So you're suggesting they're correct but can't explain their point of view with basic facts/information/references/logic?
That.. doesn't sound likely.
No, I am not. Let's look at my words again.
"The people who know what they're talking about say it once, coherently and concisely."
I thought that was pretty clear. They can explain their point of view. They explain it coherently and concisely. What about that equates to "can't explain"? Are you measuring correctness by how long someone takes to explain it?
That.. doesn't sound likely.
Of course it doesn't. That's not what I said. Not at all. I genuinely have no idea how you ended up thinking that's what I said, but I'm starting to understand why you're in favour of the loud-mouthed Dunning-Kruger victims.
In my opinion this generalization is only sometimes correct, I have been a personal witness (and participant) in many cases where it most definitely does not hold true.
My experience is the opposite. Very much so. The loud, opinionated fighters tend to be the insecure and inexperienced. The people who know what they're talking about say it once, coherently and concisely. If the company/management routinely listens to the loudmouth, the skilled people drift away to other projects or other employers.
If someone don't care (or doesn't know enough about the subject matter) enough to argue at length for their point of view, why would you listen to anything they have to say?
Maybe because they're correct? I thought you said that was what mattered?