This is also why big funds want rules like trade-at (all orders must trade on-exchange) which eliminate the ability for market makers to explicitly segregate order flow. If all retail orders went to exchanges, market makers would give tighter prices on average to win the retail flows. Basically retail traders would subsidize institutional ones.
My understanding was that it's mostly the opposite, that MMs profit from uninformed order flow (so much so that they'll buy access to it from brokerages), and that informed traders were their predators in the market food chain.
At any rate: cost of trading has by every account I can find plummeted since the introduction of automatic trading. As recently as the 1990s, spreads were quoted in eighths of dollars, and there was widespread collusion to fix prices at quarters. In 70s and before, the markets were worse; basically organized fleecing operations.
On exchange markets you can't really tell who you trade with so you have to guess.
In the old human system big funds' artificially high (cheap) liquidity is sponsored by the small player's artificially expensive liquidity and/or market move against him/her before he/she trades.
HFT says the following. If you start selling, then I will move the price downwards in accordance to my best guess as to the size of your flow. If I see serial sell orders, I will move the price subsequently lower on the evidence. I am pricing your liquidity correctly. Thus, if you are a huge hedge fund shorting the market, you face higher transaction costs because the liquidity you are demanding of the market is high, and the market maker can no longer offset your liquidity cost against ripping off smaller investors who will be stopped. This latter is the key point. In fact, for smaller investors, HFT means bid offers are much tighter. If you put a small order through the market you are instaneously filled almost at mid, thanks to HFT, whereas in the old days, retail would pay the same bid/offer for his tiny flow as huge hedge fund. The converse is true for buy orders, obviously.
Have you wondered why HFT is most hated by large institutional funds? It's because suddenly they have to pay a fair price for their huge liquidity requirements.
HFT has short-circuited the old game where large influential funds obtained tight bid offer at the expense of smaller players, and were thus able to dominate markets by trading size at unrealistically tight prices. Now we all pay for our liquidity at a fair price. It's actually really democratic (keeping in mind that competition is mega-fierce).
Ultimately, those who accuse HFT of front running are 100% correct. But there is always "statistical" front running (autocorrelation remember), HFT or Human. The difference now with HFT is that the cost of this front running is proportional to the size of your flow, and thus for smaller/retail investors it is neglibeable (because pricing is now much tigher than under the old "human" regime), and therefore positive, but for the spoiled insitutional investors / hedge funds, used to being privileged, it is back to a level playing field. Need to sell a yard? Need to pay for that buddy. Not good for them.
(obviously I am schematizing to a certain degree. Even humans price large orders wider. It's just they didn't price those large orders anything like wide enough. They sponsored the big client for the info advantage thus earned, info advantage wielded against the rest of the market: read smaller, and/or less in the know, investors).