NJ-NY commutes are naturally self-limiting. They reach some kind of equilibrium of pain and then people start moving away. The Chinese government moves people around by fiat, so they don't necessarily benefit from the same forces.
If you'd read the article, you'd know that rather than "moving people around", the CPC has in fact been trying to keep people out via a residency permit system. They've failed, as the lure of jobs and lifestyle draws people to the large cities. This article is actually about them reacting to the very real market forces and embracing the influx of people, rather than trying to stop it.
I swear, many commenters on HN haven't updated their knowledge about china for 30 years. "Moves people around by fiat" indeed.
Farmers are still routinely moved off their land to make way for urban construction and nearly always miss out on the profits from the rise in value of said land.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Gorges_Dam#Relocation_of...
The US has vastly different laws and practices than China when it comes to forcing people to move. Relocating a million people in this day and age, would simply never happen. Even the correctly maligned practice of using eminent domain for corporate benefit is exceedingly rare (even though it gets a lot of press). In fact, the US has the exact opposite problem - the inability to expand cities like San Francisco because the people won't allow it.
It's a city with thousands years of history, capital of 5+ ancient Chinese dynasties, top 2 leading China universities, Hollywood of China, ...
How ignorant could a person be to make a comment like above?
I know ther's Qing, Ming, and Yuan (Dadu). Not sure about any others.
I found the Beijing subway to be far nicer than the ones found in major American cities. No surprise since it's much newer.
I know there were some issues with Muslim separatists, but they didn't seem to even rise to the level of US terrorism threat. We do airport theater but not bus/subway theater, even in NYC.
God forbid if you ever have to transfer at xizhimen; I never thought it was possible to wait in line so long to take a subway.
Man, that seems inefficient, fiats can hold like 3 people tops
(bad pun, sorry)
I'm not trying to be dismissive here, as I'm fairly sure both Beijing and Shanghai will power ahead some point in the near future, but just pointing out that the challenge of moving around ~10m people/day within a city isn't quite as novel as the article makes it sound -- and both Tokyo and Seoul have, by and large, made it quite tolerable to boot.
Compared to the 20 years it took the Big Dig, or my own home city which has been talking / debating / purchasing / cancelling / assessing / suing re mass-transit, it really is an impressive achievement.
Traffic jam backs up 10km outside Beijing (http://bitly.com/1FSIJPB)
As well as pollution that have increased risks of cancer and premature death in Beijing (http://bit.ly/1GMIL7H)
It sounds like you're from NY; I wouldn't discount NY so quickly, without having visited Beijing to see for yourself. I've been to Beijing; I would never live in that place.
The pollution is bad, especially in the winter. We are in summer now and it is merely not good rather than really bad. Today it even rained so it's a bit fresh out. There are plenty of cities that are much worse: Cairo, Tehran, New Delhi, ...
I feel bad for those who have to work outside (crossing guards have it bad), but life expectancies in Beijing are quite correlated with lifestyle and income, just like anywhere else. If their is a dent in life expectancies, we won't see it for another 20 or so years.
Beijing has the second biggest subway in the world after Shanghai, and it carries the most people daily with over 9m riders. They are starting several more lines this year:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beijing_Subway#Future_lines
I believe the first low-speed maglev will be running this year. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_S1,_BCR
The NYT article makes Beijing sound like hell but they seem to be doing a great job of building the world's leading cities for the next century.
In NYC they're still trying to figure out how to get more buses into Manhattan from New Jersey.
http://www.capitalnewyork.com/article/city-hall/2015/03/8564...