Re:Show HN: Minimalist Object Storage Project
by y4m4b4 on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:37PM
(#9735092)
We are in an early stage, we will have a distributed version by end of this year.
It isn't about "YAS3I". It isn't compatible just for the compatibility sake.
Minio implementation is opinionated: "There is only one way to do it". Given a choice between Amazon S3 and OpenStack SwiftAPI compatibility, we picked Amazon S3. As SwiftAPI gains adoption, we may switch over to SwiftAPI, but will have to drop S3 then. Let the community decide.
Re:Show HN: Minimalist Object Storage Project
by jhundal on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @05:47PM
(#9735518)
From working at an Openstack startup for a while, I can say that customers definitely prefer the S3 API since it works with their existing tools. That being said, they are largely compatible until you get into the authorization models, and the fact that S3 is globally namespaced, whereas Swift scopes names to tenants.
Cheap, Multi-Datacenter, Performant, Highly Available storage.
"YAS3I" / Yet-Another-S3-Implementation isn't really compelling even if it is open source.
I can pull that out of https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Swift/APIFeatureComparison#A...
if I really need that.