News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by chlodwig on Monday June 15, 2015 @12:28AM (#9717515)
They missed a theory: fudging the stats and failing to report crimes. Excerpt from an interview with David Simon:

-----

They [the police department in Baltimore] cooked their own books in remarkable ways. Guns disappeared from reports and armed robberies became larcenies. Deadly weapons were omitted from reports and aggravated assaults became common assaults. The Baltimore Sun did a fine job looking into the dramatic drop in rapes in the city. Turned out that regardless of how insistent the victims were that they had been raped, the incidents were being quietly unfounded. That tip of the iceberg was reported, but the rest of it, no. And yet there were many veteran commanders and supervisors who were disgusted, who would privately complain about what was happening. If you weren’t a journalist obliged to quote sources and instead, say, someone writing a fictional television drama, they’d share a beer and let you fill cocktail napkins with all the ways in which felonies disappeared in those years.

https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/04/29/david-simon-on...

---

Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by __z on Monday June 15, 2015 @12:32AM (#9717529)
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/17/upshot/perceptions-havent-...

"These trends aren’t caused by changes in our willingness to report crime to the police. We see an even more significant decline in violent crime in data derived from surveys asking people whether they’ve been the victims of certain crimes over the past year. The National Crime Victimization Survey reports that the rate of violent victimizations has declined by 67 percent since 1993. This reflects a 70 percent decline in rape and sexual assault; a 66 percent decline in robbery; a 77 percent decline in aggravated assault; and a 64 percent decline in simple assault. This survey has nothing to say about the decline in homicide, for obvious reasons."

Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by ZeroGravitas on Monday June 15, 2015 @06:00AM (#9718420)
David Simon says that homicide is the hardest crime stat to fudge, since there's a body and the different rate changes between homicide and other crimes is actually used to try to measure how much the stats are being fudged.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by dredmorbius on Monday June 15, 2015 @08:49AM (#9718958)
Also: the coroner's office is independent of the police and makes the determination of homicide.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by dragonwriter on Monday June 15, 2015 @08:56AM (#9718989)
That's not true in all jurisdictions; I've seen several, e.g., with a sheriff-coroner's office, so that, where the sheriff's office is the applicable law enforcement officer, the coroner is not a separate office.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by dredmorbius on Monday June 15, 2015 @02:45PM (#9721195)
It is true in Baltimore, and Simon specifically references the fact.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by dredmorbius on Monday June 15, 2015 @06:29PM (#9722552)
There's a long treatment of this in Simon's 2008 talk, "The Audacity of Despair". I'd written at length on that earlier:

http://davidsimon.com/portfolio-item/the-audacity-of-despair

https://plus.google.com/u/0/104092656004159577193/posts/CexR...

Simon says:

In this culture, if you want to find out where the dirt is done, parse some statistics. I learned as a reporter to start despising statistics, and to regard anything that was ever cited to me in advance of an argument as dubious just because somebody was pulling it out and using it.

As I got better as a reporter, I realized that as soon as any of our institutions create a means of measuring themselves in terms of quality, someone is running behind them in that institution to figure out a way of destroying that statistic as a meaningful measure of anything.

In education it's No Child Left Behind and standardized test scores. In the police department, it's crime statistics and clearance rates. In the journalism it's Pulizer Prizes.

These stats don't have to do with anything once the people looking to advance themselves and their agenda, and to protect their institution, get done with them.

...

It's not corruption in the sense of somebody thinking "I am here to make Baltimore worse", or "make the retaining walls in New Orleans collapse yet again". It's somebody thinking "I don't want it landing on me, I want my day to be easier than yours, and I want you to think well of me until I get out of this job".

...

You know how you unfound a robbery report? A guy comes in to report a robbery in a place like south-west Baltimore, you say, "are you sure the guy had bullets in the gun? Are you sure? Are you sure it wasn't just a larceny, are you sure he didn't just take your wallet from you? Oh, you're really insisting, he did have a gun, you saw the bullets, it was a real gun? Hold on, we've got to run a warrant check on you. We gotta see if there's any paper on you. You don't have any paper on you? Oh, by the way, door's over there."

Robberies in the south-west district of Baltimore went down 70% in just one year.

When time came to reduce the murder rate, the same trick didn't work -- you can't hide the bodies, and it's the state Health Department which defines murders.

It's a really powerful piece.

Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by Kesty on Monday June 15, 2015 @06:09AM (#9718439)
You can always report an homicide as a suicide.

You will have an increase suicide rate, but it won't effect the criminal rate.

Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by cmdkeen on Monday June 15, 2015 @06:33AM (#9718513)
Except that's a really serious felony far and above other statistics fiddling, Baltimore at its worst didn't go that far - you're making yourself an accessory to murder after the fact. Not only would you have Federal authorities getting interested quickly but you have pesky family members raising queries about how their loved one shot themselves to death 34 times on a street corner.

Even in the darkest days of Baltimore I don't think there were allegations of homicides being declared as suicides.

Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by anthony_d on Monday June 15, 2015 @09:52AM (#9719237)
Just to be pedantic: in it's darkest days the police in Baltimore commit murder. It's naive to think the police would never do something purely because it's really bad.

I will agree that from a practical standpoint it seems far fetched to think they could get away with mislabeling homicides on any significant scale.

Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by CPLX on Monday June 15, 2015 @08:11AM (#9718808)
You can sometimes report a homicide as a suicide. Not very often, given things like the relative unpopularity of multiple gunshot wounds from a moving car as a suicide method, and so on.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by kabouseng on Monday June 15, 2015 @09:40AM (#9719180)
And if the victim has life insurance, reporting a homicide as a suicide has insurance consequences, the family would provide resistance to.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by __z on Monday June 15, 2015 @12:26PM (#9720367)
I have no data for this (other than watching TV) but reporting homicide as suicide is probably more likely due to incompetence rather than malice.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by huxley on Monday June 15, 2015 @08:44AM (#9718937)
David Simon is talking about one particular administration, he later says in the same interview:

"And tellingly, when his successor as mayor allows a new police commissioner to finally de-emphasize street sweeps and mass arrests and instead focus on gun crime, that’s when the murder rate really dives. That’s when violence really goes down. When a drug arrest or a street sweep is suddenly not the standard for police work, when violence itself is directly addressed, that’s when Baltimore makes some progress."

Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by bsbechtel on Monday June 15, 2015 @08:59AM (#9718999)
I've heard of this being done in Chicago as well.
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by Shivetya on Monday June 15, 2015 @11:30AM (#9719946)
Well rape numbers are not as high as they should be, Grady Memorial Hospital in Atlanta isn't reporting them even at times when patients request it, either from misunderstanding new privacy laws in medical records or because of the rules.

http://www.ajc.com/news/news/crime-law/fulton-rapes-go-unrep...

Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by mortenjorck on Monday June 15, 2015 @11:39AM (#9720019)
Chicago Magazine had a big two-part investigative report into a similar pattern in the CPD: http://www.chicagomag.com/Chicago-Magazine/May-2014/Chicago-...
Re:Why did crime plummet in the US? by slipjack on Monday June 15, 2015 @02:25PM (#9721055)
Would you expect that amount of fudging to change over time? Arguing that fudging stats explains the drop in crime requires that you believe in the last 30 years police throughout the country have started undercounting the amount of crime in their areas by increasing amounts year after year.