I use bookmarks for frequently visited sites, and a few select references. Using them for content management... really doesn't work particularly well.
Instead I actually download and save stuff I realliy want (and am actively looking for better tools to manage and organize that, though Zotero and Calibre are a start). I'd been using Readability somewhat, but it gets really inconvenient after a few hundred items (I've got 1000+ now).
At least with site-specific curation you've got stuff saved in some sort of context, though, frankly, that doesn't much work either.
It's a long-standing frustration of mine. Though it was actually kind of refreshing to read Vannevar Bush's Memex document a few days back which basically expressed the same concern from 1945.