There is a huge problem with the US criminal court system (I personally think it's almost entirely product of ludicrous oversentencing, the product of the 1970s-1980s "war on crime"). But I don't think it's helpful to point fingers at parts of the process that are unrelated to those problems.
I think if we dialed sentences back to reasonable levels, a huge fraction of offenders would be able to plead out to non-custodial sentences, and because their BATNAs would be improved, people facing marginal charges would have a much easier time squaring off against prosecutors who would be much more likely to back down if a trial win was still likely to do little more than produce a probation sentence.
It's worth remembering though: most people incarcerated in the US are not incarcerated for drug crimes. Domestic violence and property crimes appear to dominate US metro incarcerations.
That sounds like a classic false dichotomy. How about less plea bargaining and more resources for the courts so they don't have require massive delays to deliver justice.
I doubt you'd feel the current system was just if you experienced what Browder went through. How about a little empathy.
It's perfectly fair that they get a pass for presenting society's side in a trial but when they get to wield plea bargains for the sole benefit of their own career it's nearly privateering.
The real irony here is before I took the case, the Client tried to waive the proceeding motioning the Court for voluntary departure [1], basically agreeing to pay his own way back to his home country without trial, but ICE objected because they wanted to win at trial and have my Client barred from reentry. The twist is, without an attorney my Client won the trial because by law was clear the underlying crime did not subject my Client to removal proceedings...and of course without any legal justification ICE appealed which is around the time I took the case pro bono...after everything my Client still wanted to just voluntarily leave the Country, forego the appeal just to get the hell out of Krome/detention and even having lost the trial ICE and not much of a chance on appeal, against my advice I motioned again for Voluntary Departure and ICE still objected.
It would seem to be terribly high, if you take the number of people in jail in the USA as an input and you work out the numbers that comes down to 2% of 2.3M which is 46,000 and 8% of 2.3M which is 184,000!
That should have something in it that allows comparisons to be made.
See: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/23/world/americas/23iht-23pri... ("If lists were compiled based on annual admissions to prison per capita, several European countries would outpace the United States.")
What differs is that we keep them there much longer. Cocaine trafficking will get you a few years in Canada in most provinces, versus 5 years minimum in the U.S. and potential 10 or 20 depending on quantity and prior convictions. There is no three strikes law in Canada. In the U.S. many states will give you a life sentence for three violent felonies (in California, even three non-violent felonies).
"Q: How many men and women are in a Canadian prison on a given day? A: In 2010/2011,on a given day 38,219 adults [1] and 16,279 youth (aged 12 to 17 years) [2] were in custody in Canada (federal and provincial), for a total of 54,498 inmates.
2,818 were in custody in British Columbia’s provincial correctional system. [1] 13,758 were in federal custody. [1] In total, just over 24,461 adults were admitted to provincial or territorial jails in 2010/2011. [1]
However there were only 10,916 admissions into provincial or territorial custody to serve a sentence. The difference is accounted for by the number of people held in remand while awaiting their trial or sentencing.[3] "
http://ccphe.ubc.ca/resources/general-information-on-canadia...
That at least answers the question, even though it doesn't agree with what I read earlier.
I'm sorry but you are quoting an article that doesn't give a proper citation for this at all, so please don't rely on these probably woefully underestimated numbers. I'd be happy to have it pointed out to me if I missed their source though, but for now;
What few criminologists? How do they know there are only a few? Did they do a survey or what papers are they basing this on?
This lack of sourcing undermines the rest of your comment, not to mention you imply that the jury trial standard is "90% or lower" when you don't even specify that what you link is related to tax crimes only...
"Moreover, it's unclear to me that you can do much better than 90-95% accuracy."
Again, you basically smushed these numbers in to fit your narrative, and they are not reliable at all, so your entire argument falls flat.
" What would be your rate of false negatives (i.e. where you let a guilty person go)? And how would society react to that?"
In a society that values the principles of law and the rule of law, it is better to let a guilty man go than an innocent one, given that they should be innocent until proven guilty. Unfortunately our society seems less and less inclined to care about the rule of law, so I'm guessing "society" wouldn't give a fuck about a few more guilty people being let free, just like they don't really seem to give a fuck about innocent people being jailed.
Sorry if I'm being to negative, I just really don't understand where you were trying to go with your comment and it's bad statistics. Feel free to elaborate and correct me.
You also misinterpreted the contents of my link. It's on a tax crime blog, but the text is clear that the author is talking about perceptions of the reasonable doubt standard in general ("In a criminal tax prosecution, just as any other criminal prosecution, the Government bears the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.")
> In a society that values the principles of law and the rule of law, it is better to let a guilty man go than an innocent one, given that they should be innocent until proven guilty.
Every heuristic system of decision will have false positives and false negatives. You can ensure zero false positives, but at the cost of 100% false negatives. If you have any criminal justice system, you'll put innocent people in prison. The social debate is just about how many you're willing to put in prison to reduce the false negative rate to a socially acceptable level.
[1] This exchange in the New York Book Review regarding Judge Rakoff's editorial is also worth reading: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2014/dec/18/plea-ba.... It contains letters from Robert Swartz (Aaron Swartz's father), and Judge Michael M. Baylson, as well as a response by Judge Rakoff.
I understand that, and what I am saying is that I don't care if the person who wrote the editorial was a judge or any other person, his numbers aren't cited in any way shape or form and are left to rest completely on his laurels. That's fine for an op-ed, but you then latching onto those numbers, even with a qualifier, still undermines your position on the matter.
"You also misinterpreted the contents of my link."
Indeed, I seem to have focused too much on the tax crime angle, so I'll cede this point, but I still think that the numbers backing your linked blog are dubious, eg;
"In one study of his 10 of his colleagues by Judge Weinstein..."
"In a larger survey of federal judges throughout the country... Of the 171 judges who responded"
"ther attempts at empirical studies of these issues show that judges and suggest that jurors are all over the lot on the issue."
All I am saying is this: Show me the empirical studies and not the hugely biased numbers from some small pool of judges being asked how they rate their average conviction probability.
Sorry for the haste and missteps in my original comment.
Your bias comment also makes no sense. The bias in Judge Rakoff's article, to the extent it exists, is to cite higher than a 2-8% number because he's arguing against guilty pleas. And in the surveys the bias runs in the opposite direction: to make the reasonable doubt standard seem more stringent than it actually is. A judge saying that he only requires 75% probability of guilt to sustain a conviction is contrary to his self-interest.
Underestimated?
They're already huge!
So between 92% and 98% of the time, plea bargaining gets things right. The "beyond a reasonable doubt" jury trial standard is unlikely to be more than 95% and is in practice probably 90% or lower: http://federaltaxcrimes.blogspot.com/2014/09/proof-beyond-re.... So if the 2-8% error rate is correct, it's not clear that plea bargaining leads to more innocent people being convicted than jury trials.
Moreover, it's unclear to me that you can do much better than 90-95% accuracy. Say you set the threshold at 99.9%, only convicting when the proof is overwhelming. What would be your rate of false negatives (i.e. where you let a guilty person go)? And how would society react to that? There's a false negative rate beyond which people will push back on the court system as being too lenient on the accused. You can already see this in areas of the law where proof is difficult. For example, I think the crazy administrative proceedings for rape cases in college campuses arose, in part, because of the difficulty of holding guilty people accountable in the court system.