The way you've phrased this, there's no surprise that you're converting less users, seeing as how the "conversion" is no longer automatic.
Are you judging a conversion as someone that's paid for at least one month off service?
Are you judging a conversion as someone that's paid for at least one month off service?
Our biggest mistake was getting rid of the CC on the signup. I could write a very similar blog post. Free trial period with a 60 days money back guaranty works the best for us and our users.