Really? Places like Something Awful ban for hate speech, and that site has continued existing for a while just fine.
The fact is banning of the worst of the worst makes life better for most of the users, and they're grateful. I can't think of a single community that has suffered overall from banning racists and mysoginists.
What I've seen is those banned people end up going to form their own little secret clubs, and it's just a cesspool of seething hatred. Fine, stay in your corner, means we don't have to deal with it.
The issue wasn't with the subreddit, it's with what it was doing outside the subreddit.
This will die down/blow over in a week or so anyway.
Neckbeard seems to be a very similar level of insult (ie mild and related to appearance) and that is widespread. Actually just calling someone "ugly" seems more offensive than either of these.
Reddit certainly have a legal right to censor whatever they wish on the site but I feel they have a responsibility to the community not to do it in an arbitrary or disproportionate way.
Banning 1 hateful subreddit on an open forum does nothing to solve to issue of someone being called a hambeast, or someone being an asshole in general.
In other words, just because banning /fph won't entirely solve the problem of People Being Assholes doesn't mean it's a bad idea.
https://twitter.com/notch/status/608706518972788736
Reddit just put the world on notice that they are willing to become user babysitters, and historically this has never ended well for the company involved.