Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by orionblastar on Saturday July 04, 2015 @07:55PM
(#9831984)
Corporations used to hire typists that could use a typewriter to type up copies of letters and memos. They'd have a room of 100 typists all typing away all day for 8+ hours a day for five days a week.
That is until the Word Processor and Laser Printer caught on and then they only needed 1 person to press 100 copies on the Word Processor after typing up the letter and memo. Learning how a PC works and how a Word Processor works requires a higher level skill than a typewriter.
I used to work for a law firm IT department. I was given a series of tasks to automate forms into electric forms that were ASP web based and use Crystal Reports to export to RTF, PDF, XLS format etc. I did my job and the people who used to do the reports by hand got fired. They got replaced with an web app that worked 24/7 for free and stores data on a MS-SQL Server database.
I felt really bad that what I wrote had cost jobs.
Consider web sites that work 24/7 selling items, they put retail stores to be closed and people who work those retail jobs to be fired. Macy's closed down stores near my house and fired people, and my wife orders her dresses from macys.com instead of going to a store now.
Now you might say you need to learn some IT skills to service and support websites and technical issues, but they offshore that work to India and China for cheaper labor. Anything needed on US soil they can hire H1B Visa Workers for cheaper than US citizens to work those jobs. So yes jobs are being created, but some of those jobs goes to foreign workers who can work for a lower cost of labor.
Yes we need a basic income and support it by taxing corporations who use automated programs, AI, and robots to do the jobs that human beings used to do. Also tax the companies that use foreign labor to save on costs. It is because those companies cost native jobs when they do that.
Unemployment only counts those on unemployment insurance, not those who lost unemployment insurance because it ran out or those who ended up on welfare or disability because they couldn't find work.
We have a lot of qualified IT workers with student loan debt who cannot find a job in this country. But they are refused to be hired for silly reasons, or considered overqualified to hire H1b Visa Workers instead.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by dwiel on Saturday July 04, 2015 @09:46PM
(#9832232)
how do you tax based on the use of automated programs, AI and robots? Robots are sort of the easiest, maybe you tax their purchase? Or some kind of yearly 'property' tax on them. What is a robot though? A fax machine? A dish washer?
Taxing automated programs and AI doesn't make any sense to me. You mention that they should be taxed on jobs they've replaced. But what if those jobs never excited in the first place? Should google pay taxes based on how many people it would take to browse the entire internet all the time and track the changes in websites they find?
I'm not completely opposed to the idea of some kind of tax, but I just don't see how it can be reasonably framed. Do you have any specific ideas?
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by JesperRavn on Saturday July 04, 2015 @10:09PM
(#9832279)
Current taxation (e.g. income tax) should be completely fine. The government needs money to redistribute to people who are not doing well financially for any reason. But there is no particular reason to be more generous to people whose poverty is due to technological advancement. As you say, having a job at a given time is a very poor rationale for deserving that job in the future.
We know that technological growth increases the total amount of wealth to go around. If it didn't, companies wouldn't adopt new technologies. The only problem is when technology widens wealth disparities, which is what taxation is there fore in the first place.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by JesperRavn on Saturday July 04, 2015 @11:24PM
(#9832391)
But tax has to hurt someone, and having a job is the least discriminatory way to assign this. Income is a measure of how fast your wealth is growing, and so by taking a proportion of your income, the government takes a proportion of your wealth.
I don't have time to argue (just like you probably don't have time to present a full argument for your side) but the Land Value Tax is based on outdated and wrong economics. Unfortunately because land value tax is so far from the mainstream, there is very little work in mainstream economics directly critiquing the land value tax.
I can only summarize the reasons for it as follows
- Economic theory suggests that the most efficient tax is income tax, because income tax is the least discriminatory.
- Some people like Piketty also recommend a wealth tax, and I agree that a wealth tax might also be useful.
- A land tax would immediately impact the price of all land, since that land will have to pay tax in the future. Therefore the people who bear the impact of the land tax, is whoever owns land when the tax is introduced. That doesn't seem reasonable or fair.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by BENJIIIIIIII on Sunday July 05, 2015 @11:02AM
(#9833760)
Only taxes on produced factors can distort the incentive to produce.
As Land by definition is all that is not produced by human effort, a 100% tax on its rental value cannot therefore lower aggregate wealth and welfare.
Indeed, by putting owner occupiers on the same economic footing as renters, Land is only ever occupied by the Capitalist able to put it to its highest productive use.
So, unlike damaging taxes on income and capital, a LVT actually raises economic output.
Fundamentally, this is because shared land rent is the only fair way of paying for the services we share.
Not only is taxation of income/capital theft, but so is occupation of valuable Land without compensating those excluded.
Also, occupying valuable land is by choice. So, a LVT aligns incentives because it is paid by choice, unlike taxes on income/capital which distort incentives because they are based on coercion.
Any changes to the tax system produces one off winners and losers. This is not legitimate argument against change . Else we'd still suffer institutions like slavery.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by JesperRavn on Sunday July 05, 2015 @09:52PM
(#9836172)
Hope this helps.
Was that intended to convey that you are speaking authoritatively and I'm uninformed? If so, what is the basis for your authority on this topic? The vast majority of economists recommend income, consumption or value-added taxes, not land value taxes.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by ende on Sunday July 05, 2015 @03:24AM
(#9832823)
Income is not a measure of how fast your wealth is growing, it's a measure of how much salary and wage earners are compensated on a regular interval. Many people earn income without necessarily earning wealth. If you want to target wealth, you need to target capital and the source of its generation. The Land Value Tax is exactly that, and it's not 'outdated and wrong economics' (whatever that is supposed to mean). The LVT is highly regarded among economists as among the most efficient taxes. If anything its conception was ahead of its time, as its single shortcoming was the impracticality of determining unimproved land values in the early 1900s before computers existed.
To address your points:
1) Nonsense. The income tax is discriminatory against anyone who makes an income. Many of the 1% don't rely upon income but rather capital dividends.
2) Piketty's ideas require world-wide coordination of wealth taxation dragnets; a highly unlikely proposition. The LVT on the other hand is a wealth tax that cannot be evaded through a Swiss bank account.
3) Not really sure what you're trying to say here. Any tax immediately impacts the price of whatever it is it is taxing. An income tax impacts the cost of labor, and its introduction likewise impacted all those who were earning an income when the tax was introduced. What is your point here? One of the reasons the LVT is so highly regarded among economists is because of its minimal economic impacts.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by JesperRavn on Sunday July 05, 2015 @06:03PM
(#9835230)
the LVT is highly regarded among economists as among the most efficient taxes.
Almost no mainstream economists recommend a land value tax. For example, consult any graduate or undergraduate textbook. I would challenge you to find a single professor in a top 20 school who advocates a land value tax as the primary form of taxation.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by ende on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:09AM
(#9836717)
LVT has maintained support among mainstream economists as recent as Milton Friedman, Joseph Stiglitz, Paul Krugman, and Tyler Cowen. I have no idea where you are getting your misconceptions from.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by JesperRavn on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:09AM
(#9837089)
Friedman and Stiglitz yes, but they are not very recent (in terms of when they produced their main work) but for the others
Tyler Cowen [0]:
So I take the Georgist view to imply two claims. First, it is easier or better to tax barebones land than barebones labor. Second, taxing a factor directly is much better than taxing complements of that factor. Since I am not convinced either of these are true, I hold no particular attachment to the idea of a single tax on land
Paul Krugman [1]:
"Believe it or not, urban economics models actually do suggest that Georgist taxation would be the right approach at least to finance city growth. But I would just say: I don’t think you can raise nearly enough money to run a modern welfare state by taxing land [only]."
>I have no idea where you are getting your misconceptions from.
I'm pretty sure you are getting yours from Wikipedia.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by tzs on Saturday July 04, 2015 @11:40PM
(#9832415)
> But tax has to hurt someone
But that someone does not have to be human. Emancipate the robots, so that they cannot be owned by the companies who use their output. The robots instead voluntarily give their output to the companies in which they work (because they were designed to do so) in exchange for power and maintenance, but after the government takes a cut from the robot via taxation.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by JesperRavn on Saturday July 04, 2015 @11:43PM
(#9832423)
No, it has to be someone human. Without taxation, people would consume a certain amount. When you tax, someone's consumption has to go down, in order for the government to have something to redistribute/spend.
In your example, when you "emancipated" the robots, you effectively taxed whoever owned them at the time. If not for the emancipation, the owner would have received the income that the government was receiving.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by analog31 on Saturday July 04, 2015 @09:01PM
(#9832136)
What I don't understand is where robots will get their jobs if nobody can afford the stuff that they make. Consumption by poor and middle class people is needed in order to spur development of the technologies that the rich enjoy. If there are only 1000 people who can afford an iPhone, or to drive cars on roads, there will be no way to finance the development of iPhones (plus infrastructure) or roads. This could be the Medieval economy, where the rich were really barely richer than the poor by today's standards. If the rich want sustainable wealth, in the long run, they have to figure out how to maintain consumption by the poor, either by coming up with new labor-intensive occupations, or providing basic income.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by JesperRavn on Saturday July 04, 2015 @10:04PM
(#9832267)
While I support redistribution for its own sake, the idea that the economy is driven by consumption is false. Even Keynes would not have said so: it is only during recessions that Keynes (correctly) said that the economy needed to be stimulated.
If there are only 1000 people who can afford an iPhone, or to drive cars on roads, there will be no way to finance the development of iPhones (plus infrastructure) or roads.
This kind of verbal reasoning was replaced by mathematical models in economics. The most fundamental such model is called General Equilibrium Theory, which states that the economy is driven by the creation of value (see sibling post) and as long as the technology to create value increases, so will the total value of the economy. Keynes (who set the tone for all subsequent macroeconomics) pointed out a major deviation from General Equilibrium Theory can occur, where the economy produces less than its theoretical output. To remedy this, he recommended fiscal stimulus (e.g. "coming up with new labor-intensive occupations") but this was only a short term measure. In ordinary times, Keynes did not recommend fiscal (or monetary) stimulus.
Now in practice, zero redistribution of wealth would result in a really terrible society, and the negative externalities from poverty (and extreme wealth) would probably result in much lower economic growth. Wealth redistribution is not only ethical, but also makes a more stable and orderly society. Nonetheless, the fundamental reasoning that growth is drive by consumption per se, is wrong.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by skybrian on Saturday July 04, 2015 @11:21PM
(#9832387)
If you wanted to publish an economics paper then you'd need to come up with a mathematical model, but that doesn't mean all non-mathematical reasoning can be dismissed so easily.
We don't need to work out the model to realize that a world in which Apple only manufactured phones for millionaires would be quite different than today's world.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by JesperRavn on Saturday July 04, 2015 @11:28PM
(#9832396)
No you really do need a model, because right now you are talking about the whole economy, but only analysing a part of it. If you want to talk about the mechanisms by which the economy operates, such as consumption driving economic growth, then you need a model.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by Animats on Saturday July 04, 2015 @10:38PM
(#9832324)
"What I don't understand is where robots will get their jobs if nobody can afford the stuff that they make."
Exactly. In the US, there's plenty of capital, vast productive capacity, and a shortage of demand. The CEO of WalMart says that their customer base is spent out. One of Wal-Mart's metrics is same-store sales over the course of a month. By the end of the month, sales are down and are mostly basic necessities. That's what it looks like in mass-market retail.
There's a stable state where most of the population has a low income, can't buy much, and is barely participating in the economy. This is the normal condition in the parts of the world that have huge urban slums surrounding a rich city core. The US may be headed there. The "micro-houses" of today are the favelas of tomorrow.
More productivity only makes it worse. That's what's so frustrating.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by ams6110 on Saturday July 04, 2015 @09:10PM
(#9832154)
The whole driver of an economy is creation of value. Handing someone a basic income does not create any value, it just transfers it. It's unsustainable.
Re:So About That Whole Tech-Eating-Jobs Thing
by jwatte on Saturday July 04, 2015 @09:52PM
(#9832242)
Society-wide, technology is a human output multiplier. Over time, people without jobs will find or create new jobs, and overall output increases.
The question is not "how many jobs does technology destroy," but "how nimbly will this new resource of human time be harnessed?"
That is until the Word Processor and Laser Printer caught on and then they only needed 1 person to press 100 copies on the Word Processor after typing up the letter and memo. Learning how a PC works and how a Word Processor works requires a higher level skill than a typewriter.
I used to work for a law firm IT department. I was given a series of tasks to automate forms into electric forms that were ASP web based and use Crystal Reports to export to RTF, PDF, XLS format etc. I did my job and the people who used to do the reports by hand got fired. They got replaced with an web app that worked 24/7 for free and stores data on a MS-SQL Server database.
I felt really bad that what I wrote had cost jobs.
Consider web sites that work 24/7 selling items, they put retail stores to be closed and people who work those retail jobs to be fired. Macy's closed down stores near my house and fired people, and my wife orders her dresses from macys.com instead of going to a store now.
Now you might say you need to learn some IT skills to service and support websites and technical issues, but they offshore that work to India and China for cheaper labor. Anything needed on US soil they can hire H1B Visa Workers for cheaper than US citizens to work those jobs. So yes jobs are being created, but some of those jobs goes to foreign workers who can work for a lower cost of labor.
Yes we need a basic income and support it by taxing corporations who use automated programs, AI, and robots to do the jobs that human beings used to do. Also tax the companies that use foreign labor to save on costs. It is because those companies cost native jobs when they do that.
Unemployment only counts those on unemployment insurance, not those who lost unemployment insurance because it ran out or those who ended up on welfare or disability because they couldn't find work.
We have a lot of qualified IT workers with student loan debt who cannot find a job in this country. But they are refused to be hired for silly reasons, or considered overqualified to hire H1b Visa Workers instead.
Taxing automated programs and AI doesn't make any sense to me. You mention that they should be taxed on jobs they've replaced. But what if those jobs never excited in the first place? Should google pay taxes based on how many people it would take to browse the entire internet all the time and track the changes in websites they find?
I'm not completely opposed to the idea of some kind of tax, but I just don't see how it can be reasonably framed. Do you have any specific ideas?
We know that technological growth increases the total amount of wealth to go around. If it didn't, companies wouldn't adopt new technologies. The only problem is when technology widens wealth disparities, which is what taxation is there fore in the first place.
I don't have time to argue (just like you probably don't have time to present a full argument for your side) but the Land Value Tax is based on outdated and wrong economics. Unfortunately because land value tax is so far from the mainstream, there is very little work in mainstream economics directly critiquing the land value tax.
I can only summarize the reasons for it as follows
- Economic theory suggests that the most efficient tax is income tax, because income tax is the least discriminatory.
- Some people like Piketty also recommend a wealth tax, and I agree that a wealth tax might also be useful.
- A land tax would immediately impact the price of all land, since that land will have to pay tax in the future. Therefore the people who bear the impact of the land tax, is whoever owns land when the tax is introduced. That doesn't seem reasonable or fair.
As Land by definition is all that is not produced by human effort, a 100% tax on its rental value cannot therefore lower aggregate wealth and welfare.
Indeed, by putting owner occupiers on the same economic footing as renters, Land is only ever occupied by the Capitalist able to put it to its highest productive use.
So, unlike damaging taxes on income and capital, a LVT actually raises economic output.
Fundamentally, this is because shared land rent is the only fair way of paying for the services we share.
Not only is taxation of income/capital theft, but so is occupation of valuable Land without compensating those excluded.
Also, occupying valuable land is by choice. So, a LVT aligns incentives because it is paid by choice, unlike taxes on income/capital which distort incentives because they are based on coercion.
Any changes to the tax system produces one off winners and losers. This is not legitimate argument against change . Else we'd still suffer institutions like slavery.
Hope this helps.
Was that intended to convey that you are speaking authoritatively and I'm uninformed? If so, what is the basis for your authority on this topic? The vast majority of economists recommend income, consumption or value-added taxes, not land value taxes.
To address your points:
1) Nonsense. The income tax is discriminatory against anyone who makes an income. Many of the 1% don't rely upon income but rather capital dividends.
2) Piketty's ideas require world-wide coordination of wealth taxation dragnets; a highly unlikely proposition. The LVT on the other hand is a wealth tax that cannot be evaded through a Swiss bank account.
3) Not really sure what you're trying to say here. Any tax immediately impacts the price of whatever it is it is taxing. An income tax impacts the cost of labor, and its introduction likewise impacted all those who were earning an income when the tax was introduced. What is your point here? One of the reasons the LVT is so highly regarded among economists is because of its minimal economic impacts.
Almost no mainstream economists recommend a land value tax. For example, consult any graduate or undergraduate textbook. I would challenge you to find a single professor in a top 20 school who advocates a land value tax as the primary form of taxation.
Tyler Cowen [0]:
So I take the Georgist view to imply two claims. First, it is easier or better to tax barebones land than barebones labor. Second, taxing a factor directly is much better than taxing complements of that factor. Since I am not convinced either of these are true, I hold no particular attachment to the idea of a single tax on land
Paul Krugman [1]:
"Believe it or not, urban economics models actually do suggest that Georgist taxation would be the right approach at least to finance city growth. But I would just say: I don’t think you can raise nearly enough money to run a modern welfare state by taxing land [only]."
>I have no idea where you are getting your misconceptions from.
I'm pretty sure you are getting yours from Wikipedia.
[0] http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2005/02/why...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax
But that someone does not have to be human. Emancipate the robots, so that they cannot be owned by the companies who use their output. The robots instead voluntarily give their output to the companies in which they work (because they were designed to do so) in exchange for power and maintenance, but after the government takes a cut from the robot via taxation.
In your example, when you "emancipated" the robots, you effectively taxed whoever owned them at the time. If not for the emancipation, the owner would have received the income that the government was receiving.
in other words tanstaafl
If there are only 1000 people who can afford an iPhone, or to drive cars on roads, there will be no way to finance the development of iPhones (plus infrastructure) or roads.
This kind of verbal reasoning was replaced by mathematical models in economics. The most fundamental such model is called General Equilibrium Theory, which states that the economy is driven by the creation of value (see sibling post) and as long as the technology to create value increases, so will the total value of the economy. Keynes (who set the tone for all subsequent macroeconomics) pointed out a major deviation from General Equilibrium Theory can occur, where the economy produces less than its theoretical output. To remedy this, he recommended fiscal stimulus (e.g. "coming up with new labor-intensive occupations") but this was only a short term measure. In ordinary times, Keynes did not recommend fiscal (or monetary) stimulus.
Now in practice, zero redistribution of wealth would result in a really terrible society, and the negative externalities from poverty (and extreme wealth) would probably result in much lower economic growth. Wealth redistribution is not only ethical, but also makes a more stable and orderly society. Nonetheless, the fundamental reasoning that growth is drive by consumption per se, is wrong.
We don't need to work out the model to realize that a world in which Apple only manufactured phones for millionaires would be quite different than today's world.
Exactly. In the US, there's plenty of capital, vast productive capacity, and a shortage of demand. The CEO of WalMart says that their customer base is spent out. One of Wal-Mart's metrics is same-store sales over the course of a month. By the end of the month, sales are down and are mostly basic necessities. That's what it looks like in mass-market retail.
There's a stable state where most of the population has a low income, can't buy much, and is barely participating in the economy. This is the normal condition in the parts of the world that have huge urban slums surrounding a rich city core. The US may be headed there. The "micro-houses" of today are the favelas of tomorrow.
More productivity only makes it worse. That's what's so frustrating.
The whole driver of an economy is the transfer of value.
(See, it's easy to say vapid things and not back them up.)
Nobody = other robots?