News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by davnicwil on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:13AM (#9878594)
Looks to be an amazing piece of engineering but seriously, what's the usecase? It looks to be targeted at the amateur market ('shoot like the pros') and I just don't see the demand or workability in this space.

To pick on a few hinted at on the page:

A game of football: Leaving a camera on a tripod on the sideline while I'm focused on the game? Not in any park I've ever played in. Taking the stick from my teammates for being enough of a nerd to set this up?

Skiing: Putting a camera on a tripod, unattended, on the piste? Then get the lift up to the top so you can ski back down towards the camera? Again, I can't see this ending well for the poor old camera.

Dirt biking/other extreme sports: because people often do these alone, and so need an automated cameraman to get any filming done?

EDIT: reading some of these comments my opinion has changed, there are more compelling use cases for this than I first thought of (like letting the person who would have done the filming relax and watch the event, whilst still attending to the camera, that's a great one). This is amazing tech but the main limiting factor for now is the risk of leaving such expensive equipment unattended. When the price falls I have no doubt this will be an extremely widely used tech, as widely used as cameras themselves are now.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by CodeCube on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:23AM (#9878678)
I think you underestimate the utility. Think of parents or family members that attend football games. They're often stuck watching the game "through the viewfinder" if they want to film it ... this frees them up to look with their eyes. You also underestimate extreme sports where you want to film a trick over a given obstacle. This would be fantastic for skateboarders. Boxers who want to film themselves during a workout, or a fight to review their form could use this for sure.

etc. etc. ... just because you don't anecdotally see the demand doesn't mean it's not there ;)

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by jseliger on Monday July 13, 2015 @04:48PM (#9880961)
I'm surprised too that no one has mentioned the adult industry (either actual professionals or possibly among some amateurs / semi-pros). One could easily imagine this sort of ting being useful there, where quality is probably "good enough" and an actual cameraman too expensive.

Others have added that this version has a minimum range of 25 feet, which may scupper it for many, but long video lenses are available.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by skatenerd on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:18AM (#9882860)
Skating with a filmer is often a social activity :-)
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by jfaucett on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:08PM (#9878980)
yea, the problem is I highly doubt it actually works well for the football use case. Think about a basketball or football game. What happens when the QB fires a pass? How does the cam know which player to follow? What about a bball fastbreak where a bunch of players are moving and only one player is moving far ahead of the others, how does it know to follow him? For boxers, and skateboarders I could see this working easily though...
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by Kluny on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:30PM (#9879145)
When it's a football or basketball game, most people are only interested in one person - their kid. To hell with the quarterback. In a professional setting, there would be more than one camera anyway. It would make sense for each of the big deal athletes to have a tracking camera on them.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by Tuna-Fish on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:12PM (#9879024)
Can you just make it follow the ball? How big is the tag anyway?
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by ctdonath on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:12PM (#9879020)
Immediate use: presentations, accurately tracking the speaker without having to hire someone to keep camera on subject the whole time. Even moreso when multiple cameras. Just need one A/V control booth person, much cheaper to buy several of these than hire several cameramen.

Think TED Talks, Apple Keynotes, anything fairly big-budget where chasing the random motions of the speaker just doesn't look on par with the money going in & out of the presentation.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by superuser2 on Monday July 13, 2015 @04:38PM (#9880891)
Live production is ALL about reliability. A boring lights-up lights-down corporate show ALWAYS has 2 $100,000 light boards in active/hot standby even though one $50 DMX controller would do.

We always opt for wired where possible, even if wireless exists. We are paranoid about secure and safe cable runs. When wireless is necessary, we transmit on multiple frequencies with smart frequency-hopping algorithms so that if two of them get interference, the content still comes through on the third.

We have a visceral distrust of rechargeable batteries. We swap out AAs and 9-volts (only the brands we trust) obsessively. A good sound engineer is made very uncomfortable by (and thus obsessively monitors) battery-powered devices in the critical path.

In short: there's no way you're going to get respectable production companies to trust this thing. One, it flies, Two, it's battery. Three, it's RF. Under these circumstances, we proceed with EXTREME caution. We'd much rather build truss to get a camera where it needs to go, run cables to it, mat and tape them as appropriate. Automation is okay, but there is existing, battle-tested camera automation and it's not even that widespread yet.

Film production, maybe. A blown take isn't free, but it's pretty cheap. A flying camera at WWDC hitting battery starvation, motor failure, RF interference, etc. is the end of the world in that line of work.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by tripzilch on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:35AM (#9884733)
Ok. Just noting that the product discussed here, doesn't actually fly. It's not a drone.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by davnicwil on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:16PM (#9879046)
Yes, agreed, this pro use case is an instant, no-questions-asked sell.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by frik on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:50PM (#9879279)
Some Cisco cams can do that.

And it would be a use case for the defunct(?) Microsoft Kinect 2.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by cbhl on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:23PM (#9879525)
Except this product is outdoor-only.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by msandford on Monday July 13, 2015 @02:32PM (#9880014)
Care to explain? Does it have a GPS that makes it stop working when it gets inside?
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by damoncali on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:47AM (#9878849)
As a parent it would be a very welcome thing to be able to watch something your kids are doing and record it at the same time without sacrificing the quality of either experience.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by apaprocki on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:52AM (#9878881)
I think this is one of the best use cases outside of the sports market. I really dislike sitting behind a lens for lots of subtle experiences with kids, but at the same time I want a nice recording of it afterwards. It seems like this would help with that situation.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by mpdehaan2 on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:37AM (#9878781)
A few drone flying things that are sort of similar:

https://hexoplus.com/

https://www.airdog.com/

https://www.lily.camera/

I'm not sure these are the ones I originally read about, so there may be a few more.

This would probably work better for the skiing/hiking/other type case, provided the drone doesn't fly into something or drown.

I like that it can do the motion time lapse thing too though and it obviously would have a lot more run time.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by themagician on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:28PM (#9879555)
None of these actually exist yet. It's just a bunch of concept videos.

Here's what the current experience is actually like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=td5fZhGNz9M

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by freshyill on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:44AM (#9878830)
Have you ever seen the average non-professional try to work a camera to follow any kind of motion? So maybe in cases where it's likely that your camera will walk off, you leave somebody to guard the whole rig—this thing looks like it will almost certainly take a better video or series of photos than the average person.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by digitalsushi on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:17AM (#9878620)
People like to take photos and videos of themselves. You don't need a reason, just some vanity. These will sell like hotcakes.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by davnicwil on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:22AM (#9878661)
Sure, I guess the main thing it comes down to is cost, and likelihood of the camera being stolen or damaged when left unattended.

It's fundamentally very cool and if it was cheap enough to be essentially throw away, or at least pretty easily replaceable, I think there would be a massive demand. But that won't be true for a long time.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by icegreentea on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:21AM (#9878650)
I think you're being a bit too pessimistic. As an amateur athlete, I can definitely see the utility (albeit limited) in this. There are lots of parks in my area (I live in Ottawa... obviously this is location specific) where I could set this up and not worry about it being stolen. And I wouldn't set this up for a game, but it would be useful while practicing/training - and my teammates would not give me shit about it.

I can't comment much on the other use cases that you've gone over, but as an amateur athlete this is totally something I could use. That said, I would rather rent this than own it.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by larrys on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:24PM (#9879103)
"Looks to be an amazing piece of engineering but seriously, what's the usecase? "

This product is almost a reverse example of why you can't ask people of whether they need your product (Steve Jobs examples) since they could overestimate what they would buy until it comes time to actually do so.

My first reaction was "this is cool I have to have one!" and I thought of one case in particular where I was trying to film my car accelerating (a 911) but couldn't get my wife to come with me and besides she wouldn't do a good job anyway. But then I thought "well is filming that event important enough to get involved with this product at that price point and do I really need another practically single use gadget to have to deal with and learn to use?" I still haven't even bought a quadracopter with video (new dji 4 model) and it's not for price reasons. In the end I am thinking "ok so I will have all of this cool video then what do I do with the video exactly?" It's not that I wouldn't enjoy using these types of things but I have toys that I don't have the time to play with right now.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by fake44637 on Monday July 13, 2015 @03:23PM (#9880406)
Skiing: Putting a camera on a tripod, unattended, on the piste? Then get the lift up to the top so you can ski back down towards the camera? Again, I can't see this ending well for the poor old camera.

On the other hand, this represents a great business opportunity for ski resorts. The ski resort has a few soloshots mounted near the snowboarding rail park, and $5 lets you wear a tracking armband for 5 minutes. Drop it in the bucket at the end of your run, get an ID number which will allow you to download your footage at the end of the day.

In fact, if a ski resort wanted throw a ton of money at this problem, they could put soloshots along the entire mountain, and you rent an armband for an entire run down the mountain. That would however require sophisticated software on their end to collate all of the camera feeds and stitch together a single video file of your run down the mountain.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by jack-r-abbit on Monday July 13, 2015 @05:05PM (#9881090)
That is brilliant. But nothing says they have to stitch the video for you. Giving you access to all your clips would be enough, specially if there is some footage overlap. You might want to transition from one clip to the next in a unique way.

The problem I see with that setup though would be deciding which person to follow when two trackers are competing for camera time. I imagine the base has some sort of logic to make that decision but it would suck to be the person that keeps getting missed because you are always right behind someone that the base gave a higher priority.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by windexh8er on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:56PM (#9879325)
One of the cool features is outside of the band tracking: you can upload a file to the Soloshot to do some awesome timelapse panning. Useful for a lot of situations including celestial or just those generally gorgeous long pans.

(http://www.soloshot.com/dslr-motion-timelapse-written-instru...)

If you're at all into photography this thing has a ton of usefulness at the price point.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by Jemmeh on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:28AM (#9878716)
I agree. It's very neat, but I can't see where the users will be.

Most outdoor events, I wouldn't leave a camera on a tripod alone.

I thought it might be useful for people who make Youtube videos: these people usually work alone and it's a hassle to get actors sometimes--but in these situations, we have the tech for cheaper to already control the camera from a little far away with more control so I can't see that really having a lot of user base either.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by pech0rin on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:25AM (#9878690)
Seems like there are a lot of use cases for this. Take a backcountry ski outfit. Set a few of these up on your trails. Sell videos to people you charter. A ski resort could even use them instead of hiring people to go out and take videos/pictures. Also, there are loads of people who go surfing alone on remote beaches.

If you look at the success of GoPro, drones, etc. then this seems like a definite winner.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by rotten on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:41AM (#9878818)
I could see an artist doing timelapse of their art project using this. Although I'm not sure they'd need the tracking ...

How about a construction site timelapse? Again, not sure about needing the tracking...

The autotracking timelapse was the most interesting part, maybe for a really slow moving _thing_, but I can't think of one...

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by bane on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:43PM (#9879226)
When I was younger and studying martial arts extensively, I would have killed for something like this. Mirrors only get you so far, and I only had so many patient friends who would sit around and film me so I could work on my technique.

I can see it having similar utility for people studying dance (solo, ballroom, etc.)

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by kohanz on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:21AM (#9878657)
> A game of football: Leaving a camera on a tripod on the sideline while I'm focused on the game? Not in any park I've ever played in. Taking the stick from my teammates for being enough of a nerd to set this up?

If it's affordable, I can see this being big with parents and coaches of youth athletes. Go to a children's soccer game (or ice hockey here in Canada) and see how many parents have their cameras out, but would rather be relaxing on their lawn chair than making sure they are catching all the action.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by Fogest on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:39AM (#9878796)
A lot of people for training also like to be able to record themselves and see what they need to work on. Often times you're alone training in a field or something and it could be nice to have the camera follow you.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by Jemmeh on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:30AM (#9878733)
Now that is a good point. You could still have someone sitting near the tripod, but now they don't have to be paying attention to the camera-- they can enjoy the moment.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by thenomad on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:26AM (#9878694)
From my point of view - it means that as a run-and-gun shooter of narrative, I can essentially have an extra cameraman on tap.

That means I can shoot a close-up whilst it handles the wide, or in extremis it can shoot a wide shot and I can hold the boom mic :)

Given the cost of the SoloShot is less than 1 day of hiring a camera op who knows what they're doing, it's a pretty good deal.

Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by kriro on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:50PM (#9879274)
When I lived in the US I used to run the camera to record basketball games of our women's team every now and then. AFAIK pretty much all high school teams do it for analysis. Instantly gets better with this (assuming it can track well enough, the examples with bad scrolling tend to be focused on following a single person)
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by iamthepieman on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:29AM (#9878726)
I agree that its uses are probably more practically limited than the demo videos show. However, event photography and videography are pretty big sub-markets.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by randxx on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:10PM (#9878994)
Youtube. Fitness. Podcasting.
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by mpermar on Monday July 13, 2015 @11:24AM (#9878682)
> Dirt biking...

Right. I'd buy it for that alone.

[dead]
Re:Soloshot: Automatically film outdoor activities without a... by davnicwil on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:56PM (#9879772)
I meant this to be a bit tongue in cheek, of course this wouldn't actually happen in any serious way or matter if it did, but suppose it hints at a broader point that tech needs to be inconspicuous to have mass, everyday appeal.

I'll admit, setting up an automated camera tripod rig at a non-professional sport event would make me feel a bit awkward.. and dare I say pretentious. That's just me, I only take part in really amateur level sport where this would be the case. I can totally see lots of more serious/competitive athletes going for this.