And sometimes a stock might be entering an index but leaving another (e.g., moving from Russell 2000 to Russell 1000), so the net result might be opposite to what you'd naively expect.
So yes, it is possible to make money doing this, but it's not a sure thing.
The very act of noticing that something is a good strategy, and beginning to trade on it, will over time drain away the utility of the strategy, until it is useless or worse than useless.
Tracking indexes is "big", and has some brute simplicity about it, but eventually the market will eliminate that as a viable investment mechanism. (But that won't stop your metaphorical Dad from swearing up and down you need to buy index funds....)
The argument isn't that passive index investing is some kind of perfectly optimal investing strategy, it's that it's the most practical strategy for 98% of normal small, individual investors. If you don't have millions of dollars to invest, and you have a real job that prevents you from spending all your time researching investment opportunities, then you are probably better off just buying the market, instead of flailing around paying fees and trade commissions trying to beat the market.
If you believe in the weak form of the Efficient Market Hypothesis, and you are not a professional investor, then you should probably be in index funds.
You're almost always better off with an index than the "HR Director Got a Kickback Growth Fund"
Bogle started the First Index Investment Trust on December 31, 1975. Bogle founded The Vanguard Group in 1974; it is now the largest mutual fund company in the United States as of 2009.
[ source : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_fund#Origins ]
I would like to know how.
I'm not suggesting "anybody can do it" but the study that concludes money managers underperform the market often gets stretched into "nothing beats index funds".
Anecdotally, I spend about 3 hours a week on financial research. I've averaged 13% returns since investing in high school during the 90s.
Nothing wrong with index funds, but the boglehead position isn't axiomatic.
+1.
The "making hundreds of millions" part made me laugh too. Bet that's news to the index desks.
Honestly the simplest thing to do is just monitor the big houses and whatever they do en masse do the same. Most giant purchases have to be announced and 10M shares aren't just bought on a whim.
This does not answer the question about ROI.
I personally know 3 people who run their own money ( <5 million ) who do this as their sole form of income.
Having said that, this isn't exactly easy. You need to know
1) if a stock is going into the index
2) when its going into the index
3) how much the index will buy
4) how much the index buy will affect the price of the stock
the first 3 are trivial for some index funds, though most have rules that allow them some leeway here so there aren't always sure things.
The 4th is where you make your money.
And it isn't like there aren't other's doing this, the article makes it seem much easier than it actually is.
If you play the game theory through you'd realize that if you knew the stock is going into the index then you are probably too late to profit from it as someone else will speculate the stock is going to go into the index the week before and already move the stock.
Funds can't really avoid this, and to be honest they don't really care to avoid it. It doesn't affect them at all, they are just supposed to mimic the index. Though you do start to get into a strange feedback loop whereby the index fund that is supposed to track the index starts to dictate how the index moves, we'll call this the "index inception" effect:)