Re:Daniel Kahneman: ‘What would I eliminate if I had a magic...
by eivarv on Monday July 20, 2015 @10:13AM
(#9916133)
Sure, I agree to some extent.
In the hypothetical case it may be reasonable to assume that X knows what they are talking about; one can reasonably assume that they are better informed regarding the subject than a layperson.
But the reason for it being a fallacy is that this sort of argument doesn't provide evidence of any kind. Rather, it makes the assumption that it must be true, because the authority says so.
But the reason for it being a fallacy is that this sort of argument doesn't provide evidence of any kind. Rather, it makes the assumption that it must be true, because the authority says so.