Also, mortgage is REALLY not the only cost of home ownership. I own a house worth about $200,000. My mortgage payment is about 850/month, my taxes are about 550/month, insurance is 60, and I budget 300/month for maintenance. It would cost me 1600 to rent an equivalent house, so I'm paying more on a monthly basis to own than I would to rent. Some of that is equity, true, which is why we bought. On the other hand, when/if we sell, we'll be paying a realtor $12,000 for the privilege, so we'll have to live here awhile before the equity gains outweigh the transaction costs.
You might not be paying much more than rent.
-------------------------------------------
how old is your house?
how much of your maintenance budget have you actually used?
I'm not sure who you're railing against. Plugging in your numbers to the linked post says you should only rent the Brockwell Dr. house if you can get it for less than $850/mo.
its strikes me that a big issue with renting is the liquidity of the market you're renting in
especially if you have kids, and changing school districts becomes a big deal
all in all, I'd rather not make a 30 year bet on the US residential real estate market with a whole mortgage worth of my net worth
but its seems currently I have to pay a pretty steep premium to make the opposite bet
Buying a house is certainly something of a financial bet and clearly makes you less mobile. On the other hand (barring foreclosure), nobody can force you to move and you have a lot more flexibility in what you do with the property. For most people, as time goes on, the ability to pick up and move to another city without too much thought becomes less important and having more stability in their residence more so.
Outside, LA, SF, DC, NYC, maybe Chicago or Philly where are all these stand alone houses for rent?
serious question
outside of major markets I don't percieve the rental stock of nice, stand alone homes with yards, being paticularly large or liquid
isn't the rent vs own always a bet on the relative size of the rental stock vs available for sale stock?
if I wanted to rent a $250,000 4 bedroom home in somewhere like Westerville, OH, how many options am I really looking at?
---------------------------------------------------
http://www.homes.com/rentals/westerville-oh/?beds=4
looks like there are 4 houses that meet the critera having 4 bedrooms (and Westerville is actually much larger than most suburbs)
951 Brockwell Drive, Westerville OH, 43081 will cost you 2,000 to rent
zillow say the house is worth 231K
if I'm putting down 30K, and taking a 200K mortgage at 4% interest, http://www.mortgagecalculator.org/ says I'll pay $1,194.41 a month
where are all my savings from renting again?
---------------------------------------------------
I'll buy the argument that it makes sense in major cities, especially in markets where flippers drive up the costs
and also for people who would be buying attached properties
I'm not really that impressed with the argument for suburban stand alone properties in flyover country