News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by res0nat0r on Friday July 03, 2015 @12:29PM (#9826492)
I'm no stock expert, but I still don't see how people are getting "screwed" by hft. If you are concerned about a price fluxation just place a limit order. Simple as that. If you don't care, then place a market order. There's always been someone out there with more information, smarter people, and now faster connections than you. It's never been a level playing field and will never be.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by avz on Friday July 03, 2015 @12:50PM (#9826615)
The fundamental idea of algorithmic trading doesn't really fall into the category of screwing-people-over. However, some techniques employed by institutions engaged in it can easily be seen as outright cheating. One common example is front running [1] where a player with access to real-time order information exploits the knowledge of pending trades from other players to turn a profit at the other players' expense. These techniques can also be used across exchanges.

The issue is a consequence of the lack of market transparency. The exchanges are only required to make order information public with a significant delay. However, they sell the real-time order information to a few market players enabling them to engage in the dubious tactics at the expense of other players.

Note that tactics like front running used to be employed by brokers before algorithmic trading and have since been banned.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Front_running

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by tptacek on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:46PM (#9826914)
In order front-run someone, you must have a fiduciary duty to them. HFTs do not.

When you think about this broader proposed definition of front-running, where any anticipatory trading is "front-running", you quickly realize that virtually any informed trade could be described that way. Do extensive research on the supply chain of a billion dollar industry, notice a spike somewhere, and trade on that? You're front-running!

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by tedks on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:07PM (#9826702)
>The exchanges are only required to make order information public with a significant delay. However, they sell the real-time order information to a few market players enabling them to engage in the dubious tactics at the expense of other players.

It's easy to see why you view this as unfair.

But it is fair. Anyone can buy the real-time information if they have the capital.

Obviously markets are going to be more friendly towards you the more money you throw at them.

Just like everything else in capitalism, the fairness comes from anyone being able to have money. If you think this is unfair, you're essentially opposing capitalism.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by MereInterest on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:49PM (#9827270)
I'm having a hard time figuring out whether you are being facetious or not. What you are describing is nepotism and bribery, not capitalism.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by vegabook on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:07PM (#9826705)
The idea that HFT is front running any more than a human market maker is a fallacy. What HFT does, is to properly price the liquidity in the market. Previously, large institutional or more likely hedge fund orders would be priced very tightly, because it was in the market maker's interest to know the direction of the flow. By "winning" the trade he/she would have an information advantage on the subsequent likely move in the market (a good assumption here is that flow directions are auto-correlated, with a higher autocorrelation to important customers, which is why this makes economic sense). Armed with this information, said market maker would then pre-position against some of the slower "less in the know" flows who are inevitably triggered by price action, with such price action of course influenced by the market maker himself who can "dribble" out the big position at his leisure. He is "armed" with a position that he can move the market with. Such pre-positioning was profitable as smaller investors reacted to price action and sold. It was basically a game of "I pay for your directional information through tight bid offer for the privileged few".

HFT says the following. If you start selling, then I will move the price downwards in accordance to my best guess as to the size of your flow. If I see serial sell orders, I will move the price subsequently lower on the evidence. I am pricing your liquidity correctly. Thus, if you are a huge hedge fund shorting the market, you face higher transaction costs because the liquidity you are demanding of the market is high, and the market maker can no longer offset your liquidity cost against ripping off smaller investors who will be stopped. This latter is the key point. In fact, for smaller investors, HFT means bid offers are much tighter. If you put a small order through the market you are instaneously filled almost at mid, thanks to HFT, whereas in the old days, retail would pay the same bid/offer for his tiny flow as huge hedge fund. The converse is true for buy orders, obviously.

Have you wondered why HFT is most hated by large institutional funds? It's because suddenly they have to pay a fair price for their huge liquidity requirements.

HFT has short-circuited the old game where large influential funds obtained tight bid offer at the expense of smaller players, and were thus able to dominate markets by trading size at unrealistically tight prices. Now we all pay for our liquidity at a fair price. It's actually really democratic (keeping in mind that competition is mega-fierce).

Ultimately, those who accuse HFT of front running are 100% correct. But there is always "statistical" front running (autocorrelation remember), HFT or Human. The difference now with HFT is that the cost of this front running is proportional to the size of your flow, and thus for smaller/retail investors it is neglibeable (because pricing is now much tigher than under the old "human" regime), and therefore positive, but for the spoiled insitutional investors / hedge funds, used to being privileged, it is back to a level playing field. Need to sell a yard? Need to pay for that buddy. Not good for them.

(obviously I am schematizing to a certain degree. Even humans price large orders wider. It's just they didn't price those large orders anything like wide enough. They sponsored the big client for the info advantage thus earned, info advantage wielded against the rest of the market: read smaller, and/or less in the know, investors).

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by dllthomas on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:14PM (#9826751)
I don't follow what you say here - my understanding has it that spreads have grown tighter since computerizing things (and generally that a tighter spread is more efficient).
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:38PM (#9826872)
The spread is tight for small orders, but if you keep hitting them in one direction, market makers quickly get wise to this and start pulling back. The cost to trade for large funds isn't just the bid-offer spread, but also how quickly the market reacts to their flow. Modern market makers are very good at pricing a small spread to uninformed flow while making informed traders pay.

This is also why big funds want rules like trade-at (all orders must trade on-exchange) which eliminate the ability for market makers to explicitly segregate order flow. If all retail orders went to exchanges, market makers would give tighter prices on average to win the retail flows. Basically retail traders would subsidize institutional ones.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by tptacek on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:54PM (#9826947)
Modern market makers are very good at pricing a small spread to uninformed flow while making informed traders pay.

My understanding was that it's mostly the opposite, that MMs profit from uninformed order flow (so much so that they'll buy access to it from brokerages), and that informed traders were their predators in the market food chain.

At any rate: cost of trading has by every account I can find plummeted since the introduction of automatic trading. As recently as the 1990s, spreads were quoted in eighths of dollars, and there was widespread collusion to fix prices at quarters. In 70s and before, the markets were worse; basically organized fleecing operations.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:09PM (#9827040)
Yes I mean if I think the fair price of a stock is $100, and I knew who I was trading with, I might bid 99.99 offer 100.01 to a retail trader, but bid 99.95 offer 100.05 to a bank or hedge fund. The retail trader probably doesn't have short-term info and he's not going to keep trading in the same direction so I don't need to make as much spread.

On exchange markets you can't really tell who you trade with so you have to guess.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by vegabook on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:31PM (#9826832)
That's my point. For the vast majority of (smaller) flows HFT makes bid/offer tighter. TLDR on the above: HFT makes you pay a fair price for your liquidity requirement. If you're retail, your liquidity requirement is negligeable. If you're big your liquidity price is high. It's fairer.

In the old human system big funds' artificially high (cheap) liquidity is sponsored by the small player's artificially expensive liquidity and/or market move against him/her before he/she trades.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by foobarqux on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:21PM (#9827112)
It's more complicated than you suggest: If informed trading can't capture a good portion of the difference between the "true" price and the current price then there isn't an incentive to do it.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by res0nat0r on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:02PM (#9826676)
Front running is already illegal, so if any group is doing that they are already breaking the rules of the game, and should be punished/stopped if found out.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by JesperRavn on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:17PM (#9826765)
What some HFT traders are doing is economically equivalent to front-running, but is not legally front running since they are not front running the orders of their own clients. All of this is explained in the article, so if you disagree, it would make more sense to read it, find the parts you disagree with, and argue against them, rather than skim the article and then argue with our collective rehashing of the article's argument.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by kasey_junk on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:53PM (#9826945)
The problem is that front running requires 2 things:

- the ability to see orders ahead of someone, which this article implies you can, but you can't. - the fiduciary duty not to use someone's intent to trade against them.

HFT traders do not fall into either camp. They can't see your order before it goes to an exchange and they don't have a duty not to change their prices on one exchange in reaction to price moves on other exchanges.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by JesperRavn on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:02PM (#9826995)
The article claims that by colocating in one exchange, HFT can see you order arrive at exchange A, and send orders to exchange B before your order reaches exchange B. I don't know if this is true, but this is the most important part of the article. Given the fixed latency they introduce, you can send your trades to IEX before sending to any other exchange, safe in the knowledge that no other exchange will react to that information before your order.

No one is talking about the fiduciary duty. Fiduciary duty is just a way to define a default contract into law. E.g. brokers could write a contract saying that they promise not to front run. But since this is something that almost every client would want, it's just written into law instead.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by kasey_junk on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:16PM (#9827081)
There is a major caveat to what they are reporting that gets to the heart of this.

HFT can't see your order as it arrives on exchange A before it arrives on exchange B, they can see the results of an order. That is, they can see a large trade happened on price X on A. With that information they may want to change their prices on exchange B and they may be able to do that before you can also place an order on B.

There are lots of ways to mitigate this other than using a dark pool like IEX. All the exchanges offer exotic order types to make this easier for instance, and large block traders have for years had execution algorithms that spread their orders around venues and over time to minimize price impact.

That IEX offers another option for large block traders does not bother me at all, that they market it via underhanded moralizing i find distasteful.

Finally, in this context front-running has a specific meaning and it requires a fiduciary duty for it to be front running. By using that term incorrectly you ARE bringing fiduciary duty into the conversation, whether you want to or not.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by lucozade on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:25PM (#9827133)
Frontrunning is a crime because it's acting on privileged information. It's in the same boat as insider dealing. They have that privileged info because of their fiduciary relationship so it is relevant.

What the HFT guys are doing is not frontrunning because anyone can get hold of the same information they have (for a price). That information is not privileged (assuming deep pockets != privilege) so it's not frontrunning.

They're getting to the trade first because they're technically quicker than the routers the banks are using.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:32PM (#9826835)
That's a huge difference though. A broker owes a duty to his client not to screw him over. He's supposed to be helping the client. A prop trader has no duty to others in the market. He's their adversary. They're both competing to buy underpriced shares and sell overpriced ones.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by JesperRavn on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:40PM (#9826883)
For the purposes of this discussion, it's not a difference at all. The question is not what should be legal or not, but what customers would prefer, and what makes a better market.

If you ask a customer "would you like an exchange that gives people enough information to front run your order" or "would you like a broker who front runs your order" the answer in both cases would be a resounding no. The claim in the article is that you can create a better exchange by providing an equal footing for all participants.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:55PM (#9826957)
Everybody wants to trade with no price impact. If you asked me if anyone else should be allowed to colocate their servers, I'd say no, just give me a monopoly please. One participant's desires don't make a good market.

Fair and non-discriminatory access to exchanges (not free, but anybody can pay to compete if they wish), fast trading engines and deep order book information are what let traders put up such tight spreads for customers in the first place. Vigorous competition between all market participants keeps prices fair.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by JesperRavn on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:25PM (#9827134)
EDIT: I think you are right, although I would express things a bit differently. I'm writing a top level post with my thoughts.

ORIGINAL POST: When you make a trade, there are some information rents associated with that trade. If someone knew you were about to trade, they could capture all of those rents. When there is a monopoly on exploiting these information rents (as in frontrunning), they will be captured by the frontrunner. When there is perfect competition (as when a number of HFTs can trade in another exchange before your trade reaches it), these rents will be all wasted on technology to maximize speed, i.e. no one gets them, they become deadweight loss.

I understand that there are other issues, such as knowing whether a trade comes from a single seller or multiple smaller sellers. But this is a separate issue from simply trading ahead of other people. I don't understand why it's so controversial that an exchange would advertise the fact that traders can rely on their orders reaching the exchange before anyone else knows about it as a good thing.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @03:26PM (#9827495)
The original trader still has the ability to capture his information rents in a single trade on one market. Nobody can see it and step away or react before the execution goes through. That's all anyone is guaranteed. HFTs face the same problem. If they're trying to cross the spread to put on a trade or hedge, they also have market impact costs and slippage.

I think it's controversial because a lot of their marketing implies all HFTs do this as their primary business and thus add very little value. It creates this narrative of a parasitic activity that intermediates trades which would have already occurred where no risk is taken. I don't think that's the case in reality. All HFT strategies are looking at order books in the products they trade, and they definitely make money (or avoid losses) when someone executes inefficiently across exchanges, but there's more to it than that. HFTs are very successful in futures and non-US markets where products trade on a single exchange. How do they do that if they aren't good at predicting prices and taking risk?

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by JesperRavn on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:22PM (#9827730)
>The original trader still has the ability to capture his information rents in a single trade on one market... That's all anyone is guaranteed

Yes this is the essence of it. Based on other posts, I would guess that if you really wanted to make simultaneous trades in multiple markets, then you could. But even if HFT really did render this impossible, it's not a bad thing, since it trading in two exchanges simultaneously actually gives more rents to the large trader than the theoretical ideal of a single continuous double auction. And if you want to trade in A then trade in B based on the results of A, then you certainly don't deserve to be the first to make it to B.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by blazespin on Friday July 03, 2015 @12:47PM (#9826590)
Well, you can disable front running with your own exchange which is what he is doing. And it seems to be working (he is getting liquidity, their average market share has tripled from .4% to 1.1%)

This is much better than the government stepping in, so I am very glad he is doing it. We'll see if he can keep up the growth.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by res0nat0r on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:00PM (#9826665)
Front running is already illegal.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:28PM (#9826813)
I guess in modern terms "front running" really just means getting arbed. If someone fast sees prices move in one market, they can buy at a relatively unfair price elsewhere, even sometimes outrunning the person who moved prices in the first place. That's not really a bad thing. It makes prices move together and spreads out liquidity across markets. It's also not risk-free money. Even a pure arb has legging risk.

A lot of dark pools have orders "pegged" to the mid-market of the best bid and offer. For example if a stock is $100.01 bid offered at $100.02, the order would float at $100.015 and adjust as the price moves. If the market moves rapidly, and a fast trader sees it go $100.02 bid offered at $100.03, sometimes they can trade with the pegged order at $100.015 before the system knows the price even moved. Make a half-penny, rinse, repeat a million times. At least that's the story.

IEX prevents some of this by computing their reference price in real-time that's used to determine where orders can execute and where pegged orders are priced, while delaying incoming orders by 350 microseconds so nobody can outrun their calculation of the best bid and offer to pick off stale orders. Mind you, this isn't even a real issue in markets today. There are a million ways to trade orders that are statistically mispriced before the market actually moves, so everyone will be taking them with these predictions with little left for the guys doing a pure arb. If you blindly peg your order to any benchmark, you are going to lose.

Also, there was already a market solution for this. Off-exchange markets have discretion on who they allow in and who can interact with one another. If you do nothing but arb slow orders in their pool, they'll either kick you out or restrict who you can trade with.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by foobarqux on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:29PM (#9827162)
> There are a million ways to trade orders that are statistically mispriced before the market actually moves,

Can you talk more about this?

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @03:41PM (#9827563)
Too close to secret sauce territory, but if you can predict the market is more likely to tick up than tick down or vice versa, then buying or selling at mid-market is +EV. Here are some publicly-available examples that are too well-known to work anymore, basically various features of the order book: http://www.orie.cornell.edu/engineering2/customcf/iws_events...
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by msandford on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:07PM (#9826706)
So is the police killing someone on a "nickel ride" like what recently happened in Baltimore. But if there's no enforcement of the laws, or if the regulators disagree with the sentiment of the rest of the population, the notional illegality of such activities is of little practical value.
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:46PM (#9826918)
Do you think it should be illegal to look at the order book for a stock (public info), formulate a prediction, and trade on that prediction? Seems much different than a broker trading ahead of his client.

Large informed traders and intermediaries like specialists/locals/market makers have been in a cat & mouse game since the dawn of time. Back in the day, big hedge funds would split their orders through multiple brokers or try to make their intentions. It's natural that one seeks to hide his intentions and buy/sell without moving the price the other wants to get the hell out of the way or trade with the big order. That's just competition.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by res0nat0r on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:27PM (#9826807)
So front running is currently rampant in every area of the NYSE and the regulators are looking the other way?
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by msandford on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:32PM (#9827785)
Before you try and suggest that the financial authorities are 100% competent, I would remind you that Bernie Madoff did in fact dupe many people for many years. Financial authorities included. In fact it was a non-governmental person who blew the whistle and starting the whole thing tumbling down.

So I'm not saying that it's rampant and everyone is looking the other way. But it's definitely a possibility. What people are SUPPOSED to do and what they ACTUALLY do often don't overlap anywhere near enough.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by dkfsls on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:10PM (#9826721)
There are a few problems with that.

Exchanges make it difficult to know the current price. They sell fast data feeds to HFT shops allowing them to know about price changes before the rest of the market participants.

Exchanges have tons of order types, not just limit and market orders. There are order types that specifically benefit HFT shops by allowing them to pick off limit and market orders. If you put in a limit BUY order for $10 and the current price is $9.90. There is a big difference between executing at $10 vs $9.90 on large orders. If a HFT shop is able to push the price up to $10 (there are a few ways to do this), you just lost a lot of money and probably made the HFT a nice paycheck when the price reverts back to $9.90.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by kasey_junk on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:44PM (#9826907)
There are also order types the specifically advantage large block traders at the expense of HFT market makers. IEX only offers those interestingly, while speaking out about the others.

There is also a big difference between pricing something at 9.90 when you think there is very little demand for it, and being prevented from changing the price when the demand changes.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by sneak on Friday July 03, 2015 @12:42PM (#9826560)
Then why are we seeing market demand for his service?
Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by kasey_junk on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:42PM (#9826897)
The cynical answer to this is good marketing and savvy backers with a vested interest in getting retail customers to trade at a disadvantage.

The less cynical answer is that trading has always been a back and forth between sophisticated actors, some of which make money providing liquidity and some of which make money others ways but buying liquidity is a cost. The cheaper the latter can get from the former the better it is for them.

IEX is a dark pool setup directly for the benefit of savvy hedge fund types to move large blocks of trades and pass on those costs to others. Nothing wrong with it, but their moralizing in books is a little off putting.

Re:A trading platform that outlaws what it sees as abusive p... by mrchicity on Friday July 03, 2015 @01:40PM (#9826882)
Advertising 101: Fear monger. Sell solution to the fear.