In SF, it's great if you life in the mission, bad if you live in the Richmond. (Actually, there's a good app that works with the cabs there, but before that...)
In Boston, don't live in Dorchester or JP. Calling a cab here is unreliable.
Living in a more sparse city, the only way to get a cab is dispatch. It's terrible.
I one time opened the Uber app in Dorchester. A driver accepted me. I watched him drive around the fens in circles for the next half hour (literally, Park Drive to Fenway to Park Drive to Fenway). So I cancelled the fare. And Uber then charged me a $10 fee because I cancelled more than 5 minutes after the driver accepted.
Don't know what the fuck that was all about, but the one time I tried in Dorchester, Uber was horrid.
Isn't Uber basically dispatch? Or are there extra fees involved? Serious question
Then add the benefit of Uber also working a bit away from those busy downtown streets where just raising your arm is actually enough to get a cab.
Cabs.
I love that this is profitable, and is a job that lots of folk can get. One cabbie I talked to once used to program VAX machines.