News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by ourmandave on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @07:12AM (#9804320)
One reason they're retiring the A-10 is wiring. It's inadequate for all the electronics they want to upgrade and to expensive to replace because the design is so tight you'd have to gut the plane.

I imagine the option of having a microwaved Hot Pocket on a long mission without blowing the fuses would be nice.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by mcv on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @07:26AM (#9804372)
So build a replacement for the A-10. If the idea is good, but the version from the 1970s is woefully out of date, then design something that does exactly that, but better.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by jambox888 on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @08:05AM (#9804569)
I was under the impression that the A-10 is fine for Afghanistan but useless anywhere there is good air defence - just too slow. That said it could be useful for blunting an armoured vanguard.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by cbd1984 on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @08:29AM (#9804684)
Who are we fighting who has a good air defense?

Also, who are we fighting who would have a good air defense the second week of the conflict?

(Don't say China. China has replaced Confucianism with Waltonism, as in Sam.)

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @10:09AM (#9805289)
The main problem for the A-10 is widely available, effective MANPADS. I'm not sure what you can do to immunize your attack aircraft from them, but I am pretty sure that the F-35 isn't the answer.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by dragonwriter on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @12:36PM (#9806496)
> I'm not sure what you can do to immunize your attack aircraft from them

You can't. What you can do, is make attack aircraft more numerous, cheaper, and more expendable -- which almost certainly means unmanned. Manned combat aircraft are becoming dinosaurs for much the same reasons as battleships did.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @01:06PM (#9806790)
Can't disagree with any of that.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by cc438 on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @12:55PM (#9806671)
MANPADS are an issue but the A-10 was designed with their deployment in mind. The most important feature of a MANPAD system is it's ability to be carried by 1-2 soldiers. That places an upper bound on the weight of a system which limits the size of the missile's warhead.

Most MANPADS have warheads weighing less than 5kg, a few kg of HE is enough to cause significant damage but the A-10 was built to fly with half a wing, one engine, one rudder/elevator assembly, and a mountain of shrapnel stuck in the pilot's armored tub. MANPADS will get a mission kill on an A-10 but they aren't powerful enough to bring one down the majority of the time.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by mcv on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @11:20AM (#9805883)
Stealth unfortunately does not make the plane invisible, just harder to detect by radar. But for CAS missions, you're going to be seen anyway, so stealth is useless there.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @11:38AM (#9806047)
I agree. I think the F-35-can-do-CAS people contend that the F-35 can do CAS from altitude (above MANPADS range) with smart-munitions, but I doubt these claims for a number of reasons including availability/sortie-rate, ie cost per sortie, mission turnaround time, etc.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by dragonwriter on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @01:03PM (#9806757)
> I think the F-35-can-do-CAS people contend that the F-35 can do CAS from altitude (above MANPADS range) with smart-munitions,

Stand-off attack with smart munitions is a different role than CAS; so this isn't so much F-35-can-do-CAS as F-35-is-sufficient-because-CAS-is-not-necessary.

EDIT: to be clear, I am characterizing the position here, not endorsing it.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @01:15PM (#9806844)
> F-35-is-sufficient-because-CAS-is-not-necessary.

It's been said before, turned out to be untrue before, and I see no reason to believe it this time. Until someone finds me some credible infantrymen who say that CAS isn't needed, I will not support putting boots on the ground without a strong CAS game.

EDIT: re: EDIT: Fair enough! Don't worry, I haven't downvoted you or anything like that. As far as that position, I feel like it is maybe not the most honest one from some folks since the F-35 has been touted by some as a platform with which to do CAS.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by graycat on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @11:09AM (#9805801)
> immunize your attack aircraft from them

Stealth?

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @11:27AM (#9805957)
Does "stealth" mean anything in close visual range? Can you do close air support from afar? I don't think you can.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by graycat on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @02:25PM (#9807388)
I was responding to "MANPADS", etc. Such a device will need detectors of some kind, e.g., heat, radar, and the usual approaches to stealth should help.

For close air support, maybe the US wants to use fast, stealth aircraft firing missiles to spots specified with laser designators, GPS, etc.

As I recall, at times the USAF claimed that to kill tanks an F-16 with a missile was better than the A-10: Sure, the gun on the A-10 is amazing, but the A-10 flies low and slow and should be vulnerable to, say, MANPADS. The F-16 flies higher and faster, fires a missile, and then is out'a there.

Maybe the USAF wants the F-35 to be better, still: Use stealth.

Sure, maybe soon the USAF will want its missiles to kill tanks, etc. fired from drones, maybe even stealth drones.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @02:49PM (#9807589)
Not aware of any MANPADS that can use radar. AFAIK they all use heat seekers. Not much you can do other than deploy flares. Stealth doesn't help you in close visible range.

>For close air support, maybe the US wants to use fast, stealth aircraft firing missiles to spots specified with laser designators, GPS, etc.

Yeah, the Air Force always says that, and the ground troops always demand A-10's Apaches, etc.

>As I recall, at times the USAF claimed that to kill tanks an F-16 with a missile was better than the A-10: Sure, the gun on the A-10 is amazing, but the A-10 flies low and slow and should be vulnerable to, say, MANPADS. The F-16 flies higher and faster, fires a missile, and then is out'a there.

The Air Force always claims that they have a good reason to get rid of the A-10.

The fart-gun while awesome, isn't the real reason troops love it so much. The ability to loiter on station for a long time and keep enemy forces down in defensive mode is. Neither fast-movers, nor helicopters can loiter as long.

>Maybe the USAF wants the F-35 to be better, still: Use stealth.

Stealth isn't a panacea, it's a buff against the enemy's radar. And, yeah, drones/unmanned are the future.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by graycat on Wednesday July 01, 2015 @12:13AM (#9810035)
I mentioned both radar and heat. If MANPADS are heat seekers, okay.

Some versions of stealh try to lower their heat signatures, e.g., hide the jet engine output from the ground by an extension of the part of the plane below the engine and mixing the jet exhaust with cool air. For the F-117, can get a little view of its engine output at

http://aviation-design.fr/images/jets/rc-jet-model-f-117/lar...

Looks like they tried to hide the exhaust heat.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by jmccree on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @12:56PM (#9806676)
Close in CAS means close in proximity to friendly troops. Before smart munitions this required the aircraft to also be in close proximity to hit the enemy force without hitting friendlies. Now an orbiting bomber or drone can deliver a targeted strike while flying high in the sky miles away.

I love the old warthog, but in the days of drones, I can't see much of a use anymore.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @01:05PM (#9806773)
I think we'll have the Warthog until after the ground troops are confident with the drones / remotely piloted craft. That opinion is less to do with my own ideas about the potential of drones to do CAS well, and more to do with my assessment of what military decision makers will tolerate in terms of change.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by threeseed on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @09:10AM (#9804896)
Why not China ?

They will absolutely defend themselves militarily over the dispute in the South China Sea or Taiwan.

They are quite keen to start a skirmish with their neighbours to assert their authority and dominance over the region.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by cbd1984 on Wednesday July 01, 2015 @12:52AM (#9810138)
> Why not China ?

They're heavily invested in us, both in terms of bonds and in terms of selling us stuff. Both of that goes away the second they challenge us militarily, and their economy couldn't take it.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by mcv on Wednesday July 01, 2015 @06:44AM (#9811026)
I'm not so sure their economy is still as weak as it once was. My impression is that China really has its shit together, more than any other country. Their economy isn't as big as the US yet, but it's catching up and maturing. I think the time will come when China will insist on dominating its own sphere of influence.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @09:51AM (#9805163)
Yes, that is also true for every other effective ground attack platform. AC-130, Drones, Apaches and other helicopters. The A-10 isn't a fighter, it is for ground attack. Not even the most fervent A-10 fanatics believe that the A-10 is a capable air-to-air fighter; it was never intended to be. So, yes it needs fighters to ensure air superiority so that it can operate. That's not a bug.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by mcv on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @11:21AM (#9805893)
I once heard they're great for hunting helicopters.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by Untit1ed on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @10:23AM (#9805402)
While it's fine for Afghanistan it was designed for a cold-war tank battle. If you don't need to kill tanks or dodge air defences a propeller-powered plane that looks like something out of WW2 is a lot cheaper... and that's what's being developed by a bunch of firms for counter-insurgency.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by tsotha on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @06:01PM (#9808709)
There are already several of those types of aircraft to choose from. My favorite is Embraer's Super Tucano, of which the US is buying 100 for the Afghan government.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by jonathankoren on Saturday July 04, 2015 @04:51PM (#9831577)
Replace "Afghanistan" with "the Fulda Gap" and you have exactly described the A-10's original design criteria.

In a ground support aircraft, slowness is good, because then it can turn over the battlefield. Anyway, the plane can take a huge amount of punishment and still fly.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by Spooky23 on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @08:50AM (#9804773)
We don't deploy aircraft in places with good air defense.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by afarrell on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @09:26AM (#9804993)
The main purpose of a military is the ability to threaten violence. The ability to execute violence is a prerequisite for that.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by threeseed on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @09:15AM (#9804931)
Military purchases aren't just for today's conflicts.

Russia is going to continue to assert themselves against NATO's encroachment into the former USSR countries and China wants to be seen to be their region's unquestioned superpower. Both have a lot of political support internally to demonstrate their military strength.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @09:14AM (#9804924)
That's a strawman. Many of the older airframes in use have seen multiple systems upgrades to modernize them. If "old wiring" is the reason to mothball the A10 (yet again) then why is the B52 fleet being kept in service for a planned 95 year lifetime on the oldest airframes?
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by commandar on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @11:35AM (#9806018)
The A-10C upgrade program seems to fly in the face of that.

Really, the biggest problem with the A-10 right now is that the airframes are getting old, but that's a problem with our entire aircraft inventory. e.g., the F-15 having been grounded multiple times in the past decades because of airframes literally giving out and breaking up in training flights.

The A-10 fleet is supposed to get rewinged to help with this; the USAF signed contracts with Boeing to build the wings before they started actively fighting spending money on anything that isn't the F-35.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by astrodust on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @12:22PM (#9806387)
The A-10 is the exact sort of airplane they need now, so it's absolutely baffling to see people even talking about phasing these out and replacing the with the flying turkey that is the F-35.

As Iraq and Afghanistan proved, you need extremely close range support and sustained fire. The cannon on the A-10 is good enough for the sorts of targets they're dealing with, armor is rare, and it has significantly more mobility than the other best alternative, the AC-130.

What use is the F-35 when it can't linger, has extremely limited bombing capability, and can't strafe when necessary?

The A-10 is an extremely pragmatic solution to a messy problem.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @09:55AM (#9805190)
Where did you read that? I've seen the same criticism repeated in multiple places and I still don't buy it. It appears to me to be another weak justification for why one of the Chair Force's least favorite step-children can't have any toys.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by benihana on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @08:22AM (#9804648)
>because the design is so tight you'd have to gut the plane.

I don't get why that is. The plane was designed in the 70s, when personal computers were the size of closets. Even if it was tight, I can't imagine new tech taking up more space than the old tech did, even if there's more of it.

Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by nickff on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @12:42PM (#9806543)
The new electronic circuits are smaller, but they require more power than their predecessors, there are more of them, and the sensors have placement requirements which conflict with the aircraft's configuration. All of this adds up to having to re-wire the aircraft, do a new layout, and move around a large number of parts.
Re:Test Pilot Admits the F-35 Can’t Dogfight by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @01:27PM (#9806942)
>The new electronic circuits are smaller, but they require more power than their predecessors

That makes no sense at all. It is a nonsensical statement.

>and the sensors have placement requirements which conflict with the aircraft's configuration. All of this adds up to having to re-wire the aircraft, do a new layout, and move around a large number of parts.

Unless what you're really trying to say is that the stuff designed to fit a different specific aircraft can't be directly bolted on to an A-10, then I simply don't find those remarks credible. And if you are trying to say that, then you aren't being reasonable.