News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by andymoe on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:38PM (#9822200)
I don't think the operating system to connect the worlds drones is going to be closed source. 3DR and their open source base is going to give Airware a run for their money as the de facto standard "operating system for drones" in the consumer and more and more in the commercial space.

In the meantime people like Drone Deploy and Skycatch will fill the gap when it comes to data collection and processing which is where the real business is long term. Drones themselves will continue to become a commodity. Also, it's worth remembering that a Chinese company, DJI, has about 80Pct market share in the US for consumer and prosumer drones. Lots of competition for everyone.

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by freeqaz on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:58PM (#9822296)
3DR's software doesn't compete in the commercial space. It's a hobbyist platform and it will be much harder to certify by the FAA or other agencies. That is a huge portion of being successful in the space. Especially when you're doing things that have more risk, like photographing electrical infrastructure in a densely populated region. The FAA is going to be the agency that determines if you can do that, and the companies that has that advantage will win the space.
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by kenrikm on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:06PM (#9822785)
There is no reason why it would be any more difficult to certify then Airware. The 3DR stuff is already more then capable todo the task and 3DR sells in the commercial space. Source: I've personally done multiple long range (many miles) autonomous missions and landed within 3ft of the target landing zone, I have hundreds of hours of flight time with many different platforms (Naze32, APM, Pixhawk, DJI).
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by chatmasta on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:51PM (#9822951)
Maybe a stupid question, but how exactly do you "personally" do "autonomous" missions? Isn't it a one-or-the-other sort of thing?
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by kenrikm on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:56PM (#9822962)
If drones could build themselves, program themselves charge themselves etc.. then maybe it would be one or the other. For the time being someone needs to do those things so while it might be autonomous as far as flying goes there is still much human interaction to be had.
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by andymoe on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:17PM (#9822384)
Maybe it will be difficult to fully certify in the way you are thinking but the definition of "Commercial" is certainly going to be changing as rules for drones under 55lbs are finalized in the US as they already have been elsewhere. I think the space Airware will be able to compete successfully in with their current strategy will shrink as those rules get formalized and "hobbyist" platforms are used to do more and more real work. (Not that I don't wish them the best of luck - there are great folks over at Airware.)
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by apapli on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:02PM (#9822315)
it's just a matter of time before the open source platforms add in the features required for FAA etc approvals.

All the other components (aside from flight controllers and chassis) are already OEM hobby items anyway, just photographed and put into a flashy brochure. It's not a big step to FAA approvals, despite the fanfare this seems to attract.

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by erkkie on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:54AM (#9823953)
What do you mean by "hobbyist"? 3DR itself has commercial operations as well, not to mention the countless users of the components in various industries.

Certification will come from companies using the off-the-shelf components. Most likely privately.

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by monomyth on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:30PM (#9822432)
Are you implying that 3DR drones use a different software?
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by apapli on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:58PM (#9822301)
Agree. And a standard is already emerging for quadcopters with OpenPilot's CC3D platform. That's already pretty solid and has a very healthy release rate / dev community around it.
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by foobarqux on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:33PM (#9822441)
I think Airware is going to pull a Meeraki and transition to focusing on the management portion of a solution.
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by Htsthbjig on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:10AM (#9824232)
I have more than 20 drones of different sizes, some of them are big.

I am never going to buy a drone that is not mine(closed source) when I could buy machines that are totally under my control.

Being closed source means the NSA could easily snoop what I do at every moment, in Europe, send the GPS coordinates, the telemetry, pictures and videos all the time without my consent.

US companies are becoming increasingly spies of the US gobertment all around the world, specially people that worked closely with Uncle Sam, like those guys from Airware.

I don't see Chinese or European companies buying into this, when they can tailor open source into their specific needs. We already do that, so it is not that complex thing to do.

I see this article as PR.

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by amelius on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:31PM (#9822167)
It sounds like vaporware :)
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by sjtrny on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:16PM (#9822379)
It is just a pr piece.
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by evilolive on Friday July 10, 2015 @12:25PM (#9864918)
It is definitely PR. Airware has invested a lot more into doing its own hardware, its own possibly certifiable low level code than doing exciting things (sense & avoid etc). Heck, no amount of money will let you write a single line of code on their OS for drones currently.

But is the PR going to work ? It seems easy enough to deter the "serious guys" doing some "serious commercial inspection" from using 3dr. The same way people use cisco equipment on their network because they're told that's what you do if you want peace of mind.

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by stefanix on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:52AM (#9824370)
"That kind of stovepipe way of doing things isn't going to scale,"

It's amazing how many times this argument is made by proprietary systems people. In their world the web should have never happened.

The only chance they have is to use lots of VC money on certification bs that tries to lock out open source projects.

I smell PR as well.

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by slavik81 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:52PM (#9822274)
Good luck. There's so much diversity in the equipment, payloads and use cases for these systems that it's incredibly difficult to standardize. Cutting integration costs has been a dream for many years, but previous standards introduced more complexity than they eliminated.
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by spc476 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:00PM (#9822308)
Go back to the late 70s/early 80s and marvel at the incredible diversity in computers, most with unique operating systems.

Standardiztion will happen eventually.

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by slavik81 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @08:22PM (#9822614)
It's a good point that we've seen this before. I'm under the impression that many early computer standards were essentially de facto standards caused by everyone trying to be compatible with a market leader. e.g. "Unix-like" or "IBM PC compatible". That's probably not the only way, though.

I guess the real question is "how are successful standards created?"

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by dharma1 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @08:28PM (#9822638)
nah. It will be ardupilot (or another open source flight controller) on linux, and because it's on linux, you have access to all the other open source goodies you need for processing, analytics, connectivity etc.

It's already happening - check out http://emlid.com or http://erlerobotics.com for boards you can use with Rpi2 or Beaglebone Black

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by ericd on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:00PM (#9822762)
These look nice for consumer applications, but Big Enterprise Companies typically aren't looking for something thrown together using a RPi, and some of them are going to use a LOT of drones. The hobbyist market doesn't really seem significant compared to the number that will be used by utility, mining, telecom, and other companies with sprawling physical networks of assets.
Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by dharma1 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @09:35PM (#9822902)
The point is not about Rpi, it was just an example. The powerful thing is that it's open source, very active project (check out https://github.com/diydrones/ardupilot), and runs (among other things) on standard Linux distributions. 3DR has received over $40m of funding so far, it is not in any way just a hobbyist platform and is aggressively going after industry verticals like farming.

They manufacture and sell their own drones but there is also a growing number of other manufacturers building drones using ardupilot.

That's not to say that Airware won't have customers, since drones in general are a fast growing sector and there's plenty of room for different businesses. But I doubt it will be the de facto operating system for drones

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by ObviousScience on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:19AM (#9823841)
I'd still expect that we'll see something like a real time OS microkernel written in hardened C or Ada/Spark or kin with a standard suite of drivers to control sensors, motors, etc.

Most of those kind of things get written as open source projects, and then compiled in to specific bundles by middle men who get certified by insurance companies to reliably choose and compile such bundles.

Big companies (eg, Boeing) will naturally still just use the open source microkernel tied together with a few in house drivers, since they have the capacity to deal with software certification themselves.

Really, I wish hobbyist drones would start having more functional co-processors, because I want one where the flight computer and the user land computer... aren't the same core.

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by dharma1 on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:51AM (#9824364)
normal linux kernel runs fine for realtime tasks when compiled with prempt rt flag - https://wiki.dronecode.org/_media/elc01.dronecode_and_ardupi... and it's possible to do very intesive computation on the computer running the flight controller - Andrew does a demo where he flies while compiling the linux kernel on the same computer at the same time, no glitches :)

And if you want a co-computer, it's quite easy - use any board you like, for instance Nvidia Jetson which has tons of GPU cores for paraller processing, and just talk to the flight controller via mavlink over ethernet

Re:Can Airware be the operating system to connect the world'... by ObviousScience on Friday July 03, 2015 @02:12PM (#9827061)
> it's possible to do very intesive computation on the computer running the flight controller - Andrew does a demo where he flies while compiling the linux kernel on the same computer at the same time, no glitches

My point is that it's incredibly dangerous to build this as our default security model in drones, because while it's certainly the case that the flight controller has the raw processing power and if our security worked perfectly, it wouldn't be a problem we live in the real world and errors in userland execution shouldn't be able to break the control loop and send heavy toppling down on your head.

Just because you're probably smart enough to do your taxes while you drive doesn't mean it's not safer if you focused on the road.

> And if you want a co-computer, it's quite easy - use any board you like, for instance Nvidia Jetson which has tons of GPU cores for paraller processing, and just talk to the flight controller via mavlink over ethernet

Yes, I expect that the model we'll see for consumer drones is something like a Kepler embedded module running userland, with a second, standalone ARM core running the flight controller (with the flight controller exposed as a device in userland, but talked to as a server on the wire).

Probably with some kind of hardened RTOS on the flight controller, and Linux running userland OS.

This has the benefit that controlling the drone is no different than lots of other devices we control, we can work in our usual operating system, and we get to perform a sanity check between userland and flight control execution.