That's nonsense. jlouis challenged us to "Take the fastest webserver written for Java and for Erlang", not the slowest ones. And that's exactly what the TechEmpower benchmarks do and they give Java a ~500% advantage.
As for codesize, if you don't like netty then the very next ranked result is servlet3-cass which delivers nearly the same performance -- again, approx 5X faster than the fastest Erlang impl -- in just a few lines of code. Surely you were aware of this when you wrote that comment.
Again if you or anyone can prove a significant GC impact serving up text or Json definitely hit up the techempower folks and make a case for extending the test length. It might help improve Erlang's standing which right now utterly sucks in comparison to Java performance (probably because of the maturity of the JVM).
However it's worth nothing the test only runs for 15 seconds. It might be an interesting addition to run it for 10 minutes and measure 99.9% latency, as jlouis proposes, and prove one of you correct.
https://www.techempower.com/benchmarks/#section=data-r10&hw=...