Jenny McCarthy and Dave Grohl's opinions on the effectiveness of vaccination are clearly as valid as my doctor's. Weighting my doctor's views above those is clearly a fallacy because debating rules.
I'm not saying that expert opinions don't have merit, I'm saying that expert opinions aren't logically true because they are uttered by experts.
I suggest you look a little more into these "debating rules" (logical fallacies), as they are basically old-timey resoning rules; i.e. popular and intuitive arguments that don't make sense.
P.S. As I recall, the Foo Fighters were mixed up in HIV-denialism, not anti-vaccination.
But the reason for it being a fallacy is that this sort of argument doesn't provide evidence of any kind. Rather, it makes the assumption that it must be true, because the authority says so.
Sure, authority can be a useful heuristic for non-authorities, but is useless in argumentative reasoning, e.g. "X, who is an authority says Y, and so [therefore] Y is true".