I like to think that Craigslist isn't free, I just pay for it with my time and attention by flagging the junk that doesn't belong there.
Craig very famously types the command "sweep the leg" (a Karate Kid reference) to remove spam. Maybe it's the same command for small projects based on the service. :-)
You mean the mentality that has created one of the top five websites ever? I mean EVER? ... Oh, that poor Craig, silly idealistic fellow...
If craigslist were solely out to monetize this website, that'd be fine. But they don't. They keep some things free and Craig has made a big deal about making money in the categories that needed a charge to prevent spamming. So there's a disconnect between a guy who wants to fight the "man" and someone who clearly just went out of his way to squash a bunch of little ones.
The correct moves in this situation for a top five website are:
- build the feature yourself. It sucks for the little guy who made his website but your users get the benefits anyway.
- don't build the feature because this feature is trivial and your users don't want it anyway. So this external website languishes and provides no benefit and no harm.
- buy the feature. Buy the company for a little money and implement the feature. The top 5 websites do this all the time. As an added bonus, you can acquire this talent who can create lots of great features for your users.
- hire the guys who made the feature and ask them to build it for you. They'd probably leap at the chance.
- Give the external website your blessing. Invest a little money in them so that if they strike it big you'll benefit.
- Make them pay a data access fee. Charge them per query.
Any of these would have been better options. This would be how a top five company should behave.
1. Craig was having a discussion with Romy that was clearly misleading. The fact that there's been no further communication and pipes have been turned off demonstrates that.
2. All pipes were shut off. Even if you thought that Romy's pipe was commercial, some might not have been. Drowning everything might be easy, but it doesn't seem good.
3. He's on the board of the Wikimedia Foundation and the Sunlight Foundation. These are both great organizations that advocate for openness, transparency, and the sharing of data. These groups would despise an action like this.
Craig has a right to run his business the way he wants to. However, there's a odd level of hypocrisy here and it merits being pointed out.
37signals, another company that seems to have a decent handle on how to get users, also believes that not providing features is part of why their apps work for so many people.
I would guess they are operating under the principle of "If it ain't broke, don't fix it"
I agree with you that money is not the primary motivation, but I think the choice is more complex than simply opting in or out of potential revenue.
There are of course other possible explanations: 4) Craigslist RSS server runs on a Pentium w/ 256MB of memory and can't scale 5) Someone at Yahoo stole Craig's girlfriend so he hates them.
Any others?
I'm also pretty sure they only charge when the community begs for it (apartment listings in major cities, as a barrier to keep out spam) and are legally obligated (escort services, http://www.seattlepi.com/business/386655_craigslist07.html)
I had hoped that the culture might become more developer friendly after Jeremy Zawodny (formerly at Yahoo) joined up. Zawodny even wrote an article about how all this terrific data was available via RSS, but there was no good way to piece it together: http://jeremy.zawodny.com/blog/archives/008513.html
Craig is a programmer and he comes across as a normal, humble sort of guy. We like him and we like his service. I don't understand his obsession with keeping craigslist a) locked in the dark ages for functionality and b) not letting anyone build something that adds useful features. It really starts to make you think. Is he just strange or (if you don't give him the benefit of the doubt like I do) evil?