Cynics and detractors have already pointed out the corruption, cronyism, the woeful state of pension reform and rampant tax evasion.
A highly favorited comment on a different NYT piece on the Greece deal sheds light on the indifference, there:
I was at my local tax office this morning - I figured that since most people
here have stopped paying taxes, the timing might be good. It took me half an
hour to do what normally would have taken a morning (most of which would have
involved waiting on line).
In the office I was dealing with, both wickets were open, and I could see the
office beyond. Of the five people I could see, two were at the wickets, one was
entertaining a succession of visitors who were not conducting business, and two
were doing nothing. Just sitting there. Nothing.
I was there because I have a new (British) passport. I have a password-protected
file on the Tax Office site, but I cannot change my number myself, because every
such transaction in Greece begins with the assumption that the client is lying,
and therefore this sort of trivial business has to be done in person and the
number verified. Fill in a two-page form and present the passport.
The woman I dealt with - very courteous - entered the information in my file.
Then she printed everything as well - several pages, nine stamps, seven
signatures.
Greece has been promising (to its creditors) to simplify, cut the red tape,
reduce the Civil Service, for years, but things only get worse. Syriza re-hired
the few that the previous government laid off, knowing they didn't have money to
pay for them.
This is a tiny example of why no one trusts the promises of successive
governments. 'Give us the money now, and we'll reform later.'[1]
Let alone this mess, I wonder what had broken the spirit of the once mighty Hellenic people that they should let these national contagions fester for so long, to allow for their nation to be at receiving end of such humiliation.I particularly want to know why certain southern European countries share this brand of indifference and fatalism about their affairs. I have observed this in Portugal too.
[1] Peter Bowen a British citizen in Crete, Greece shares his thoughts
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/14/world/europe/greece-debt-p...
It is clearly meant according to the Maastricht criteria:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euro_convergence_criteria
"2. Government budget deficit: The ratio of the annual general government deficit relative to gross domestic product (GDP) at market prices, must not exceed 3% at the end of the preceding fiscal year (based on notified measured data) and neither for any of the two subsequent years (based on the European Commission's published forecast data)."
"3. Government debt-to-GDP ratio: The ratio of gross government debt (measured at its nominal value outstanding at the end of the year, and consolidated between and within the sectors of general government) relative to GDP at market prices, must not exceed 60% at the end of the preceding fiscal year. Or if the debt-to-GDP ratio exceeds the 60% limit, the ratio shall at least be found to have "sufficiently diminished and must be approaching the reference value at a satisfactory pace"."
Or in easier words:
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maastricht_Treaty
"2. Government finance:
Annual government deficit:
The ratio of the annual government deficit to gross domestic product (GDP) must not exceed 3% at the end of the preceding fiscal year. If not, it is at least required to reach a level close to 3%. Only exceptional and temporary excesses would be granted for exceptional cases.
Government debt: The ratio of gross government debt to GDP must not exceed 60% at the end of the preceding fiscal year. Even if the target cannot be achieved due to the specific conditions, the ratio must have sufficiently diminished and must be approaching the reference value at a satisfactory pace.".
Or less than 20 millions out the 330 million people living in the EURO zone.[0]
The Debt-To-GDP ratio is a mess. You can see the combined effect of austerity and crisis on some economies. And countries like France have only been twice within the target and not recently. [1]
At the end of the day, as many things with the EU, the real rule is around the interpretation of what means "satisfactory pace" and "exceptional cases" - which is regular political hidden under a layer of pseudo-righteous mathematics. (which is not unusual at all for an international treaty)
[0] http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/tgm/table.do?tab=table&init=1&l... [1] http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/tgm/table.do?tab=table&plugin=1...
The EU is a horrible project and a complet failure in every way.
There is no real economic study that says "3% good, 4% bad" (and it would be idiotic, really -- you need many more parameters to judge a State credit-worthiness, as Japan proves every day). It's all about politics.
It was not clear to me, but thank you for the explanation.
What insanity that the European nations would cripple their economic tools with a treaty like this. There are times when debt/GDP absolutely should be in great excess of 3%, and times when debt must be greater than 60%, and no country should require 'approval' to tackle their own economic problems.
Fortunately, I suppose, it looks like these sections of the treaty are not enforced very strongly.
Or at all, for certain countries. Germany and France routinely break pretty much any parameter, in various directions, and absolutely nothing happens.
But as soon as a minnow spends a little bit more, oooh boy...
Germany has been very strict on their own budget in the last four years and tries hard to satisfy the Masstricht criteria. For the following data, cf. http://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/wirtschaftsdaten104.html
budget deficit/surplus of EU countries (% of GDP) (Haushaltsdefizite/-überschuss der EU-Länder): -3 is allowed, Germany has
2012: +0,1 %
2013: +0,1 %
2914: +0,7 %
2015 (estimate): +0,6 %
2016 (estimate): +0,5 %
which is (IMHO) exemplary.From the Maastricht criteria only "total debt (% of GDP)" (Gesamtschulden (in % des BIP)) is problematic, since there only 60% is allowed. But also here Germany is working very hard to satisfy this criterion:
2012: 79,3 %
2013: 77,1 %
2014: 74,7 %
2015 (estimate): 71,5 %
2016 (estimate): 68,2 %Media like to show "feel good metric" to put a patriotic positive spin (us good, them bad) on the result of regular political arm-wrestling between temporarily weaker countries. You won't see those metric in France however the media will use different things to achieve the same effect. The idea is to build a moral high horse so that your people can forget that over there, few people have benefited but a lot will pay.
[0] http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/tgm/table.do?tab=table&init=1&l...
[1] http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/tgm/table.do?tab=table&plugin=1...
"In 2003, France and Germany had both overspent, and their budget deficits had exceeded the 3% of GDP limit to which they were legally bound."
Both countries basically spent their way out of their economic downturns, then told everyone else not to do that.
Some of the issues are that the IMF wants Greece to implement the austerity stuff on a different time scale than SYRIZA plans to, and that the population is very much against those systems (which I can understand).
If the greek government would improve their tax agency so they’d have 0 tax evasion (let’s just assume that), then with the next election, a party would get elected that changes that. The reason: Currently, greece has to pay back debts, but that means people have to pay a lot more taxes, and only see the infrastructure to become worse – leading to uproar.
Greece can’t just stop spending completely, they have to improve the situation in many places, while simultaneously improving tax collection slowly.
If the Greek people lived beyond their means in the past, someday the moment will come where they have to tighten their belts. Bad luck, but they decided in the past to spend money that they don't have.
I am not saying who is wrong or who is right, but I don't think the blame falls only in one side. I'd argue that you take a risk when you lend money, and shit happens if you lend to people who can't pay.
If one looks at it that way, the whole argument about "lenders chose to lend to them, taking risk that they might not be able to pay, therefore they are to blame as well", falls wayside. This is because the risk they assumed to be taking was one of Greece "not being able to pay", not Greece choosing to not honour the deal.
Tl;dr: There is a difference between the risk of not being able to pay, and the risk of choosing to default/not pay at all.
The point is no one wants the bomb to blow up on their hands, and I get that, but meanwhile the situation in the country gets worse and worse... in the hopes that somehow the country generates more money.
Here the "ideology" starts taking place in the discussion, there are proponents of austerity, saying the confidence generated by always paying out-weights the short term losses, and there are people that say it doesn't work, and that we should somehow try something different since this strategy has been tried and failed a couple of times already. Like, hey let the guys off the hook for part of their debt (lenders knew the risk...), and let the blow generate economic pressure for growth (e.g. Get out of the euro, and let the newly minted and devalued currency be extremely attractive to buy stuff out of Greece, making their economy move).
You have to show the people at the same time that they gain something, too – for example, while you reduce corruption in tax spending, one of the first priorities should be improving performance of Police and similar public services. You can save a lot of money there while at the same time providing a better service. That leads to better public acceptance.
If that's really your theory, then Greece is not the first European country you should target.
Switzerland added a balanced budget amendment to their constitution in 2001
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balanced_budget_amendment#Swit...
Many people consider this as the model for a similar amendment that was added to Germany's constitution in 2009
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balanced_budget_amendment#Germ...
(which the German government takes really seriously at the moment) and Austria's in 2011:
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balanced_budget_amendment#Aust...
It's also unclear what exactly "too much debt compared to GDP" means. What number is too much, and under what circumstances?
Additionally, while Finland's debt/GDP may be "fine", for your definition of fine, Finland's economy is not doing fine, thanks to the constraints imposed by the Euro and the same austerity policies in place throughout Europe. [1] [2] Even now Finland has 8%+ unemployment and 0.8% growth. Indeed for these reasons, Finland is expected to become one of the most indebted countries in Europe. [3]
[1] http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/06/01/the-finnish-dise...
[2] http://www.interfluidity.com/uploads/2015/07/Greekovery.png
[3] http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-01-23/is-finland-a...