News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by farawayea on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:12AM (#9885498)
This is great. Let's continue: remove pocket, remove hello
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by glogla on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:24AM (#9885607)
Hello is just few (hundred?) lines of Javascript giving UI to WebRTC.

Unless you want to remove WebRTC and that's just stupid.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ultramancool on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:51AM (#9885825)
Removing registration on Hello servers and WebRTC altogether is not stupid if you give a shit about your privacy, look at the leaks WebRTC provides, local IPs which are great for fingerprinting, real IPs from behind VPN, etc. It's one big gaping privacy nightmare so far, so it's pretty reasonable to have it disabled, until this gets sorted out at least.

Fortunately it can be toggled off in about:config easily.

Set loop.enabled = false to disable hello, set media.peerconnection.enabled = false to disable WebRTC. If you don't want pocket, set browser.pocket.enabled = false.

You can even make yourself one big user.js file to fix the bad ideas that have been added to Firefox lately. Mozilla still has a good thing going for them, and that is user choice. However stupid the defaults get.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by mhurron on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:56AM (#9885858)
It is getting annoying to have to go into about:config with every release to turn things I don't want off.

Off should be default. Let those that want to use these features turn them on if they want. Or better yet, ship a damn extension.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by Animats on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:07PM (#9886878)
Right. It's like the "just hit delete" line from spammers, and the invisible "x" boxes to reject "shared" posts in Facebook.

Firefox doesn't even predefine some of the things in "about:config" that need to be set to turn off some of these undesirable features.

There's IceCat, a GNU fork of Firefox without all the proprietary extensions.[1] It may start getting more traction as Mozilla puts more junk in the browser.

[1] http://www.gnu.org/software/gnuzilla/

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by Manishearth on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @03:05PM (#9887279)
You don't have to. Drag it off using the customize button.

These things are lazy loaded and wont run until you turn them on. No footprint when they're off the UI (minimal footprint when they are on)

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ultramancool on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:02PM (#9885909)
It's a real pain, but they want the less sophisticated users to be able to take advantage of all the latest stuff and if Chrome or IE is shipping with it enabled, they have to compete. Well, that explains WebRTC at least. As for the other stuff...

I'm a Pocket user, but I have no idea why that needed to be integrated into the browser, seems like an insane decision to me. I hope they got a good pay day out of that.

Same as the history based advertising tiles. Sure, it's checked locally, it still seems creepy and annoying... but again, browser.newtabpage.enhanced = false.

Unless we lose this level of user choice, I don't see a better alternative. It would be nice if someone would ship some tool to automatically update a user.js file, however, I think many of us have different opinions about what feature we do and do not want enabled in our browsers.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by mlinksva on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:47PM (#9886252)
Mozilla got $0 from Pocket. Mindboggling. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9885360
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by kuschku on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:57PM (#9887223)
Well, they kinda got money, in a different way:

Before, mozilla was implementing their own pocket competitor. Switching to pocket, and existing solution, allowed them to save money.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by mhurron on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:15PM (#9886013)
Off by default lets everyone choose to turn it on if they're interested. It also might clue in Mozillas devs that if they want people to turn it on, a setting in about:config isn't the only place you should be putting the button.

Off by default is neither removing user choice, nor is it preventing Mozilla from saying they ship with feature X. It is the right way to present it.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ultramancool on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:40PM (#9886192)
> Off by default lets everyone choose to turn it on if they're interested.

It lets more sophisticated users choose. Less sophisticated users however will more likely switch to a different browser the moment a site doesn't work before poking through settings.

I think a better way than a separate setting would be to go in the direction of many software firewalls and present it to the user as a choice when an application requests it as many browsers currently do with the location APIs. This would provide individual domain-level control over what permissions sites are granted by you. I don't know why this sort of policy seems to be restricted only to the location APIs...

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by mmcru on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:29PM (#9887033)
are there any popular sites that rely on Hello or Pocket to function?
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by greiskul on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @04:01PM (#9887640)
Off by default is simply off for 99% of users.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by TD-Linux on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:46PM (#9886247)
I agree with a lot of this, but not turning off WebRTC in general. Certainly you should turn it off (or force TURN only) if you're trying to hide your IP behind a VPN. But IPv6 already causes you to lose the same amount of privacy as exposing your IPv4 address behind a NAT, so it seems somewhat of a lost cause.

I still think WebRTC enabling peer to peer connections is better than running all of your data through a third party server.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ultramancool on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:18PM (#9886472)
> But IPv6 already causes you to lose the same amount of privacy as exposing your IPv4 address behind a NAT, so it seems somewhat of a lost cause.

Extremely few people have active IPv6, it seems unlikely to catch on now. In addition to that, IPv6 privacy extensions may allow a solution to this problem for many users, but if their link local IPs are also published that may lead to further trouble, depending on configuration. Remember though, this leaks all interface IPs, I have many virtual machines installed with their own network adapters added to my system, VPN adapters, etc which also leaks data as all of those adapters will have v6LL IPs on them even if they're not in use.

Additionally, this issue is already actively being used for fingerprinting. Not some exploit of tomorrow. There was a New York Times advertiser caught doing it a few days ago.

> I still think WebRTC enabling peer to peer connections is better than running all of your data through a third party server.

Yeah, which is why I encourage disabling it completely. Until either they fix the privacy issues or the value of using some WebRTC application appears to trump them to you.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by technofiend on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:55PM (#9887210)
Are you aware IOS 9 will prefer IPV6 by default? And that many browsers already have a "Happy Eyeballs" Implementation? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Eyeballs

IPV6 isn't going anywhere: IPV4 exhaustion is a real concern and with the internet / internet of things growing, the only place to grow is really the IPV6 space. NAT only delayed the inevitable.

See here - https://ipv6.he.net/statistics/ - for current statistics on how many IPV4 addresses are left.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ultramancool on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @03:08PM (#9887295)
Yeah, I know, many OSes do already prefer it by default. I see more pushes for CGN than I do for IPv6 as a solution to IPv4 depletion though, it just seems dead in the water, in my country at least. Maybe your ISPs are better, but no locally available ISP will offer me native v6, it's either real v4 or CGN v4.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by TD-Linux on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:58PM (#9886795)
>Extremely few people have active IPv6, it seems unlikely to catch on now.

Except that over 20% of the United States has IPv6 connectivity. In fact, you might be using it without knowing (most mobile providers have it now, in fact some use IPv6->IPv4 translation methods) [1].

>Remember though, this leaks all interface IPs

Does it? Maybe you should file a bug so that only routable interfaces and non-LL IPs are used. This does seem like a problem.

[1] https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html#tab=per-...

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by ultramancool on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @03:16PM (#9887334)
> Except that over 20% of the United States has IPv6 connectivity.

The entire rest of the world has near-zero, just look at your own link. I'm in Canada and we have 0.55% here. No local ISP will offer it to me, and the one that did withdrew it completely last year. So perhaps I'm just slighted. There are a few other countries with 5%+ but it still makes up only a very small percentage of internet users. To top it off, while there has been some IPv6 adoption in the US, CGN has also caught on pretty heavily all over the world and seems to be, sadly, the solution most ISPs will actually go with for the near term at least.

> Does it? Maybe you should file a bug so that only routable interfaces and non-LL IPs are used. This does seem like a problem.

https://diafygi.github.io/webrtc-ips/ is able to immediately reveal all the VM interfaces on my system even with no VMs using them. I suspect this is done so that faster routes may be established, but it is indeed a major problem for anyone who doesn't like fingerprinting.

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by pjc50 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:06PM (#9885939)
Does Firefox Hello do registration if you never click the Hello button in a particular session?
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by Manishearth on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @03:08PM (#9887294)
Hello does nothing until clicked
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by Raphmedia on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @02:28PM (#9887026)
It's third party features that I will never use.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by baby on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:21PM (#9886500)
Oh please don't remove pocket, this is one of the awesome feature of Firefox along with Tree Style Tab (and if it was just me I would add Tree Style Tab by default as well)

(And of course I go against the public opinion here on HN, but I wonder how many people did actually use Pocket before trashing it?)

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by chris-at on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @03:42PM (#9887508)
Pocket had an add-on that was working just fine. The old one even needed less space than the new button and didn't require a cookie.

I'd reinstall the old one but "This add-on has been removed by its author".

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by baby on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:25PM (#9888167)
It's debatable but I think something like pocket is fundamental to a 2015 browser experience. The bookmarking system has been bad since its beginnings.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by urda on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @03:00PM (#9887250)
1) Open the menu

2) Click "Customize"

3) Drag pocket and / or hello from the tool bar into "Additional tools and features"

4) Take a breather, phew that wasn't too hard was it?

https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/customize-firefox-contr...

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by stevenh on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @04:10PM (#9887689)
These need to be disabled by default, and the steps you list should be taken by people who want to enable them.

If a masochistic user wants to navigate the labyrinth of dark patterns meant to confuse them into not understanding that the "Additional tools and features" category is also the "completely disabled features that run nothing in the background" category (why would anyone think that, ever?), then they can go ahead and do it. If these things are so great, then I'm sure users would be happy to put that extra work into enabling them. After all, it's 3 simple intuitive steps!

Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by makomk on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @03:44PM (#9887517)
For some reason, I keep having to do that - it doesn't stick. And every version brings more unwanted toolbar buttons I need to remove. I'm seriously considering looking into building a version of Firefox with them patched out altogether.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by lamby on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @03:54PM (#9887584)
Rebutting a claim that the default options are poor by providing instructions to change those settings seems, at best, a non-sequitur.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by Excavator on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @11:14AM (#9891689)
Don't even need all that. Just, right-click the icon and click "Remove from Toolbar/Menu".
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by hartator on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:22AM (#9885582)
I wouldn't mind these two as assumed business decisions. But please stop the hypocrisy. It's just hurting Mozilla image without fooling anyone.
Re:Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default by techwizrd on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @01:59PM (#9886800)
Just out of curiosity, how will removing Pocket integration and Hello (a thin UI over WebRTC) personally? Both are lazy-loaded, so the only bloat they add is "visual bloat". This behavior is seriously disappointing from the Firefox community.

I've been using Pocket since it was Read It Later and I was pleased to see it integrated into the browser. Mozilla is working on a Reader mode[0] but it does not seem to be ready for public consumption yet (despite landing in 2012). Most people don't even know it exists, and it obviously does not save it for later (unless you bookmark it). The implementation is open-source (MPL license), although Pocket itself is proprietary. Hotword detection is not absolutely necessary for browser functionality, yet I hear no chorus of complaints from Chrome users. Should Mozilla be prohibited from partnering with proprietary third-parties whether or not it benefits their users?

Hello is even less of an argument. Firefox Hello is a simple Javascript UI for the existing WebRTC spec supported by Firefox, Chrome, and Opera[1]. It allows people to communicate without having to set up accounts, sign-in somewhere, and works against the platform lock-in of proprietary services such as Facetime, Hangouts, and Skype. If it's disabled by default, the service becomes useless. My parents shouldn't have to enable it about:config for me to talk to them, nor should they have to download another plugin to use a technology built-in to the browser. I understand the security implications[2] in IP leakage[3], but I don't see a simple fix that doesn't neuter the functionality (although this comes close[4]). W3C has stated their position on fingerprinting[5], but at least Mozilla is actively working on the issue.

0: http://www.ghacks.net/2015/02/07/mozilla-starts-to-push-read...

1: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/which-browsers-will-wor...

2: https://twitter.com/incloud/status/619624021123010560

3: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=959893

4: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/statutory/

5: https://github.com/w3ctag/spec-reviews/blob/master/2015/05/f...