News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by hyperpallium on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:04PM (#9872043)
So we'll switch to an entirely different basis - as we did from vaccuum tubes, relays, gears - I like Kurzweil's historical argument on this.

It's like Peak Oil - when the straightforward methods are exhausted, the price goes up, making it viable to explore other avenues that were comparatively inefficient before. Think about an intel-killer. Think about VCs thinking about an intel killer. Some tech may turn out to be much better than expected. To change the figure again, those neglected minor veins may lead to greater deposits, as has happened before.

There is so. much. demand for this.

eg biological neurons are far superior to our best silicon.

Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by titanomachy on Sunday July 12, 2015 @03:15AM (#9872804)
This reminds me of Peter Thiel's idea of "indefinite optimism": we've been spoiled by a recent history of frequent cutting-edge innovation, so we assume that it will continue despite having no idea of the shape it will take. The key here is recent history -- humanity has only been advancing at its current breakneck pace for a few generations. Technological stagnation is more the normal mode.

I think we should consider the possibility that growth in processing power will level out at least for a while. There are some interesting research avenues which may yet bear fruit, but there's no guarantee that some miraculous scientific breakthrough will appear just in time to salvage exponential growth. "Moore's Law" is not some fundamental law of the universe.

Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by carapat_virulat on Sunday July 12, 2015 @07:23AM (#9873144)
Yes, some people take the approach that because one guy called Malthus was wrong before, things can't turn really bad ever. Never understood that kind of reasoning.

Seems like plenty of people even if they don't believe in Father God, they still have some kind of faith in Mother Nature, or Brother Progress that have our backs covered whatever we do.

Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by bsder on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:47PM (#9872135)
> eg biological neurons are far superior to our best silicon.

By what metric?

Biological neurons misfire and make errors all the time. Biological neurons don't like -40C or 100C very much. Biological neurons get rather upset when you subject them to a couple of G's of acceleration.

Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by leereeves on Saturday July 11, 2015 @10:23PM (#9872382)
We'd need artificial neurons without those limitations.

For example, just a few days ago a team from UCSD announced something like that called 'memprocessors'.

Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by coldtea on Sunday July 12, 2015 @12:01AM (#9872541)
Unless it's an actual product, those announcements are a dime a dozen. We're still waiting for "memsistors" and "cold fusion".
Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by leereeves on Sunday July 12, 2015 @07:07AM (#9873120)
It's research, but they claim to have built some.

http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/1/6/e1500031.full

Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by p1esk on Sunday July 12, 2015 @02:51PM (#9874455)
Their conclusion:

"The actual machine we built clearly suffers from technological limitations, that impair its scalability due to unavoidable noise. These limitations derive from the fact that we encode the information directly into frequencies, and so ultimately into energy. This issue could, however, be overcome either using error correcting codes or with other UMMs that use other ways to encode such information and are digital at least in their input and output."

So, it remains to be seen how feasible this machine is.

Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by coldtea on Sunday July 12, 2015 @12:01AM (#9872539)
>So we'll switch to an entirely different basis - as we did from vaccuum tubes, relays, gears - I like Kurzweil's historical argument on this.

The historical argument boils down to: "we've managed to do this a few times in the past, THUS we'll be able to do it indefinitely".

Hardly a logical or coherent argument.

Re:After Moore's Law: how phones are becoming open-source by hyperpallium on Sunday July 12, 2015 @03:12AM (#9872802)
Yeah, I misspoke "argument". It's odd that he doesn't actually articulate the "increasing returns" argument. It's that better technology enables you to see and do better (smaller, larger, faster, purer; whatever your trajectory). Knowing more gives you awareness of more avenues; more people (population) working on it (not needed for the basics of food, shelter etc) enables exploration of those avenues. But most of all, better technology, tools, methods give faster iteration. Because trial-and-error is how we explore unknowns.

Of course, all of that is about discovery - and pre-conditioned on there being something useful to discover. Whether there is or not is necessarily a matter of faith... since, by definition, we don't know. Historicaly it's turned out that way, but rephrasing you, past performance is no guarantee of future performance.

Personally, I see Chaitin's work as showing that there is infinite pattern; and with infinity, some of it is bound to be useful. It's a matter of finding it.

Of course, in the present case we already have a proof by existence that better technology is there to be discovered: you.