I think she is trying to paint the "blackout" as the same as the fatpeoplehate banning, which created similar, but different shitstrom. Some people even believe that.
But this is different - the fatpeoplehate incident was about hateful people no longer being able to feely practice their hate and harassment.
Blackout is about people realizing they are on the ship, and the captain has no idea what she's doing, and the ship has quite a few icebergs in the way.
Luckily there's many other ships you can jump off to if the iceberg gets too close.
People migrated from Digg to Reddit. People will migrate from Reddit to whatever will come next if the need should arise.
I wonder if they received an influx of traffic following the Great Reddit Blackout of 2015 and thought it was worth investigating if they could spin an immigration to match the emigration from Digg after their own past community mistrust issues.
I think we've all be on the internet long enough to see vibrant communities (usenet, forums, MUDs, myspace, etc.) bloom and wilt away. If Reddit cannot provide a high level of value to the people that generate content within the community they will migrate away to an environment that does.
Unlike Usenet, though, it provides simple editing, pictures, video, and some other things people want.
But search sucks.
There's a lot of other former Redditors making the migration there too.
That being said, if you like it, go for it.
Even though I admit reddit is a strange place, somewhat halfway between a company and a governing body with democracy-like structure. Still, given the sheer amount of userbase, it's unlikely that the activism of the mods and a chuck of active users (who are upvoting the boycott related posts) would seriously affect it (i.e., bring the website down in the long term). Probably such internal decisions would change the flavor/nature of the website.
To use a clear topical analogy, people weren't upset about Michael Brown per se to the point of rioting in the streets. His case was just a rallying point for frustrations over perceived systemic police abuse of power.
I agree with the main point, though, that you shouldn't fuck with the reddit community.
*Edit: I'm a redditor in the 9 year club.
I'm curious what you mean by "loyal", then.
> The 'vocal minority' are the content creators and contributors.
That term, content creator. That's a bit disingenuous in this case. It's rare for anyone to create content specifically for reddit, the vast majority of this content you're talking about is re-posted to reddit from other sources.
> Reddit, as it becomes more mainstream
Reddit is one of the largest sites on the internet, how much more mainstream does it need to get before you stop characterizing it as "becoming mainstream"?
The truth is, the company made a decision and the moderators got ansty and threw the users under the bus in an attempt to make a power play.
The most virulent detractors were a vocal minority, they were the mods of a few large subreddits.
r/AskScience also has a lot of AMAs, and so was directly affected by Victoria's firing in a way that most other subs were not.
It sounds like any well-moderated, decently large subreddit would have reason to be pissed.
That r/shitredditsays is celebrating shows that mistreatment has not been happening to them.
Worf, Buzz Aldrin, Obama, Bill Gates, Elon Musk ..
The people who "revolting" this time were the people who brought us these. I don't think it's fair to write them off as re-posters; they've put huge, huge amounts of time and effort into curating some of the most engaging original content reddit has ever seen.
It's a high-traffic site, sure, but I wouldn't call it mainstream. I would consider much lower trafficked sites like Expedia, Zappos and Huffington Post more "mainstream".
This is an incredible simplification.
If we follow the 90-9-1 model: 1% of reddit's user base contributes new content, 9% interacts with that content, and 90% are lurkers and consumers. The 'vocal minority' are the content creators and contributors.
Reddit has hardly changed in its existence. Things like a search that works or reasonable moderator tools have been promised for years to no avail. Reddit has never had any decent product leadership, but their attempt to reign in control of content has been disastrous.
Moderating content outside of removing illegal content is a really slippery slope. It's incredibly difficult to get content standards right. Reddit, as it becomes more mainstream, seems like its trying to get content standards under control, but the cost is immense and might eventually end up alienating its userbase.