Re:To help poor people, give them money
by blacksmith_tb on Friday July 10, 2015 @05:47PM
(#9866970)
Just as logical as saying that if the wheelchair-bound were better at walking, they wouldn't be in wheelchairs. Poor people are often living anxiously one emergency from total bankruptcy, eating cheap, non-nutritious foods, living in uncomfortable or dangerous housing, etc. They'd need to be more than just good with money, they'd need to be brilliant.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
"Just as logical as saying that if the wheelchair-bound were better at walking, they wouldn't be in wheelchairs."
Yeah, that's a good analogy to show my point. You don't throw someone on a wheelchair on their feet and hope it goes well. Just like you don't give a poor person a wad of money and hope it goes well.
Re:To help poor people, give them money
by blacksmith_tb on Friday July 10, 2015 @05:53PM
(#9867022)
No, the analogy was intended to compare a condition (poverty) with another (paralysis), not a tool (money) with another (wheelchair).
Actually, lack of money seemed to play the same role as presence of wheelchair in the above...
Somebody should construct a theorem that states that any metaphor can be used to support any given argument.
This doesn't make sense. I pay a quarter (or more) of my total income so that government can take care of these individuals. Food, basic nutrition, basic safety, etc.
This should be a solved problem.
Re:To help poor people, give them money
by alejohausner on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:58PM
(#9867471)
Most government spending benefits the middle class, not the poor. Roads for your car, schools for your kids, basic research for your devices, police to keep poor people from stealing your stuff, subsidies to keep your company profitable: the typical taxpayer gets a lot of benefit from taxes.
Re:To help poor people, give them money
by jack-r-abbit on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:35PM
(#9867340)
I get what you are saying. But really, not all of your income tax goes to take care of the poor. Sure the government wastes a lot of it on bullshit but there is no reasonable scenario where 100% of your income tax could go to help the poor.