News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by yellowapple on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:01PM (#9734838)
> Would an ISP still be able to call their service "unlimited", by this definition, if some of their distribution nodes (cable optical nodes, wireless cell towers, whatever) are oversubscribed+saturated to the point of degraded service for the customers on that node?

That definition specifies "artificial" limits, which would - I'd think - exclude technological limitations like oversubscription/saturation.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by maxerickson on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @04:05PM (#9734878)
Oversubscription is intentional (and in many scenarios can enable lower prices).

I doubt rules about advertising are going to change the market, the problem is that tens of millions of people are happy to pay for connectivity without really sweating the details of it.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by nathanlied on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @06:19PM (#9735659)
Rules about advertising could just end up like it did in Portugal. ISPs were advertising unlimited data (on fiber/cable), but the small print stated that there was a limit, which was dependent on congestion/etc.

Essentially, in any given month, you could get throttled/yelled at for going over an arbitrary data cap, which could (and did) vary every month. Given, it was usually above 1 TB, but it was still there.

ISPs got a book thrown at them by the FCC equivalent, saying that if they advertise their product as unlimited, it must be truly unlimited. Literally the next day that decision came out, all ISPs changed their adverts from unlimited to "at will" data caps, which essentially conveys the same marketing message, but isn't a regulated term.

Welcome to the new world, same as the old world, except where we've replaced a word.

Re:AT&T fined $100M after slowing down its ‘unlimited’ data by spacehome on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:10AM (#9737075)
Yea, but that's a better world to live in, because people know what "unlimited" means and will glide right over it, thinking they get the speaker's intended message. I want people to see a new unfamiliar term like "at will" and think for 5 seconds about what the heck that actually means. AT&T would have avoided all the fines and public backlash if they had just made up some new term rather than underhandedly and intentionally misleading people.