries charge as well as a real particle.

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by jpmattia on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:24PM (#9924545)
> You have n-type material, where the charge carriers are electrons. So far so good (a real particle)

Even that: It's a quasi particle. It's an electron with an effective mass, which differs from the mass of an electron in free space.

The effective mass arises because of the collective electron interaction with the crystal atoms. At a range of high energies, the electron even exhibits the same behavior you'd expect from a relativistic particle (with something different than c for the ultimate velocity.)

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by losername on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:33PM (#9924605)
That's just a figure of speech. The charge of an ion stems from the ratio of electrons to protons. To every "hole" there is a proton, which is a particle. I am repeating myself.
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by johntb86 on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:47PM (#9925215)
It's not just a figure of speech, it's a useful abstraction. The protons don't move, but the holes seem to do that. Not only that, if you pretend the holes have a certain amount of mass you can predict how they move, and they move similarly to how a positibly-charged particle would move in the same circumstances.
[deleted]
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by phreeza on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @09:45AM (#9922183)
I am afraid there is no nice way to say this, almost all of what you wrote there is completely wrong.
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by knieveltech on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @10:27AM (#9922465)
Don't be lazy. If you see errors please provide correction so the rest of us can benefit!
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by selimthegrim on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @09:59AM (#9922276)
Agreed. Quasiparticle does not mean it's evanescent or has imaginary energy! Back to scattering class....
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by yk on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @10:16AM (#9922390)
In this context, the particles that appear in the Standard Model. So a quasiparticle can be understood in terms of the underlying structure of matter ( a crystal in this case), a 'real' particle can not be understood in terms of some underlying mechanism. Granted, "can not be understood in those terms yet" is preliminary and a not really satisfying definition.
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by Conjoiner on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @07:48AM (#9921547)
The difference between a bullet made of real particles and one made of math is that the real one can kill you.
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by fsloth on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @01:13PM (#9923855)
Hmm, I think you got it in reverse. We are talking about of properties of real physical things all the time here. We just can't expect to instantiate any random piece of math in the real world - like take a specific vector subspace and try to use it as a katana, that would be silly.

We take a physical system and apply some mathematical properties to it. In the case of bullet I think what is interesting is to model it's energy, E = 1/2 mv*v. Now, if we take the kinetic energy of a bullet, and apply it to any other object, and then instantiate this object in the real world the lethality of the object depends on the nature of the object. A ball of hay of a diameter of 1 m in 1 atm 10 meters away with the kinetic energy of a bullet does not sound lethal. An object more like a bullet, like an iron nail, probably can be. Gummy bear? Who knows.

The point is, the maths here are about physical things, although it can take a lot of experimental work to manufacture a specific physical system that exhibits behaviour which is modeled with specific piece of math.

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by dvdkhlng on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @08:26AM (#9921694)
Quasi-particles are not just math. They have measurable properties that are like properties of real particles (just like "holes" in P-type semiconductors can be measured to behave like quasi-positrons). Or, replying to your proposition:

"With the holodeck safeties off, even holographic bullets can kill." - Picard, First Contact.

:)

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by losername on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:07PM (#9924399)
> just like "holes" in P-type semiconductors can be measured to behave like quasi-positrons

I'm sorry to ask because I should actually know this, isn't the remaining positive charge accounted to the protons in the core? A moving "hole" is just a figure of speech.

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by randallsquared on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @08:00AM (#9921595)
That's true for values of "you" reading this in 2015, at least. :)