Our biggest mistake was getting rid of the CC on the signup. I could write a very similar blog post. Free trial period with a 60 days money back guaranty works the best for us and our users.
Are you judging a conversion as someone that's paid for at least one month off service?
Well, I think you know the river runs both ways, they probably want to filter out people who share that mentality, not judging your views on morality or whatever but it does not support your argument at all. If you are not willing to provide a card up front it means you don't have money to spend right there and then, and those companies probably are more interested in talking to those who have shown they are able to pay if required.
I look at it this way. Let's say I come across Acme Corporation's website. They are selling what appears to be a really cool product. I figure I will give it a try and signup for the free trial and at the same time enter my credit card info. I give it whirl, but in the middle of testing it out I get sidetracked with a phone call or whatever and forget to finish testing. I wasn't impressed enough with the little testing I had completed to go back immediately and after a couple days I completely forget I even signed up. Now 29 days later my credit card gets whacked for a $20 monthly fee. I have two choices at this point. I can file a chargeback, which isn't fair to the company. Or I can eat the cost and cancel immediately, which isn't fair to me.
In my opinion, there is absolutely no reason to demand a credit card upfront for a trial.
*Edited to fix a typo.
Sign up now, give my credit card, and to cancel I have to call a phone number which may or may not work and talk to a person who's entire reason for employment is to make it difficult for me to cancel with no assurance that anything has actually been cancelled until the next billing cycle.
When I take over the world, it will be a law on pain of summary execution that any recurring billing which can be signed up for online must be cancellable online :/
The card requirement is a great way to filter out the less serious ones, if we miss one exception like yourself, it's no biggie, there's always someone who need the solution and willing to pay for it.
The only reason where I'd be reluctant to do a card trial is if it was difficult to cancel or they didn't offer a refund if I accidentally forget.
Plenty of shady people using fake cards to sign up for trial as well.
If someone was selling you a phone at a flea market, would you give them your CC number before you knew the phone turned on?
FWIW, I personally refuse to do business with companies that utilize this kind of flow - it feels like a scummy dark pattern, where they're banking on people to forget they've signed up and they can get at least one month's worth of charge out of it. That goes double when you can sign up online but it requires calling in (and talking to "retention" people) to cancel.
"But we don't want to interrupt your service.." goes the salesman.. yeah right.
If you're going the free trial route, fine, but it should require affirmative action after the trial to begin billing. You don't need my credit card until I've actually bought something from you.