News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by SwellJoe on Saturday June 27, 2015 @12:51AM (#9789164)
I find it disheartening how much people trash talk Perl, while other languages that are extremely similar (JavaScript, Python, Ruby all share much more with Perl than they do with, say, Haskell or Go or ML), get a pass. It's become trendy to do so, to the point where people who clearly have never learned Perl or worked with it feel entitled to speak with authority on it. Taking it to the point of dismissing anything Perl's creator has ever said (as one of the commenters on this wiki page does) is absurd and means not listening to an extremely bright technologist (I mean, c'mon, Larry invented patch, the basis of a tremendous amount of awesome in modern software development!).

There are misfeatures in Perl, certainly, but there are roughly as many misfeatures in JavaScript. It's silly to dismiss it as "awful" when there's so much that is clearly nice about the language for many categories of problem.

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by hangonhn on Saturday June 27, 2015 @02:34AM (#9789326)
I loved Perl when I first learned it. I loved it for the same reason I love Python now. It's very easy to express ideas I have in mind without worrying about the details. It's a great prototyping (as in prototyping ideas, not as in the type system) language. It was my introduction to "higher level" languages. That said, Perl suffers from having too many magical operators that makes it hard to reason about a snippet of code. I feel Python strikes the right balance.

Your comparison to Javascript is apt but I think a lot of us also find Javascript to be a bit of a horror. Recently I learned that Javascript doesn't handle modulus on a negative number correctly among other things.

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by adrusi on Saturday June 27, 2015 @03:12AM (#9789371)
Perl suffers from having too many magical operators that makes it hard to reason about a snippet of code.

Certainly a matter of personal preference, but a sprinkling of operators isn't so bad once you're acquainted with the language. Yes it's possible to weave a mess in perl, but most of the time you're just dealing with code that might have a few sigils preceeding an identifier, not ASCII soup.

I'd say the real issue is weak typing (implicit conversions between primitives, using strings for many things where some more specialized data type would have been more appropriate) and variable scope problems. These can lead to hard to locate bugs. Worse is the culture in the perl community of manipulating the VM's internals and generating code at runtime and all kinds of other extremely dynamic behaviors. It's amazing what perl lets you accomplish there, but when some package you got off CPAN does something weird and then something goes wrong, it can get really weird.

Recently I learned that Javascript doesn't handle modulus on a negative number correctly among other things.

That's not really true. Javascript doesn't have a modulus operator, it has a remainder operator, and it is completely valid as a remainder operator. The "%" operator is usually called the modulus operator, but it originated in C where prior to C99 its behavior on signed integers was undefined, and on signed integers modulo and remainder are equivalent. So javascript didn't want undefined behavior so they picked one definition and ran with it, it just so happens that C99 chose the other definition and it stuck.

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by jbert on Saturday June 27, 2015 @05:37AM (#9789622)
I'm interested in the details of the variable scoping problems are. I'd have thought that perl's explicit declaration of lexicals with 'my' was better than "declare at first use" of javascript/python/ruby.

[There's a class of mistake where you typo a variable name which you can make in those languages which gets caught in a language where you have to declare variables.]

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by SwellJoe on Saturday June 27, 2015 @05:48AM (#9789650)
I share your confusion over that assertion. I actually miss Perl's excellent block scope capabilities when working in almost every other similar language. I imagine most other languages have gotten it, by now, but a few years ago when I was using Python for a few years for a client it didn't have block scope and I missed it. A brief googling actually hints that maybe Python still doesn't have block scope, which is pretty weird, so I assume I'm googling wrong.

But, perhaps discussion of scope problems in Perl is just when talking about very old code. Perl had some scope atrocities back in Perl 4 and some weirdness in early Perl 5 days. But, for the past 15 years or so, it's been very predictable and has improved (like the syntactic sugar of "my" declarations in foreach or while expressions).

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by leoc on Saturday June 27, 2015 @09:19AM (#9790045)
I seem to recall that Python not only didn't (doesn't?) have block scope, it tended (tends?) to produce a completely, blithely cryptic error message when the programmer assumes that it does have proper block scope and writes a program that fails as a result. Discovering that was memorable.
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by a_bonobo on Saturday June 27, 2015 @10:29AM (#9790258)
Python 3 has changed the "standard" traceback to be more readable and include more information, maybe that one is more to your liking: http://blog.ionelmc.ro/2014/08/03/the-most-underrated-featur...
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by fanf2 on Sunday June 28, 2015 @06:10PM (#9795310)
One weirdness I encountered recently with nested functions:

  sub a {
    my $v;
    sub b {
      # captures only the first
      # instance of $v
    }
  }
This is because named subroutines are created once and variable captures are resolved at that time. I expected the more normal capture semantics you get with anonymous subs, like

  sub a {
    my $v;
    my $b = sub {
      # a new $b each time
      # captures each $v
    }
  }
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by AdieuToLogic on Monday June 29, 2015 @03:12AM (#9796780)
The lexical scoping rules are precisely what causes this behaviour. The first example defines a nested function which has access to the variables in scope when defined (as you remark).

It's little different than this block defined outside of any function:

  {
  my $v;

  sub b { ... }
  }
Whereas an anonymous function is "defined" each time the enclosing scope is evaluated.

For more info, see: http://www.perlmonks.org/?node_id=389319

HTH

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by jbert on Sunday June 28, 2015 @06:51PM (#9795438)
Thanks - useful point. But, I think that's more of an oddity of nested, named subs than anything else. The usual anonymous subs close as you'd expect (as you say).
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by raiph on Saturday June 27, 2015 @04:20PM (#9791413)
> most of the time you're just dealing with code that might have a few sigils preceeding an identifier

I personally like sigils but, afaict, one can almost eliminate sigils in Perl 6 if one wants to.

Instead of $ sigil on scalar (single item) variables:

    a scalar =$= 42; # uses a fictional feature [1]

    say scalar;
    # 42

    scalar--; # decrement scalar

    scalar.say;
    # 41
Instead of % sigil on dicts (hashes):

    a dict =%= pi, i, e, now;

    say dict;
    # 2.71828182845905 => Instant:1435371876.325275,
    # 3.14159265358979 => 0+1i

    dict<pi>--;

    say dict.invert;
    # Instant:1435371876.325275 => 2.71828182845905
    # -1+1i => 3.14159265358979
Instead of @ on lists (arrays):

    a list =@= 10,20;

    say list >>+>> scalar;
    # 51 61
> I'd say the real issue is weak typing

In Perl 6 everything is (implicitly) nominally typed. One can optionally add explicit nominal type info.

It's certainly not HoTT and it has weaknesses that look unlikely to be addressed this year[2] but it's also one of the most advanced gradual typing implementations in any language.[3]

> implicit conversions between primitives

In Perl 6 conversions are generally explicit. If you name a couple implicit conversions in Perl 5 we could compare with Perl 6 (and, say, Python).

> using strings for many things where some more specialized data type would have been more appropriate

Can you provide an example?

> variable scope problems.

Scope features are very much a Perl 6 strength.

Again, perhaps describe a scenario where it's a weakness in Perl 5 and we can compare with Perl 6 and perhaps other langs?

> manipulating the VM's internals

The "reference" Rakudo Perl 6 compiler is a front-end to the NQP compiler toolchain. The NQP toolchain targets several VMs including the JVM. It does not manipulate the JVM's internals!

(NQP also targets MoarVM[4] but it uses the same principled ways to communicate with MoarVM that it does with the JVM.)

> and generating code at runtime and all kinds of other extremely dynamic behaviors.

Ah yes. Perl 6 has upped the ante on that. It is statically compiled in a lot of ways but it also has very powerful dynamic features, carefully designed. [5]

----

[1] I made up the term 'a'. In reality it's 'constant'. But that name is kinda surprising for the purposes to which I've put it -- the terms it declares aren't very constant! But 'constant' is much longer than 'a' and this sort of declaration is supposed to be harder than using other scopes such as 'my' or 'has'. See http://irclog.perlgeek.de/perl6/2015-06-27#i_10812609 and following for a tiny bit more discussion.

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9771718

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gradual_typing

[4] http://moarvm.org

[5] See this example and my comment about static/dynamic aspects of Perl 6 interop: http://www.reddit.com/r/perl6/comments/399o82/python_matplot...

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by raiph on Saturday June 27, 2015 @03:11PM (#9791211)
> [lang X] doesn't handle [basic math] correctly among other things.

From a recent talk[1], what are x, y, z in the following?

    x       =  7 ÷ 2;
    y       = -7 ÷ 2;
    z       = .1 + .2 - .3

    x    y     z

    3.5  -3.5  0             # human

    3    ?     tiny number   # c89; ? depends on compiler
    3    -4    tiny number   # ruby 
    3    -4    tiny number   # python 2/3    
    3    -3    0             # bc    
    3.5  -3.5  tiny number   # perl5
    3.5  -3.5  0             # perl6
----

It isn't just basic math.

How "long" is the following string?

    ปฏิบัติจริง

    7 characters              # human

    len("ปฏิบัติจริง")    = 33    # python 2
    len("ปฏิบัติจริง")    = 11    # python 3
    "ปฏิบัติจริง".length  = ?     # ruby
(For Ruby, I've found "the core language does not provide a way to count [human perceived characters]". [3] Is that still correct or out of date?)

----

> Perl suffers from having too many magical operators that makes it hard to reason about a snippet of code. I feel Python strikes the right balance.

To quote Larry Wall, "Perl 6 ... has been rethought and rebalanced on every level".[4]

It might be interesting for you to pick a couple Perl 5 operators that you consider too magical; then we could look at the merits and demerits of those ops in Perl 5 and their equivalents in Python and Perl 6.

> It's very easy to express ideas I have in mind without worrying about the details [of Python, now, and Perl, back in the day]

This, of course, has explicitly been a deliberate focus of all the Perls. Part of the point of Perl 6 was to remove the bits in Perl 5 that were problematic (including some "too cute/weird" stuff) and to introduce much nicer higher level abstractions (eg grammars instead of just regexes[5]).

----

I've long encountered vocal folk who underestimate or misunderstand Larry Wall and Perl to an absurd degree. Perl has been focused for over two decades on making it easy to get the right results when doing basic practical things (like integer division and counting characters) and, imo, that ought to be obvious to anyone who looks at the matter carefully.

----

[1] http://www.slideshare.net/Ovid/perl-6-for-mere-mortals and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lpu-3UF_b48

[2] http://www.reddit.com/r/perl/comments/2szv7m/beginner_progra...

[3] http://unicode-programming.readthedocs.org/en/latest/count-c...

[4] http://www.infoworld.com/article/2882300/perl/perl-creator-l...

[5] https://github.com/moritz/json/blob/master/lib/JSON/Tiny/Gra...

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by raiph on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:58PM (#9870847)
Someone just pointed out that I missed a line in the bit about string length:

    "ปฏิบัติจริง".chars   = 7     # Perl 6
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by raiph on Friday July 17, 2015 @09:01PM (#9906188)
And someone else just pointed out that the python line should instead be the two lines:

    3    -4    tiny number   # python 2
    3.5  -3.5  tiny number   # python 3
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by hangonhn on Saturday June 27, 2015 @03:42PM (#9791297)
Wow. This is such a fantastic comment; I am very impressed.

I think my experience with Perl ended at Perl 5 so my comment is a bit dated but the sentiment stayed with me, which I admit is unfair.

I also forgot to give Perl credit for another thing: introduction to regex.

Perl was a great language for me to learn and I should revisit my sentiments about it.

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by raiph on Saturday June 27, 2015 @05:45PM (#9791625)
> I think my experience with Perl [is] a bit dated

In some ways, contemporary Perl 5 (eg this year's 5.22 release) is quite unlike older Perl 5s. For example Moose -- which first arrived in 2005 -- is a powerful and relatively clean OO and "roles" system which has matured in to a huge ecosystem of its own within CPAN. (It was/is a kind of back port of the Perl 6 OO model which itself built upon the notions found in systems such as CLOS.[1])

But my personal focus is Perl 6.

> I also forgot to give Perl credit for another thing: introduction to regex.

Perl 6 unifies "regexes", PEGs, and lexical closures. [2].

> Perl was a great language for me to learn and I should revisit my sentiments about it.

Anyone who joins the freenode IRC channel #perl6 and says hi will be welcomed.[3] If you visit, feel free to paste a link to my comment. :)

----

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Lisp_Object_System

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perl_6_rules

[3] https://kiwiirc.com/client/irc.freenode.net/perl6 (today's log at http://irclog.perlgeek.de/perl6/today)

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by teddyh on Saturday June 27, 2015 @10:56AM (#9790343)
In the 90’s I learned and used C as a general programming language. For lighter tasks, I used shell scripts, sed, and awk, and I came to know them well, and I still use them regularly. I knew then that I needed a better programming language for general programming, and from a distance, I could see that Perl was like shell, sed, and awk all mashed together. I did not want it – it seemed like the entirely wrong direction to go. (Minor or domain-specific languages like PHP was out.) I had heard of Python, but did not try it until I was asked to write a small utility which was just complex enough that a shell script would not suffice; I took the opportunity to learn and use Python (then version 1.5) for it.

I have used Python at every opportunity since, and am happy to use Python 3 everywhere possible.

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by sspiff on Saturday June 27, 2015 @05:39AM (#9789625)
I never used Perl, but I use Ruby where people might have used Perl before. (Small one-off scripts or simple automation stuff)

People often attack the appearance and readability of Perl code ("write-only" code), but lot's of Ruby code I come across has the exact same problem, except that people seem to love adding 4 or 5 extra layers of abstraction on top of that.

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by krylon on Sunday June 28, 2015 @07:58AM (#9793180)
One can write totally incomprehensible code in any language if clean, readable code is not a priority.

And the opposite is true, too, of course. I have seen some fairly messy Python code and some marvelously clean Perl code. And I am fairly certain that over time, some people have written beautiful PHP code and ugly Lisp code.

In my humble experience, it is not so much a property of the programming language as it is of the programmer(s).

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by AdieuToLogic on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @12:01AM (#9802871)
You make an excellent point which, unfortunately, is often not remembered by practitioners of our field (myself included).
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by wmil on Saturday June 27, 2015 @02:40PM (#9791111)
Perl's critical failure is that most CPAN modules expect admin rights and a gcc build environment in order to install correctly.

That killed it on shared hosting and for small projects that may not have a server admin's support.

Also devs are used to having named arguments for their functions. Not supporting that is just silly.

And finally it's difficult to google things like $/, $", $% and $_ when you're confused.

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by justinator on Saturday June 27, 2015 @03:20PM (#9791239)
> Perl's critical failure is that most CPAN modules expect

> admin rights and a gcc build environment in order to

> install correctly.

> That killed it on shared hosting and for small projects

> that may not have a server admin's support.

I install Perl apps on shared hosts all the time. The great majority I work on are cPanel-powered. They have a CPAN module installer right from within the cPanel.

Compiler support is an option, and is usually enabled by default. If it's not, it's easy enough to enable that in WHM (the cPanel for cPanel accounts basically)

cPanel is available on hosts like Bluehost, Hostmonster, (dog help us) GoDaddy. Most hosts that built their own control panel for hosting accounts have thus moved to cPanel. cPanel, no surprise, is a Perl shop themselves.

So, the 800lb gorilla of shared hosting control panels presently does what you say you can't.

I also ship Perl apps that specifically do not require outside CPAN Perl modules that require compilation, but have support for features, if they're present. Throw up the .gzip distro, throw up, "install.cgi", chmod 755, and visit the thing in your browser. It wasn't impossible ;)

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by AdieuToLogic on Monday June 29, 2015 @02:04AM (#9796640)
> Perl's critical failure is that most CPAN modules expect admin rights and a gcc build environment in order to install correctly.

See this thread:

http://www.perlmonks.org/?node_id=630026

For how to install CPAN modules in alternate locations. Be sure to note the setting of PERL5LIB to the location you choose when running Perl in order to resolve the modules in the custom location.

> Also devs are used to having named arguments for their functions. Not supporting that is just silly.

There are some idioms available to address this. If you are interested, reply and we'll discuss them :-).

> And finally it's difficult to google things like $/, $", $% and $_ when you're confused.

If you have access to a Unix machine with perl installed, then running:

man perlvar

Will produce a man page enumerating the predefined variables which are difficult to use a search engine to find.

HTH

Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by raiph on Saturday June 27, 2015 @04:52PM (#9791497)
It'll be interesting to c how the radically overhauled module management in Perl 6 pans out.

(They're making sure that installation is practical. For example, NativeCall, for calling C libs, does not require a C compiler.)

> Also devs are used to having named arguments for their functions. Not supporting that is just silly.

The latest Perl 5s have this ("signatures").

Signatures are a central element of Perl 6. (They are way more powerful than in Perl 5, even the latest.)

> it's difficult to google things like $/, $", $% and $_ when you're confused.

Yes.

Fwiw Perl 6 only keeps three of these oddly named variables (removing dozens of others) and they are simple in practice:

    name  concept    formally means the current/latest

    $_    it         topic (Nil or any value/object)
    $!    oh noes!   error (Nil or unthrown exception)
    $/    /regex/    match (Nil or parse tree)
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by cbsmith on Monday June 29, 2015 @02:30PM (#9799943)
I think you have to squint pretty hard to say that JavaScript, Python, or Ruby are "extremely" similar to Perl. It's really its own, bizarre world.
Re:The Three Great Virtues of a Programmer: Laziness, Impati... by ddrum001 on Saturday June 27, 2015 @11:31AM (#9790436)
I suppose those who only write in relatively similar languages like JS, Python, and Ruby start seeing all the tiny differences and miss the entire subset of Lisp languages that offer so much more.