Re:Removal of Unsafe in Java 9 – A disaster in the making
by joshstrange on Monday July 13, 2015 @02:13PM
(#9879882)
Herein lies the problem. As other commenters have pointed out there is no alternative way to do thing performantly without Unsafe. These "core" (as in used everywhere not core to java) libraries don't use Unsafe for fun but often because there is no other way to do something without compromising way too much on speed or other things. If Java 9 had replacements for Unsafe things it would be one things but it doesn't.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Removal of Unsafe in Java 9 – A disaster in the making
by pjmlp on Monday July 13, 2015 @02:30PM
(#9880003)
JNI
Re:Removal of Unsafe in Java 9 – A disaster in the making
by colin_mccabe on Monday July 13, 2015 @09:52PM
(#9882375)
JNI has a very high per-call overhead. It is not an effective alternative to many things in Unsafe. For example, in Hadoop when using short-circuit local reads, the client determines if the file descriptor it has cached is still valid by doing a read from a memory-mapped file. The only way to do this with decent performance is with Unsafe#getLongVolatile. In contrast, JNI methods can't be inlined, often require copying memory back and forth, and don't work well with the just-in-time compiler.
In many cases, the overhead of JNI is too large to even use it, unless you move a large portion of the program out of Java. If Oracle goes through with this removal it will be a huge problem for Java and the JVM ecosystem.