Re:Why Greet Apple's Swift 2.0 With Open Arms?
by Flimm on Thursday June 18, 2015 @06:09AM
(#9737655)
I think the credo of free software is the developers owe their users free software, not the community at large. It's a subtle distinction.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why Greet Apple's Swift 2.0 With Open Arms?
by anon1385 on Thursday June 18, 2015 @07:21AM
(#9737856)
I'm not sure that is the credo. At least, it's not the credo behind the GPL. Every day I use software that is at least partly GPL code, but I can't access the source code. Why? Because I used a webapp. If the software you use is running on a server rather than your local machine then the GPL says you don't get to have 'freedom'.
So "users" isn't a useful distinction when it comes to Free Software, because the GPL doesn't guarantee freedom for users. It only guarantees freedom for the person who owns and controls the hardware.
Re:Why Greet Apple's Swift 2.0 With Open Arms?
by pron on Thursday June 18, 2015 @07:41AM
(#9737924)
When the GPL was written, this kind of software wasn't very common. Now that it is, the FSP formalized the AGPL, which they recommend over the GPL for server-side software.
Re:Why Greet Apple's Swift 2.0 With Open Arms?
by anon1385 on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:22PM
(#9739642)
Nearly any software is potentially server side software. So really they should recommend AGPL for everything, and relicence all FSF owned projects as AGPL.
They don't because a lot of people even inside the FOSS community are violently opposed to the AGPL. Quite a few people think that it conflicts with Freedom Zero.
Re:Why Greet Apple's Swift 2.0 With Open Arms?
by Flimm on Thursday June 18, 2015 @07:30AM
(#9737883)
Good point. That's more precise summary of their credo and it's narrower than the "community".
Re:Why Greet Apple's Swift 2.0 With Open Arms?
by shiggerino on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:16PM
(#9740136)
There is no meaningful distinction between user and developer. All developers are users, and in cases like this, with compilers, all users are also developers.