News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Invest in Tools? by benihana on Sunday July 05, 2015 @03:27PM (#9834616)
>so they do have a certain moral obligation to give back.

What moral obligation are you talking about? There's no moral obligation for anyone using open source software to give anything back. Are you aware of how software licenses work?

Re:Why Invest in Tools? by Stratoscope on Sunday July 05, 2015 @04:23PM (#9834770)
There's an interesting nuance in the phrase "a certain moral obligation." In my understanding, it's a fairly weak statement [1], somewhat akin to "People will think more highly of you if you do this thing, and less highly if you don't."

Contrast this with "they have a moral obligation." To me that is a much stronger statement: "People will think you are behaving in an immoral way if you do not do this thing."

It's funny how adding the word "certain" to the phrase actually makes it a less certain, gentler way of putting things - quite the opposite of the literal meaning of the word.

Put another way, I could imagine a law being passed to enforce "a moral obligation". But it seems much less likely to have a law enforcing something described as "a certain moral obligation."

[1] I mean "weak" in the sense of not being a strong claim of obligation, not "weak" in the sense that the phrase is a poor way to say something.

Re:Why Invest in Tools? by ams6110 on Sunday July 05, 2015 @06:25PM (#9835311)
Right, I just meant in a "pay it forward" or "the decent thing to do" sense.
Re:Why Invest in Tools? by ObviousScience on Sunday July 05, 2015 @03:33PM (#9834639)
If you're referring to software license terms, you're making a legal, not a moral argument.