Bad loans are a symptom of a poor fiscal situation.
No one forced Greece to take out loans.
Consider this write up :http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2010/10/greeks-bearing-bonds-...
This was before the "Greeks as Victims" narrative gained wide currency.
“The way they were keeping track of their finances—they knew how much they had agreed to spend, but no one was keeping track of what he had actually spent. It wasn’t even what you would call an emerging economy. It was a Third World country.”
As it turned out, what the Greeks wanted to do, once the lights went out and they were alone in the dark with a pile of borrowed money, was turn their government into a piñata stuffed with fantastic sums and give as many citizens as possible a whack at it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis#2...
So yes, so far, only one side (lenders) has taken losses.
Also, by the time of the haircut the banks that did the original lending to Greece were not holders of the private bonds. They had been unloaded. Ever since 2009 almost all money given to Greece from the so called bailouts have merely been transfers to primarily German and French banks. The bailout has been nothing more than a propping up of German and French banks while at the same time doing great damage to the Greek economy.
To be sure Greece has a pretty messed up government and they need to mature politically. The Greek people have suffered greatly and need to reform but further austerity is not going to help them.
In that case, Greece should be fine with no further bailouts - all they need to do is officially repudiate their debt. Then they can go on running Greece independently without any reforms and they won't need to beg the Germans and Bulgarians to send them money.
This is why Argentina's default wasn't anywhere near as bad - they were fairly close to consuming as much as they produced.
Unlike Greece, Argentina also instituted necessary reforms - for example, import substitution and breaking sticky wages via a 13% nominal wage cut for govt workers and pensioners [1]. Greece has steadfastly refused to do these things in spite of having ample time.
[1] Recall why Keynesians promote inflation - to inflate away real wages, which this cut also did.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis#c...
Banking is not risk free, nor should it be.
Borrowing isn't risk free. Nor should it be.
Both sides have a responsibility in this. Actions have consequences.
Why would we protect institutions from the effects of the free market?
Why suddenly when it's a bank in trouble, does free market ideology not provide the solution?
>Both sides have a responsibility in this
I dont see both sides making efforts to work this out at all. I see greece in headlines owing money; i dont see headlines about DB being forced to agree to forgive interest on loans, cut employee salaries/bonuses, or take any kind of belt-tightening measures.
Where exactly do you see both sides taking responsibility?
[ source : http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-18056677 ]
Or are we going to single out individuals that are responsible and saddle them with billions of debt? The alternative in this scenario to democratically-shared blame is ludicrous. Blame/consequences can't just magically disappear at this point.
Look, don't get me wrong, I'm all for politicians being accountable for their actions. As a freedom minded (Libertarian/Anarcho-capitalist), I think a simple act/rule such as that would put us straight down a path to true freedom from government. But this crisis/situation is not one of those times where I'd advocate such a course.
"Democratically-shared blame" is the ludicrous option.
The important part is this; if you live in a country where you're allowed to vote for your representation, you are part of the government and share in it's successes and it's failures.
But not loans to governments, but loans to individuals, industry and finance.
What then happened was that the crash of '07-08 came and spooked the private banks issuing those loans. Only then did the various governments step in and underwrite the bad loans to effectively bail out the private banking system.
This, along with the number of companies etc that shut down, has put a massive economic burden on said governments.
Thing is that before the euro, Greece could have depreciated its currency to make its exports cheaper. But with the euro the currency is set to the export situation of Germany.
But the point is, if you forgive the Greek their debt, how do you know that they won't return to their old ways and ruin their country yet another time? How do you know that you won't have the same problems again 15-20 years down the road? And should you bail them out again then?
I'm not saying the proposed solution is great. It's not. But my impression is that the Greek are hemming and hawing, and doing their best to avoid any structural reforms that would prevent such a crisis from happening again. They don't seem to take responsibility for their mismanagement and they don't seem to see any reason why they should change their behavior. They put band aids on some parts and the people suffer, and the creditors are partly to blame. But no one seems to be interested in getting rid of the systemic issues like corruption, tax evasion and fraud.
I think that's the difference. The creditors don't trust the Greeks to fix their country because they don't seem to think any of it is their fault. But the creditors did trust Germany to fix its problems after WW2.
EDIT: replaced "debtor" with "creditor".
(Nitpick: the Greeks are the debtors.)
It seems to me that if anyone loans money again to an unreformed Greece, they've accepted that risk.
I expected Greece to be pushed out of the Eurozone just on the term sheets alone. I can't possibly see how this ends without another referendum in another handful of years and a Grexit in the end, anyway.
[0] http://mobile.nytimes.com/blogs/krugman/2015/07/12/disaster-...
[1] https://twitter.com/EdConwaySky/status/620272062771429377/ph...
At a glance it seems that there is a big push for privatisation and more power for capital over labour to encourage business, which the cynic in me assumes will be for the rest of Europe to exploit.
If that's the case, then Greece shouldn't have much of a problem. If X% of the money will go to paying interest, then the Greeks can default and their budgetary shortfall is only (100-X)%.
So why is Greece so keen on having other people send them money?
Also, no austerity can be imposed on the Greeks - Greece is a sovereign nation. Greece can choose to trade austerity for money, or they can choose to default and do whatever they like (although of course they will need to pay for it themselves).
The austerity imposed on the Greek people will shrink the economy and ensure that the next few generations will be labouring in servitude to pay off the debts of the previous generations. The supreme irony in all of this is that Germany was able to thrive after WW2 in part because of the writing-off of more than half of their government debt, something that Angela Merkel has claimed is 'off the table'.
Further reading: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/29/where-did-the-g... https://medium.com/@gavinschalliol/thomas-piketty-germany-ha...