IP cameras in my house recording to in-house server = OK
IP cameras uploading data to external "cloud" servers I don't own = do not want
I think the big issue is that people say "oh cool, I can use this with my iPhone" and then just set up their camera, access it on their phone, and call it a day. They never set anything up or log in on their computer so they never see the "please change your password from the default" message you get on first access.
But yeah, a package with one or two IP cameras that work with both wifi and ethernet, a modest NAS already configured with hard drives, and basic security settings in place would be nice. I just wonder how well it would sell since people seem to prefer "pay $200 now and then $10/mo with zero setup" over "pay $500 now and take 20 minutes to set things up".
I believe they encrypt the video (and audio) between the camera and their servers but they deal with the unencrypted 'goods' when they stream it back to you in real time or as a DVR.
You trust them. You can do that.
Why did you need cameras?
I think that the reason its happening, though, is because of a failure of OS producers to solve a couple of problems: one big one is that people just don't like having to maintain a filesystem - and more often than not, don't understand how to do it, either. Another problem is that the OS vendors are asleep at the wheel and have let parties such as Dropbox and so on basically eat their lunch on area's that should really, arguably, have been features of the personal computer operating system world. Peer to peer should be a built-in feature by now. Distributed filesystems which allow full control by the end user: likewise. These should be up-front services of the OS, and not some back-end monstrosity which execution as a market force is leading, directly it seems, to people who just don't care where their data are stored, as long as they can see it now and then themselves ..
I hope we will see some response to this soon - certainly actors like the IPFS group (http://ipfs.io/) have some interesting approaches to the problem. I'd love to see the expectation of built-in, de-centralized, peer-based-filesharing to take off, and we can put and end to all these inter-connected violations of human rights otherwise dressed up as fancy Web 2.0 operations of value ..
Products like this would be great if they could somehow be plugged into a user's existing, personal ecosystem (cf. concept of distributed personal cloud). I'm working towards this but it'll take time before such things are fully baked [1] (and there's also the question of business models).
Until then, we're just going to see more and more devices that require external back ends to operate and our homes/lives will become ever more porous, to (eventually) ever fewer companies.
Otherwise you're committing a very serious offence, especially if you're uploading those images to the internet.
That about covers it really.
I object because turning it on and off by hand would be a real drag, so pretty soon it would be on all the time. I object because I have cats, so motion-based recording will get a lot of cat videos.
I don't want to leave a statistical record of when I am likely to be out of my home. I don't want to have video and sound recordings of my home in a subpoenable format. I don't want Google to record my kids running around the living room naked -- instant child pornography charges. I don't want recordings of consenting adults having sex in the living room late at night. I don't want recordings of people having conversations that they didn't think were being recorded. I don't want my friends to stop visiting.
I don't want my home invaded by Google.
I don't want my home invaded by Google.
But think of the benefits!They can see what you watch on TV and use that to tailer offerings and discounts. They can see what brands you wear. They can see what you read. They can transcribe what you talk about.
All of this is about to immensely improve their ability to offer you relevant brands and services. Yay!
I have this slightly panicky feeling that my perception of what's acceptable sharing of private data is so disconnected from current popular sentiment that I'm becoming a bitter outsider.
I'm sure it's technically well executed as expected from Google management but I do hope it bombs as a product for (to me) obvious reasons.