Re:Trader Made Billions on Subprime
by cstejerean on Tuesday January 15, 2008 @04:30PM
(#98866)
He didn't drive the prices up (at least not by much). The fact that more and more people started defaulting on their mortgage drove up the price of insurance. That's what he was betting on (and he was right). So if he didn't make the money someone else would have (whoever was holding on to those insurance contracts).
You can't buy a financial instrument without driving its price up. This applies even more if you're buying hundreds of millions of dollars worth of a financial instrument.
True in general, but when he bought them, they were priced very low. Even after he bought millions (presumably) of the swaps, other investors thought he was an idiot and didn't follow suit, so the price of the swaps probably didn't go up much. It was only after the sub-prime fiasco got into third gear that other investors began clamouring for the swaps.
By all rights, his initial foray into buying the swaps most likely had minimal effect on the price. Ultimately he felt they were incorrectly priced by the market and made a bet on them.
Yes, but this still doesn't actually hurt the people that hold mortgages (the homeowners). Whether or not my bank can handle the fact that I'm about to foreclose has nothing to do with my ability to (not) pay.
Speculation provides liquidity to the market. That generally lowers the cost of financial transactions ceteris paribus.
Re:Trader Made Billions on Subprime
by byrneseyeview on Tuesday January 15, 2008 @09:11PM
(#99019)
Which raises the future cost of lending to deadbeats, because the only banks with capital will be the ones who were conservative.
One concern was that even if Mr. Paulson bet right, he would find it hard to cash out his bets because many were in markets with limited trading. This hasn't been a problem, however, thanks to the wrong bet of some big banks and Wall Street firms. To hedge their holdings of mortgage securities, they've scrambled to buy debt protection, which sometimes means buying what Mr. Paulson already held.
In other words, Paulson was buying mortgage insurance contracts, driving their prices up, and now banks are buying those contracts from him (at higher prices than they would have if he hadn't been involved in the market).