I'm a disappointed subscriber.
Also agreed that it's not 'true' 2-factor authentication if you can get product support or log in with only a master password. That opens up a lot of social engineering attacks. But then, true 2-factor authentication is also a support nightmare when people lose their passwords, so I'm sympathetic, but it doesn't change the fact it's not ideal.
Also, since you would generate the recovery codes, there wouldn't be a need to explain why the master password should be long & random; and it would reduce the risk of customers using an easy master password (either from failing to change it, or failing to use sufficient length/randomness).
[Many services w/ 2fa support recovery codes.. here's github for example: https://help.github.com/articles/downloading-your-two-factor...]
History, mostly. Ten years ago 2FA wasn't really a thing for most sites. We built an "alternative login" system, where you could create secondary passwords for your account and optionally set that password to be a "restricted" login. This was when using FastMail on untrusted machines (eg public libraries) was not at all uncommon, and HTTPS and even cookie-based login wasn't widespread and being able to create a throwaway password was very useful!
Over time we added paper-based OTP, Yubikey, SMS and so on but at its core its still just for secondary passwords.
We have started work on a rewriting the whole way this system works, which will work like more "conventional" 2FA systems, and will allow a second-factor on the master password. We're expecting it to be available later this year.
You can create an alternative login and put 2 factor on that, but not the master login. In theory you should never have to use the master login, and they have written pages of text justifying not having two factor on the master login, but thats not how it works in real life [0]
In real life, they require you to submit your master password to get any support. [1] .... so there I am overseas needing support and having to submit my master password over a dubious hotel connection.
They have promised real 2FA for years and years. One of these days I will ditch them for a provider who can bother supporting real 2FA.
[0] https://www.fastmail.com/help/account/2fa.html
[1] https://www.fastmail.com/html/?MSignal=Support-**