News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by cjensen on Monday June 15, 2015 @02:57PM (#9721272)
I'm not seeing a problem here. There is tons of precedent for taking a RSS feed and displaying advertising next to it. Google Reader did it. NetNewsWire did it.

Having an RSS feed implies that you are okay with someone copying what is found in the feed and displaying it to users. Since there is no technical mechanism defined to flag allowable uses, there is presently no way for an RSS author to signal intent or add conditions like "may not be commingled with advertising."

It seems to me that Apple is just providing a heads up to the RSS author what is going to happen, and giving them the chance to opt-out ahead of time. Apple could have done this without asking.

The only weirdness is making it seem like the RSS author has accepted terms unless they respond. That was a poor choice. They should have said "this is how we will run things; to stop us from using your RSS feed, click this link."

Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by brillenfux on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:00PM (#9721286)
Putting out a RSS feed does by no means imply consent to third-party use. The same way like putting out pictures doesn't mean everybody can use them. Christ!
Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by cjensen on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:12PM (#9721359)
There are at least a dozen third-party Feed Aggregators who disagree and feel that consent is given. Why is this only an issue now?
Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by detaro on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:23PM (#9721413)
Because they make it very much sound like they derive obligations of the publisher from it. Which as far as I know other aggregators haven't done without proper sign up.

You will be responsible for any payments that might be due to any contributors or other third parties for the creation and use of your RSS content.

Could potentially be a lot of additional trouble if they get a hold of a feed that wasn't intended to be publicly accessible.

Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by notahacker on Monday June 15, 2015 @04:32PM (#9721885)
If you must create a convenient channel to disseminate material that leaves you commercially exposed when it actually does get shared, it's probably best you don't make it visible to web crawlers.

The only thing Apple is doing differently here to many bots that have boldly gone before is sending a warning message.

Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by payne92 on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:04PM (#9721304)
The indemnification provision is a big problem. It's basically saying that if someone sues Apple, you are obligated to defend Apple.
Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by cjensen on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:09PM (#9721339)
Pretty sure that actually says "if someone makes a claim against your feed, we'll let you know. If you say the claim is bs and indemnify us, we'll keep republishing."

That can be inferred by the fact that indemnification is a subclause of "you can resolve the issue." In other words, it would be only occur as a result of the RSS author's active and intentional actions in responding to a claim. Again, stupid wording though.

Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by Animats on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:28PM (#9721441)
Putting that in an unsolicited email is insane. If someone has an actual copy of that email, with headers, please post it somewhere. Send a copy to the EFF. Send copies to law professors.
Re:I Do Not Agree to Your Terms by skybrian on Monday June 15, 2015 @06:13PM (#9722472)
I don't remember any ads in Google Reader. This question suggests there weren't any:

http://www.quora.com/Why-didnt-Google-put-ads-in-Google-Read...