News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by EGreg on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:48AM (#9864607)
I once met David Chalmers when he was teaching a philosophy course at NYU. And I asked him after the class ... What can you say about consciousness in the "hard probem of consciousness"? I am having trouble making any statements about it which are objective.

I have begun to suspect that our concepts of consciousness and morality are the result of our language and the way we have defined them. With morality is has become clear to me that personal duties are relative to personal goals. That is, "X should do Y" is incoherent, it really implies "X should do Y if X wants Z to happen" which is what the colloquial understanding is. Always being careful to mention Z removes any feeling of mysticism from morality!!

Perhaps with statements about consciousness, the situation is similar. I couldn't really formulate any sort of mystical question once I was carefully adding the SUBJECT of each sentence explicitly in.

The main question I have about consciousness is not about the processing - that can be explained mechanistically. But about the final result of perceiving this orchestra - why am I in my brain and not anyone else's? What is this extra element that is required for the conscious experience and can we ever be sure a machine we built is really subjectively perceiving anything in that metaphysical sense?

Thoughts?

Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:50AM (#9864619)
Doesn't seem right - morality is often intuitive or blind. Else why did Socrates say "The unexamined life is not worth living?" Why, because most (almost all) people don't think about Z.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by zkhalique on Friday July 10, 2015 @12:47PM (#9865081)
Just because they don't think about or stress Z doesn't mean it isn't there. Sometimes Z is a subconscious brain heuristic developed as a response to competing interests, threats, social consequences etc.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 10, 2015 @02:25PM (#9865777)
Folks learn their moral sense long before they can rationalize anything. Do what momma says, that's all the 'Z' that the brain knows.