Yeah, that's a good analogy to show my point. You don't throw someone on a wheelchair on their feet and hope it goes well. Just like you don't give a poor person a wad of money and hope it goes well.
This should be a solved problem.
Sorry, but that is not really logical. Many people are poor simply because they don't earn enough money. There is a difference.
Based on the relationship between poverty and ethnicity, I'd say it's related to much more than their choices.
Which, clearly, are a representative sample of the poor people in the society at large.
> are poor because of their choices or because of the place they live. Neither of which are fixed with cash.
Since changing the place you live often is generally not free of cost, I don't see how that follows for the "place they live" group.
To the extent that the "choices" group is past rather than current choices, I don't see how that works for that group, either. (Heck, even with current choices, choices are constrained by the available options, which cash does change.)
The problem with the "evidence" you're using is that it can be interpreted many ways. It's merely a correlation.
In circumstances closer to controlled experiments where I actually gave someone money, they usually wound up worse off in a couple months, not better, unless I made sure the money went towards fixing a real problem.
I am sorry, just this statement alone, disqualifies your whole argumentation. It is just a barroom cliche of the rich.
And who cares if you think my argument should automatically be "disqualified" because it doesn't match your politics.
And sometimes they are cliches, because they match into politics of some people. It is always much better to have an argument, why you do better than others, than to admit, that you are lucky.
But I guess, you are the one, who knows which ones are "accurate", because you know best.
> And who cares if you think my argument should automatically be "disqualified" because it doesn't match your politics.
Right. It is better, that your politics matches the politics of the rich and mighty.
And what's with the childish ad hominem? Do you think you're still in high school?
When there is a monthly stipend that someone knows they can rely on no matter what happens (getting sick, losing their job, family emergency), they are suddenly capable of thinking beyond immediate needs.
Many people caught in the poverty trap know full well that they're making short term decisions that will do more harm than good in the long run, but often the better decision is beyond your means, either financially, or time-wise (because you're working 3 jobs and still falling behind on your bills and coming home completely drained and exhausted).
Give poor people a reward/goal within reach and then see how they do.
I know working on long projects can be very draining because weeks can pass by and I'm still very far away from the goal of project completion.
Poor people's lives are like that. They have to jump through more hoops and exert much more discipline for their life to get better.
One of the things I love about basic income is that if it's set high enough it really removes moral culpability from the rest of society.
So even if your relatives can't make good decisions, you've established a moral high ground and can safely refuse and blame them going forward, whereas if you'd never given them money, it'd all be your fault still.
The real problem with it is that's it's likely a massive labor subsidy, since basic income likely kills the minimum wage.
Joking aside, the concentration of wealth is a different issue than poverty. They're only distantly related.
Also, I'm for progressive taxation schemes.
Time after time, when I've helped family members with cash, it winds up getting wasted horribly and helping them less than it hurt me to give it to them. When I help them with what they need, their situation improves.
And logically, if the poor as a group were good with money, they wouldn't be poor.
Yet the article asks me to abandon reason and experience because there's some "a growing body of evidence" somewhere out there which are not provided by the article.