Re:Banks have never heard of SYN/ACK
by AndrewDucker on Sunday June 14, 2015 @08:16AM
(#9714617)
He doesn't say that the change makes things perfect - he says "There's only one possible failure mode and not two, and that failure mode is the safer one"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_Generals'_Problem
"Because acknowledgement of message receipt can be lost as easily as the original message, a potentially infinite series of messages are required to come to consensus."
What you want isn't really a handshake, it's a commit, and no finite amount of messages will ensure agreement over a lossy network.
Er.....that doesn't appear to solve anything, instead it just pushes the error state down a level; there's still an ambiguous state where #6 is sent and not received.
The client thinks the charge is going to take place, and so thinks the client will be charged, but the bank never gets #6 and so never makes the charge, aka distributed atomic operations are hard.