"Latin" is used as the name of a writing system, which is used by both English and French. "Cyrillic" is also the name of a writing system, used by several languages. In some cases, there is a one-to-one relationship between named writing systems and languages, but not in these cases.
The distinction made in Unicode is between writing systems, not languages.
(Note that some valid renderings of a letter in one writing system may be similar to a letter in a different writing system, but the range of acceptable renderings is different between writing systems. This is generally not the case between languages using the same writing system.)
You could argue that French A and English A are the same because they are identical by descent, but then you'd have to admit that Greek A and Cyrillic A are more of the same.
So I guess the question is: how are you defining "writing system"?
You say this, but you give no argument at all. What makes English A and French A the same thing in a way that English A and Cyrillic A aren't? From a Unicode perspective (at least, from the perspective that Unicode takes with respect to Chinese characters -- 青 and 靑 are different code points despite being the same character), "Cyrillic Capital Letter A" and "Cyrillic Handwritten Capital Letter A" would be different code points, since they look nothing alike (disclaimer: I don't know that in the particular case of A the printed form and the handwritten form look nothing alike, but I do know that in general the handwritten form of a cyrillic character may not resemble the printed form. Feel free to substitute some other letter where I say A).
> but French and English -- e.g. in citations or quotes -- shouldn't be distinguished that way, except for punctuation
Why not?
I have seen advocacy for using the distinction that Unicode already makes (!) between a fancily curved apostrophe that is part of the spelling of a word, and the same glyph, but used to end a quotation. This is stupid. You'd need to train everyone in the world (well, the relevant part of the world) to input the same thing differently depending on how they're using it. Even if you made the effort, it will never happen reliably -- people have enough trouble spelling words differently depending on how those words are used.
Finally, my original point about Chinese writing didn't refer to Unicode at all. Spoken Chinese is encoded into characters using a system that makes heavy reference to semantics. This is a terrible idea, and as a result Chinese speakers are severely retarded in the development of their ability to read. The claim I'm making is that mission-creeping Unicode to encode semantics rather than glyphs (much as written Chinese encodes semantics more than it encodes sound) is similarly a bad idea. The goal of Unicode is to represent writing, not meaning.