This is more an indication of the NSA focusing too strongly on offensive/monitoring operations and not on information security, which is their job as well.
This is precisely how I feel about this kind of thing.
To my mind, the NSA should be working to make the security technologies used by American individuals, American companies, and the American government as strong and as free of vulnerabilities as possible. The necessary degree of transparency would, of course, mean any such improvements would be available to anyone in other countries, but I think that situation is far superior to our current climate where we suspect (and not as wild conspiracy theory) that our vulnerabilities were as likely created by the NSA as not.
Many American individuals—and presumably companies—consider the NSA an adversary simply because these individuals value their privacy and the NSA has shown only hostility toward Americans concerning their privacy. In some alternate universe, my own opinion of the NSA could have been positive had they been an agency focused on decreasing the risk of individuals' privacy being compromised.
At the very least, that they are not (apparently) presently sufficiently charged with assisting other branches of the government maintain security is a misallocation of talent.
Didn't NSA develop SELinux?
Edit: Heh, lets all avoid the fact that NSA created something insanely useful for the entire world. Nobody likes to think about these things. Hating is so much easier.
Instead, they have thrown away any trust and respect they had earned. Now they are feared.
Defense against "cyber attack" isn't even NSA's job, and where NSA participates in such endeavors that's on .mil, not .gov
DHS does have responsibility for cyber security on .gov however. But what is DHS supposed to do if OPM decides to throw open the keys to the kingdom to any random "authenticated" contractor handling background checks?
P.S. NSA might somehow have caught this despite everything I mentioned if they were engaged in better "monitoring operations" on other government networks and international communications relays... is that really what you want?
I can think of a few million people who might have, yeah.
Try clicking on the "About IA at NSA" link and you'll find out what NSA means by "Information Assurance":
> NSA's Information Assurance Directorate (IAD) protects and defends National Security Information and Information Systems, in accordance with National Security Directive 42. National Security Systems are defined as systems that handle classified information or information otherwise critical to military or intelligence activities.
Or in other words, what I just said...
Is that really their job? It seems there might be a dozen other agencies responsible, ones less interested in foreign computer networks. Is that DISA's bailiwick? Perhaps NIST? Homeland Security? et cetera
Information assurance. Products and services for government and businesses.
The agency that deals with intelligence (espionage) is the CIA, and the CIA do have their own cyber espionage systems, NSA not only is not doing their actual job, but they are being redundant.
Which is fine, of course, but why are you trying to speak as if you have authoritative knowledge?
You say that NSA is responsible for cybersecurity within an HR agency because their name has "SECURITY" in it, and as far as I can tell this is meant completely seriously. So should NSA also be responsible for the military defense of the nation since their name has "SECURITY" in it? Should they regulate financial markets because their name has "SECURITY" in it?
In case you wish to know, NSA is responsible for (among other things) 'SIGINT' and 'ELINT'. CIA is responsible for 'HUMINT', 'OSINT', and many other fun things.
Both the NSA and CIA are foreign intelligence agencies, mostly due to historical accident. And of course there's an entirely separate DIA, which also exists mostly due to historical accident, but focuses mainly on military intelligence matters.
For example, your aged grandfather used to run ethernet through pressurized conduit. If that pressure ever dropped some heavily armed men would turn up.
The IP packet header has fields for security classification as well as compartment. If I design warheads and you design rocket engines, our computers are in different compartments so the router between us will drop packets if you and I attempt to discuss our work. However I could invite you to lunch.
What Bradley Manning did was simply not possible. Or rather it would not have been without the Congressional COTS mandate: Common Off-The-Shelf Computers. Rather than design special hardware or write special software for military computing the avionics for the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter were purchased online from Alibaba.
However a problem we really do have is that we have lost our expertise. The COTS mandate lead to less demand for the kinds of engineers who could have prevented this breach.
My friend Murray Sims is a naval civil service coder. He rang me up once to beg me to work for the navy:
"People are dying because of software bugs."
Id love to but I get a little loopy sometimes so have no hope of getting a clearance, instead I write technical articles.
Your friend definitely has a point. People are dying because of software bugs. And process bugs. And outdated hardware.
I agree with you that we have lost our expertise. I think the defense industry in general has a demographics problem. There's a lot of old guys who are about to retire. A lot of young, inexperienced people. And not enough of the mid-career engineers.
I applied to the US Air Force Cyber Command as well as all manner of military computer security jobs. I received but one response, that my application to be an encryption machine trainer was declined.
I was an unclassified subcontractor once. The primary contractor selected me for my expertise with "the part".
What he should have done was to ask me to select the vendor. The part I was asked to write code for had quite a serious design flaw.
I State This That It May Be Rejected:
The Lysistrata Manifesto
http://www.warplife.com/manifestos/lysistrata/
tl;dr: I shall withhold sex until the computer industry fixes its product defects.That got on my nerves.
"'The client' is really, really happy with all the prototype boards that we just soaked The American Taxpayer for."
"Great. Please tell 'The Client' that YOU SELECTED THE WRONG "PART!"
Click.
I have the idea that I could offer the consulting service of selecting 'The Parts' to the extent they are unclassified. They often are. But I dont have the first clue as to how to get started. Among my concerns is that some contractors dont want to pay someone to tell them how to avoid cost overruns.
That was not my intention though I do understand why you took it that way.
I intended to insult the United States Congress.
NASA's system told me that I was not qualified to work on rocket telemetry systems, even though I was then working as a telemetry engineer for the prime contractor on the NSROC II sounding rocket contract.
The Navy's system told me that I was not qualified to work on aircraft instrumentation and telemetry systems for NAVAIR, even though one of my past jobs was as an aircraft instrumentation and telemetry systems engineer for NAVAIR.
My wife has similar anecdotal experiences. She applied for a job with the federal government requiring experience as a K-12 biology teacher. She was rejected even though she worked as a high school biology teacher for almost a decade and won several national awards and two educational fellowships.
Real Soon anow http://wew.warplife.com/jobs/ will redirect to a domain that my brother in law will register for me because my reputation for speaking my mind has made me completely unemployable.
I get deeply frustrated (though I understand where they are coming from) when governments make the argument that they can't take advantage of this or that cloud service because the service's security isn't vetted. Clearly, the security in the backing systems owned by the government isn't sufficiently vetted either, so they're sacrificing velocity for non-security.
I know, it's a flippant attitude. Blame a lousy day. ;)