News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by hueving on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:09PM (#9734014)
So what does unlimited mean then in your definition? Even before they throttle, you will be limited by the throughput of the cell tower.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by revscat on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:18PM (#9734097)
Interesting question.

"Unlimited: Wherein the amount of bandwidth, measured by megabits/s up/down, will not be artificially affected. While system outages or other technical limitations can at times affect throughput, at no point will AT&T or its subsidiaries place constraints upon throughput based upon the amount of data transferred over the course of one or more billing periods."

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by derefr on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:36PM (#9734275)
Would an ISP still be able to call their service "unlimited", by this definition, if some of their distribution nodes (cable optical nodes, wireless cell towers, whatever) are oversubscribed+saturated to the point of degraded service for the customers on that node?

If they could, then would they still be able to call the service "unlimited" if they enforced moment-by-moment QoS at the distribution node (so your neighbour's download will slow down to allow you to Skype, as if you were both connected through the same router in a building)?

And if that is allowed, then what is the difference if they're doing the QoSing by long-time-window statistical aggregation rather than packet-by-packet prioritization?

Decreasing the bandwidth available to a given link that has reached some monthly "quota" on a given oversubscribed node†, has exactly the same incentives as decreasing the bandwidth available to a given link for as long as someone else is trying to saturate the pipe with higher-priority traffic.

Either method disincentivizes everyone on the link from "wasting" their bandwidth unnecessarily (in a "you don't want your neighbour to do X, so you stop doing X and hope that they have empathy" way), such that the link becomes less saturated on a long-term basis. But only one is ever highlighted by the news as explicitly breaking the promise of "unlimited." Why is this?

---

† (...where that quota is the area-under-the-curve of the router's upstream bandwidth, divided by the number of users attached to the distribution point—in other words, the user's ration of the distribution node's available transit. If the quota is an arbitrary fixed number that isn't anywhere near this number, then that's just price-gouging.)

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by georgerobinson on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:41PM (#9734328)
I would think so. Let's use "unlimited" in the context of public transport. You have paid for a Travelcard on the London Underground Zones 1 to 6, including peak hours. If there is congestion on the line, or it's a busy rush hour morning is your Travelcard no longer "unlimited"? I mean you're not paying an SLA in which you're guaranteed a seat and that trains will be delayed no longer then X minutes. I'm not defending AT&T in the slightest, but I think "unlimited usage", "100% availability" and "100% link rate" are not the same.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by derefr on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:56PM (#9734426)
I would almost say that an oversubscribed+QoSed line is the modern definition of "residential service", while guaranteed bandwidth (equivalent in effect, but not necessarily in implementation, to the "dedicated circuits" of DSL terminology) is the modern definition of "business service."
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by revelation on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:57PM (#9734431)
So many people here obsessed with making some kind of technical disambiguation. I don't think the lawyers care for that at all.

Both intentionally throttling and not remotely providing the necessary infrastructure necessary to support use will get you into hot waters.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by derefr on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:06PM (#9734476)
My question was more:

If an ISP usually has enough pipe for everyone on each of their distribution nodes (that is, has no oversubscription—or, more practically, only oversubscription for aggregations of customers with statistically-predictable usage such that the node should reasonably never be saturated, with some extra engineering tolerance for the rare occasions usage goes above statistical norms)—

but the ISP sometimes falls short when the introduction of a new service like VoIP or Netflix or Steam into the market, or lots of new denser construction in an area, makes demand outstrip their supply,

then should they get in trouble for enforcing QoSing (through whatever means) on their distribution nodes, temporarily, while they work on upgrading those nodes?

Because, if so, then ISPs should probably never use the word "unlimited" at all because they would still get in trouble for reasons (almost) completely out of their control.

(I say "almost" because they could just refuse to sell service in oversubscribed areas. But customers would like that even less, if the ISP has a local monopoly. Alternately, ISPs could change to "dynamic billing" where everyone in an oversubscribed area gets billed for non-unlimited service for as long as they're oversubscribed, and then goes back to being billed for unlimited service once the oversubscription is over. This would be cool, but seems like one of those nearly-impossible-with-the-hardware-we've-got sort of things, especially for wireless ISPs where you don't stay on the same distribution node so you're constantly moving between oversubscribed and undersubscribed nodes.)

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by developer1 on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:44AM (#9736883)
If the technology cannot provide unlimited for customers who have paid for it, then unlimited service should not be sold. Simple as that. Anything else is inexcusable. If the technology stack can only handle all customers at 250 kBps, then that is the maximum service they should be selling.

"We can handle 20% of users at 5 Mbps, and the other 80% at 250 kBps. So we'll sell the 5 Mbps. But we won't restrict sales to 20% of customers, we'll sell to as many as want it and then throttle to handle overloads on the system." There is no way to make this situation acceptable. Don't sell what you can't provide. Pretty fucking simple.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by rnovak on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @09:38PM (#9736285)
but AT&T isn't in trouble for enforcing QoS, they're in trouble for throttling connections down to dial-up speed after a usage cap.

Even when read in the most beneficial light, no way can the word "unlimited" be interpreted to mean such a thing.

But the FCC Specifically said that companies have the right to employ reasonable network management. 56Kbit/s on the same network others are getting 30Mbit/s is not reasonable by anyone's stretch of the imagination.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by gregwtmtno on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:18PM (#9734952)
"Would an ISP still be able to call their service "unlimited", by this definition, if some of their distribution nodes (cable optical nodes, wireless cell towers, whatever) are oversubscribed+saturated to the point of degraded service for the customers on that node?"

I actually complained to the FCC about this very issue. Where my office is, I can see the service degradation progress over the course of the day, peaking around 2PM when everyone's in the office. Should ATT really be allowed to advertise that they provide LTE service here, when every weekday the service provided is much, much slower, if usable at all?

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:20PM (#9734971)
What does it mean to sell wireless service 'where my office is'? Presumably you could drive somewhere inside their geographic service area and continue to get service. After all, its wireless.

Every service will be limited by local congestion. I'm not sure where this could be going? I get unlimited water from my local water company; but of course the pipes and the number of faucets at my house are practical limits.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by gregwtmtno on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @10:16PM (#9736444)
If there's too much congestion to provide LTE speeds in a certain area, they shouldn't be able to advertise LTE speeds in that area. Or they should build more capacity to manage the congestion.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @11:00PM (#9736613)
Maybe an office building is a little narrow for an 'area'?
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by gregwtmtno on Thursday June 18, 2015 @09:29AM (#9738362)
I'm talking about the entire neighborhood. (Manhattan's Financial District)
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by yellowapple on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:01PM (#9734838)
> Would an ISP still be able to call their service "unlimited", by this definition, if some of their distribution nodes (cable optical nodes, wireless cell towers, whatever) are oversubscribed+saturated to the point of degraded service for the customers on that node?

That definition specifies "artificial" limits, which would - I'd think - exclude technological limitations like oversubscription/saturation.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by maxerickson on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:05PM (#9734878)
Oversubscription is intentional (and in many scenarios can enable lower prices).

I doubt rules about advertising are going to change the market, the problem is that tens of millions of people are happy to pay for connectivity without really sweating the details of it.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by nathanlied on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @06:19PM (#9735659)
Rules about advertising could just end up like it did in Portugal. ISPs were advertising unlimited data (on fiber/cable), but the small print stated that there was a limit, which was dependent on congestion/etc.

Essentially, in any given month, you could get throttled/yelled at for going over an arbitrary data cap, which could (and did) vary every month. Given, it was usually above 1 TB, but it was still there.

ISPs got a book thrown at them by the FCC equivalent, saying that if they advertise their product as unlimited, it must be truly unlimited. Literally the next day that decision came out, all ISPs changed their adverts from unlimited to "at will" data caps, which essentially conveys the same marketing message, but isn't a regulated term.

Welcome to the new world, same as the old world, except where we've replaced a word.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by spacehome on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:10AM (#9737075)
Yea, but that's a better world to live in, because people know what "unlimited" means and will glide right over it, thinking they get the speaker's intended message. I want people to see a new unfamiliar term like "at will" and think for 5 seconds about what the heck that actually means. AT&T would have avoided all the fines and public backlash if they had just made up some new term rather than underhandedly and intentionally misleading people.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by mangeletti on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:44PM (#9734346)
Certainly "unlimited plan" doesn't mean "limited to a greater extent than the limited plan".

If AT&T had set the bandwidth rate to match that of their normal 5GB plan, there would be no problems. In fact, I think that would be seen as expected behavior. What they instead did was punish their long-time customers who were grandfathered into a mistake that AT&T made. I signed up for unlimited data in 2008, after the second iPhone was out, so it's not like the term "Internet" was suddenly redefined and AT&T was in a new paradigm of mobile Internet access. What really happened is that they got greedy and oversubscribed their network, and they decided to punish us for that.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by msravi on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:23PM (#9734144)
FYI, "unlimited data" != "unlimited throughput". No one's asking for unlimited throughput. What people who signed up thought they were getting was pretty straightforward - unlimited data at the throughput promised. Period.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by nathan_long on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:29PM (#9735030)
> unlimited data at the throughput promised

I'm with you, but I've noticed that ISPs generally state speeds using "up to". Eg, AT&T's lowest U-verse tier gives you "Speeds up to 6Mbps".

Which is exactly the worst guarantee possible. "Don't worry, we certainly won't give you more than 6Mbps!"

Of course, if you pay them more, they'll guarantee not to give you more than 18Mbps.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by bachmeier on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:19PM (#9734108)
For the purposes of this action, it means you can use it as much as you want. AT&T was selling it as unlimited 3G/4G, they were not told the conditions that would result in throttling, and they were not told that they would effectively have an unusable data plan after throttling. My memory may be fuzzy, but this story[1] provides a few more details.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/29/technology/FTC-says-ATT-de...

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by istvan__ on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:18PM (#9734095)
This is not about the speed, more like about the volume of data. They limit you after you reached a limit that should have never reach because it was advertised limitless.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by Aloisius on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:25PM (#9734164)
I would define it as without limits imposed by the company. Limits imposed by nature are fine. I'm not going to complain about unlimited talk time when there are only so many seconds in the month.

I'm even ok with prioritization for congestion control since you're hitting a natural limit of available bandwidth. This is apparently what AT&T is doing now according to Ars Technica.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by biot on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:02PM (#9734458)
Throughput, latency, and so on are natural limitations of consuming bandwidth (internet and RF) which is shared across subscribers. What the FCC took exception to (and rightly so) is that AT&T imposed artificial limitations on subscribers based on their consumption. You can't say that your service has no limits but then go on and impose limits.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by colechristensen on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @02:40PM (#9734304)
When it comes to networking providers wired/wireless/mobile it means speed is invariant with regards to volume.

Network neutrality means speed is invariant with regards to source.

I have mixed feelings about traffic shaping between users and protocols – that is limiting a minority of whales taking an unfair share.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by VLM on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @03:24PM (#9734606)
My daily driver has an unlimited top speed. Rather optimistically according to my xbox and Forza it can top our around 100-110. (Edited to add, Forza seems to imply I can get my car up to 115 or so, then stability control loses it, but theres no hard coded limit).

In the army I drove a pos HMMWV and it has a limiter topping it out at 55 mph from memory. Although if you remove the governor supposedly it rockets along at 75+. My pos would have leaked out all the oil or something before it ever got to 75, but in theory a reliable one can go that fast. The civilian model replaces the 100 HP indestructible engine with a 600 HP consumer engine so those move quite fast.