However, for unskilled labor, like Uber, I care a lot about needing a car right now - and dealing with drivers directly is not efficient at all. As such, Uber is doing so well in this market.
Uber and AirBnB caters to immediate needs for a short term engagement, so the dispatching capabilities are the real value (find me someone who can do X right now).
Homejoy is dispatching for a long term relationship, so it has a hard time staying engaged in the relationship as it progresses.
I think the skill is less important than the duration of the engagement for a dispatching service like this.
Anecdotally I pay Molly Maid to clean my apartment, because i don't want to deal with liability, legality or tax complications.
With driving, nothing of that is required. Many people are in auto mode when they are driving. Think about it - is it easier to drive vs. cleaning your place? Of course you want basic driving skills to be there - but I think the DMV licensing process and Uber ratings generally takes care of that. You are going extreme by talking about death etc. - but how many Uber journeys have resulted in that. There are millions of Uber being driven every day - and I haven't read about a single death (of the passenger).
Cleaning, being good at cleaning, is an uncommon skill. I've gone through my fair share of housekeepers. When you find a good one that you trust with the keys to your home, you want to hold on to them.
> The only skill required is attention to detail and caring enough to do a good job.
Thought experiment: imagine yourself cleaning 100 houses professionally for two hours. My bet is that the last house would be 2X - 3X more clean than the first.
I'm sorry but shutting the company down because the round you could raise wasn't as big as you hoped feels like wimping out. Alive beats true to your vision and dead. In "The Hard Thing About Hard Things", Ben Horowitz coins the term WFIO (pronounced wiff-e-o) for that "We're Fucked, It's Over" feeling that entrepreneurs get on a regular basis. Lawsuits spooking investors is certainly bad but hardly even qualifies.
Given how big an issue the worker classification issue is for the whole economy, I could see the regulatory issues getting sorted out over the next few years. Quitting seems like a premature move to me. How do the investors who put $40m into the company feel? Who's going to invest in this team again? Who's going to go work there?
That hits the nail on the head. A 1099 contractor has to cut some 30%-40% off their wage to support things like self-insurance, etc (or add yea much). If you're "working" for a gig provider, you're not a 1099 employee by the inherent nature of the thing. Granted, you're not in a normal employer-employee relationship, but neither are you a skilled freelancer contracting your labor out on wages you yourself set and negotiated.
While I fully support the idea of TaskRabbit, Lyft, Uber, Homejoy et al, certain realities have to be faced squarely: they are not being real about the nature of their business. They really are something like employers, with something like employees.
Cheung is likely correct that a third legal category needs to be created (neither 1099 freelancer nor true employee), but in the absence of that, it seems profoundly more ethical to consider the workers employees.
The recent US Dept. of Labor interpretation suggests the same: see "Does the Worker’s Managerial Skill Affect the Worker’s Opportunity for Profit or Loss?" at http://www.dol.gov/whd/workers/Misclassification/AI-2015_1.h...
Of course then you're even more at risk of disintermediation, so you're probably charging for listings. It's a useful business but a smaller one.
As someone who used to build/sell websites to small cleaning companies, real estate agents, tradesmen, etc.
Marketing+Parts+Labor was the formula for almost all of their costs. Marketing represented ~20-25% for the few that were willing to discuss it with me.
http://blog.sfgate.com/techchron/2014/07/22/homejoy-hikes-ho...
That is in line with what Homejoy was asking for [25%].
Homejoy providers had direct access to the customer base they interacted with and could siphon off those clients they built a relationship with relatively easily. I know that is what I did once I found one I liked.
I've heard this as a need from literally every service provider I've ever used. They relish referrals.
I driver Uber more because it is easier to get a cab. They alone are already making more than the entire taxi industry in SF.
If anything, it seems Homejoy's problem is in making it too easy for their cleaners to find retained customers.
I never ordered from a cleaning service before Homejoy, and I doubt I'll bother with it after Homejoy. It's a useful service to me, but I'm not going to call half a dozen random guys on their cell phones to find one that will work for me.
Similarly, ride volumes are way up after Lyft and Uber come to town. Before, there is a lot of demand that is simply going unfilled.
While a bit off topic, I was really happy to see this sort of comment from you. I'd love to buy you a coffee or beer in Chicago sometime.
The technology that most companies like these offer (with the possible exception of Uber) is a commodity. The real asset they have is the network effect. Which makes the balance of power between the tech company and the "1099 contractors" deeply suspicious. What are these companies doing for the laborers that makes them valuable enough to be skimming returns from the work?