"Individuals’ security and privacy on the Internet are fundamental and must not be treated as optional."
"Free and open source software promotes the development of the Internet as a public resource"
So their speak and actions are very different, like shady politicians.
Actions speak louder than words.
This sounds like an excuse that could justify withholding just about any choice from users. Why not have a first-run splash page with something like "Pocket is a really cool service that runs best when it's part of your Firefox. May we turn it on? [yes] [no] Don't worry, you can always change your mind later! [Read more about what Pocket does.]"
Did you also consider if this "benefit" will conflict with the Mozilla Manifesto or not? What were the arguments pro or against of it?
If you did perform this analysis, then was it performed before the user study or after? If you did not, then why?
User research isn't my field, but my understanding is that the study asked a random sample of people if they noticed the feature, if they found it useful, how they used it, and so forth.
This is absolutely not ok in a Hacker News comment. If you can't comment civilly, please don't comment here.
researcher at Mozilla
Firefox has always been the browser that, in contrast to the competition, doesn't try to decide what's best for me. I really appreciate that. Even with this change Firefox is still the best about that, but it is not a move in the right direction.
I thought that was well enough known from UX research that it shouldn't be a controversial decision?
With that said, much of the UX research you are talking about deals with a users first use of a program. The entire program not the addition of one additional feature over time. Also, the more relevant research is that many, many users just click "no" unless they are lead to believe they will lose functionality they currently have. If we were to actually follow the current UX trends from research pocket(or pretty much any features) would never get added to Firefox at all past it's core use of browsing the web.
Of course it is, if the question is why it was bundled by default, rather than leaving it in the add-on store.
Also, the more relevant research is that many, many users just click "no" unless they are lead to believe they will lose functionality they currently have.
That sounds like a strong argument in favor.
Either way, my issue(and I'm sure the issue to most people against it) is that Pocket is a closed platform. I was okay with the binary blobs since not having them would have significantly degraded the browsing experience for users, but including by default things like Pocket makes the moral distance between Mozilla and Google, Apple etc a small enough gap to me that I'm not sure I'm going to be sticking with Mozilla's products long term.
But the question is when the choice is asked, right? If you would have the time to explain the Pocket feature to a normal users, don't you think most would say "OK, saving articles might be useful, keep it in"?
The problem is that you don't usually get the time to explain the feature well enough, and if there's no time, the user will click it away ASAP (and be annoyed).
Why did you feel it necessary to ignore that issue completely over several comments directly addressing it?
The Firefox design team did studies on this, seeing how real users interact with the feature. The results are that bundling it in the browser makes it useful to a lot of people, overall making the browser experience better for them. That's really all this comes down to - the data shows users are happier, overall, with it present by default.
Some users don't like it, like the author of this article, but more users do like it.